Comal

Restaurant · Lower East Side

Comal

Restaurant · Lower East Side

5

116 Forsyth St, New York, NY 10002

Photos

Comal by null
Comal by Leo Bieber
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null
Comal by null

Highlights

Inventive Mexican dishes: skewers, mussels, aguachile, chicken  

Placeholder
Placeholder

116 Forsyth St, New York, NY 10002 Get directions

comal-nyc.com

$50–100 · Menu

Information

Static Map

116 Forsyth St, New York, NY 10002 Get directions

+1 646 988 9678
comal-nyc.com

$50–100 · Menu

Features

reservations

Last updated

Sep 22, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

NYC’s New Restaurant Openings - New York - The Infatuation

"Comal is in the old Gem Wine space on the Lower East Side (but not the old, old Gem Wine space now occupied by Ha’s Snack Bar). It’s a small plates restaurant from a chef who used to be at Jupiter, grew up in Mexico and spent time working in London, so you’ll see everything from surf clams with cascabel chiles to sweetbreads with cabbage and pineapple on the menu." - will hartman, willa moore, molly fitzpatrick, sonal shah, bryan kim

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/new-nyc-restaurants-openings
View Postcard for Comal
@eater

Biggest NYC Restaurant Openings in June 2025 | Eater NY

"A 42-seat, Mexico City–inspired restaurant from chef Gaz Herbert (River Cafe, Ikoyi, Jupiter) that embraces a multidisciplinary approach to Mexican cuisine, informed by the chef’s background and aimed at a focused, intimate dining experience." - Melissa McCart

https://ny.eater.com/restaurant-openings/399236/nyc-restaurant-openings-june-12-2025
View Postcard for Comal
@eater

Closed NYC Restaurant Gotham Bar and Grill Building Up for Sale | Eater NY

"Opened this week by Gaz Herbert (formerly executive chef at Jupiter), the restaurant channels Herbert’s British upbringing and Mexican childhood with a menu featuring dishes like lengua al pastor, mussels with corn custard, crispy sweetbread with pineapple and tortilla, and a skate wing guiso. He’s joined in the kitchen by head chef Scott McKay, an Acru and Atomix alum, and the venue occupies the former Gem Wine space." - Emma Orlow

https://ny.eater.com/new-york-restaurant-news/399866/gotham-bar-and-grill-restaurant-nyc-building-sale
View Postcard for Comal
@infatuation

Comal - Review - Chinatown - New York - The Infatuation

"Comal is in the old Gem Wine space on the Lower East Side (but not the old, old Gem Wine space now occupied by Ha’s Snack Bar). It’s a small plates restaurant from a chef who used to work at Jupiter, grew up in Mexico and spent time in London, so you’ll see everything from surf clams with cascabel chiles to sweetbreads with cabbage and pineapple on the menu. We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Will Hartman

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/comal-nyc
View Postcard for Comal
@eater

Comal, a Restaurant Influenced by Mexico City, Will Takeover the Gem Wine Space | Eater NY

"After Flynn McGarry decided not to renew his lease, he passed the keys to Gaz Herbert, the former executive chef at the King team’s follow-up, Jupiter in Midtown; Herbert will open a restaurant in the Lower East Side space at 116 Forsyth Street (between Broome and Delancey). The concept is a fine-dining menu influenced by Mexico City and the global flavors of the city’s current restaurant scene and is slated for a June opening. Herbert, who grew up between Cuernavaca and CDMX and holds both U.K. and Mexican citizenship, says, “It’s a city that I know very well and it’s very close to my heart.” He adds that in his adult life he returns for about a month every year, dating back a decade, and that a recent restaurant-hotel consulting job in Mexico included luring McGarry to come down to Mexico to do a series of dinners at the property. The menu won’t stick strictly to traditional Mexican flavors and will also pull in Herbert’s culinary background, which includes cooking at several restaurants in London such as the River Cafe and Ikoyi. This will be the first restaurant Herbert opens independently; part of the draw to this Forsyth Street location was the turnkey nature of the former Gem Wine space, which had not long ago undergone its own renovation as it pivoted away from its initial tasting-menu roots. The team is working with La Metropolitana, a design studio known for Mexico City restaurant clients like seafood favorite Contramar, to create custom furniture for the LES space, which will seat about 44, and Herbert is working on adding outdoor seating as well. As for drinks, they will pursue a full liquor license; Herbert says cocktails will stray away from “cheesy” and blend elements of Mexican ingredients and spirits with classic New York cocktails." - Emma Orlow

https://ny.eater.com/2025/4/10/24404733/comal-opening-gaz-herbert-gem-wine-forsyth-street-mexican-new-restaurant
View Postcard for Comal

Jeon Kang

Google
wow, the food is really good here. beautiful atmosphere too. not to be missed

T C

Google
Agh I wanted to like this restaurant so much. It is one of the most stunning interiors and the design team has really outdone itself. Overall, the food was okay but given the price point, I wanted to be wowed. My fiance and I ordered the crab uni custard (SO SMALL), okra (delicious and recommended), sea bass (just okay) and chicken in spicy broth (very spicy). Nothing really stood out but I will say the team and staff were incredible. I absolutely loved the ambiance, just wished I loved the food as much!

