Jason F.
Yelp
I'm saying merci to the quality dishes and service being offered at Cocotte, an intimate French bistro located on Hyde Street in a cross section of both the Russian and Nob Hill neighborhoods of San Francisco. Open for almost ten years now in what was once Hyde Street Bistro, with a few changes to their romantically lit indoor dining room and not one but two new outdoor parklets on Hyde Street, where you literally and both see and hear the Powell-Hyde Cable Car trains turn the corner of nearby Jackson Street rumbling by, Cocotte offers wonderfully plates entrees and a well curated wine list all sold at a decent price point. A friend and I made sure we made a reservation to come here on a cool weekday evening, as the city was commemorating San Francisco Restaurant Week for Fall 2021. In events such as these, local purveyors of food can offer their customers a three-course pre-fix meal at a set price so new diners to their establishment and long-time fans can not only get a real sense of what their menu has to offer, but also a darn good deal. At Cocotte, they were offering one of the pricier meal deals for sixty-five dollars, we got to select from three entrées from their Hors' D'oeuvres section of their menu, three entrées from their Entrée section of their menu, and two from their Dessert section of their menu.
What really had Cocotte on our minds when selecting a restaurant for restaurant week to go to was the fact that they were serving a Soufflé for their first course, and a Beef Wellington for their second course. So my friend and I both ordered their Aged Cheddar Soufflé which was served with an endive salad topped with persimmon, pomegranates, and a tarragon dressing. For my second course, I ordered their Beef Filet Mignon Wellington which was served with a potato gratin, grilled broccolini and topped with a burgundy sauce, while my friend ordered their Day Boat Seared Scallops, which was served on a bed of red Kuri squash puree, parsnip chips and topped with a Vadouvan beurre blanc. And for our dessert it was suggested by our server that we split both dishes that we were offering for this pre-fix meal plan so we gamely ordered their Banana Crème Brulée and their Panna Cotta. To pair with my meal I asked our server what red wine they would recommend to pair with their Filet Mignon Wellington and it was suggested that I pair with a glass of their 2016 Chateau Vieux Potana Lalande De Pomeral sourced from Bordeaux, France, which of course was their highest price red wine at eighteen dollars, while my friend went balls to the walls and ordered the wine pairing with all three pre-fix courses, which was offered during restaurant week for one hundred and five dollars total.
After deciding to sit out on their patio, when we arrived they weren't too busy at all, which allowed us to take in the neighborhood atmosphere and special live music that plays every Thursday evening that was performing in front of the restaurant's bar area. The Cheddar Soufflé was a decent starter, but way too eggy for our tastes so much so that that one flavor overwhelmed the entire dish. My Beef Wellington was a beautifully composed dish, but the meat was slightly overcooked, which made me sad, but the wine pairing really did accentuate every slice of beef, and my friend's scallops were a decent, if somewhat spare dish in terms of quantity of scallops. The real stars of our meal was in fact their dessert, as both were not only plentiful in quantity but overall wonderfully composed desserts that had me savoring each sweet bite. I think a return visit to Cocotte would be appreciated, as their menu is filled with intriguing composed French dishes that represent what dining at a traditional rotisserie would be like on the stone cobbled streets of Paris. The way that their Fig & Goat Cheese Tart and Citrus-Cured Salmon Beignets are described on their main menu have me eager with real aplomb! Cocotte does represent good food sold at decent price points, restaurant week not withstanding, highlighted by an engaging ambience with two accessible outdoor parklets serenaded by live music on occasion, and enhanced with really great customer service, and whether you are a local or tourist in San Francisco, they deserve to be supported.