Andrew L.
Yelp
The best thing about Cocoro, other than it's superlative staff and the one and only Makoto, is the bright and shiny fresh fish. New Zealand sushi restaurants, inexplicably, do not serve the wide range of fish you'd find in Japan or the U.S., but what Cocoro does serve (maguro, sake, tai, uni, several styles of shrimp, mackerel, crayfish, Bluff oysters, etc.) is excellent. They understand the temperature at which sushi should be served. Their knife and presentation skills are top notch.
I try to go here at least once a month and have become dependent on Makoto and his staff for their generosity of spirit and deep-seated reverence for the joy in Japanese cuisine. It's the type of place -- rare these days -- where you want to get to know the staff and strike up conversations with Makoto about what's fresh and what he recommends. He's good, if you're a regular, at figuring out your tastes, but is always happy to recommend something new.
You definitely lose something from the absence of a bar (the inability to spark up a conversation or ask your itamae about the fish), but the wait staff are well informed and quick to ask Makoto if they don't have an answer. And Makoto, once you get to know him, will be happy to come out and chat with you. He's great, one of my favourite people.
The sake selection is excellent and, again, the wait staff can articulately explain your choices. It's a pricey joint (somebody has to pay for all that fabulous white linen), but you will come out satisfied. I've eaten lunch there for about $45. That bought me 4 pieces of nigiri sushi, 6 pieces of sashimi, and 3 or 4 Bluff oysters. Generally, I spend a lot more because it's all so good and I have to have a bit of it all.
Two for dinner costs $200 if you're liberal in your selection of small dishes and your bill includes beer and sake.
Highly recommended. During dinner, they have a prix fixe menu if you choose the private tables, but you can order whatever you want if you sit at the large centre table designed to accommodate about 15 people.
Some people have remarked that the interior is spartan, but I disagree. The liberal use of wood gives all those straight lines a sense of depth and warmth that makes me feel quite comfortable.