Joy Wu

Google
One of the most exciting new openings in NYC this summer. Situated at the old gem spot where I spend a lot of wonderful nights, Comal brings such a thoughtful approach to food. The flavors, textural combinations and the dedication to seasonal ingredients truly sets it apart from the “just another wine bar” scene in the city for the past few years. The experience extends beyond the food, Comal showcases such beautiful interior design, handcrafted plate and table wares, painted murals, as well as a rotating art display in collaboration with galleries. Cannot wait for the many nights to come with this special place!

H J

Google
Comal has quickly become one of my favorite spots in the East Village. It strikes that rare balance of feeling like a neighborhood hangout while delivering food that’s thoughtful, bold, and beautifully executed. The smoked half chicken with Comal sauce was my standout dish — smoky, tender, and packed with deep flavor. A close second: the octopus with tortilla and green sauce, which was perfectly cooked and had a bright, herbal punch that cut through the richness. The aguachiles were also memorable — sharp, refreshing, and unlike anything I’ve had elsewhere. If you’re lucky enough to go when they have it, don’t miss the crab tostada. It’s seasonal, but it nailed the contrast of crunch and savoriness — a masterclass in balance. Highly recommend for anyone looking for inventive Mexican food in a setting that feels both casual and special.

James Eisenman

Google
We went for my birthday and the experience was fantastic. The food was amazing and they made us feel right at home. A+

Ksenia S Saffron & Honey

Google
Loved the food, the friendly service and the cool restaurant space!

Sharon Batan

Google
So good and creative dishes! Loved the Al pastor skewers and the soft serve the best and the chicken with rice

Younjae Doh

Google
The food was good however not fantastic and extremely small portions considering the price point. For example a potato dish was $17 and it was maybe around 3-4 bites. Our dinner session was also super rushed with a very strict dining time of ~110mins. Difficult to relax and get through the food and wine within this time frame.
google avatar

Hannah H.

Yelp
Comal is in LES, and their cuisine is a celebration of Mexico City - our group came here to check them out for an early dinner, and our party ordered the following to share: +some Skewers - al pastor and mushroom (they also have lengua) +Mussels - with corn custard and potato +the Striped Bass Aguachile - with lime oil; I was actually excited for this dish! +the Asparagus - with lardo and masa +and, Smoked Half Chicken - stuffed wings with Comal hot sauce; we also added the Comal Rice and the Green Salad with cotija with this dish Everything was beautifully presented and easily shareable. For dessert, we had a passion fruit ice cream and the Chocolate & Guajillo Torta. The restaurant itself is cozy, and I enjoyed their open kitchen; the service was on point, as we were frequently checked upon, plates were cleared, and our drinks were always full! They take reservations! We were seated promptly for ours, and I highly recommend in making one as the place was pretty packed when we came. +great shareables +open kitchen +friendly service +reservations accepted
google avatar

Linan C.

Yelp
A total disappointment. Felt like we were ripped off. We ordered the lobster salad and it was literally chopped up lobster onions and parsley on top. I ate a whole mouth of parsley... A full meal of confusion and utter disappointment... Waygu Skirt steak served with tortilla in the side... Gave them extra star because the beef lengua skewer was pretty good.
google avatar

Shawn H.

Yelp
This was mostly excellent. We loved the skewers, mussels, aguachile, potato, and especially the desserts (some of the best we've had this year). We also got the steak, which came with amazing tortillas and sauces, but we both thought the steak itself was too tough for tacos, which we were disappointed about given the price.
google avatar

Sheina L.

Yelp
Went here the week it opened, so perhaps they're still figuring things out but I didn't enjoy our meal. My father is from Mexico City. My husband and I visit often and I make Mexican food at home often. I feel confident in saying that while the restaurant's aesthetic reminds me of the cool and vibrant restaurant scene in CDMX, I found the food to be really disappointing, especially for the price. The aguachiles was bland and the fish's texture was hard, almost crunchy? The chicken for the chicken mole dish was slightly undercooked and there wasn't enough mole sauce. They served pickles with it, too, which had zero connection to the dish and didn't make any sense. There were also no tortillas offered so the dish overall felt incomplete and disjointed. The only dish I liked was the al pastor skewer but it was tiny for the price. Dining here was a total bust IMO. Didn't even want desert. Sorry.