COMPTON'S

Sandwich shop · East Village

COMPTON'S

Sandwich shop · East Village

2

123 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003

Photos

COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by Will Hartman
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null
COMPTON'S by null

Highlights

Fresh ingredients, housemade condiments, retro vibe, free games  

Placeholder
Placeholder

123 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003 Get directions

comptons.nyc
@comptons.nyc

$10–20 · Menu

Information

Static Map

123 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003 Get directions

+1 917 639 3040
comptons.nyc
@comptons.nyc

$10–20 · Menu

Features

coffee
comfort food
lunch
popular for lunch
popular for solo dining

Last updated

Oct 8, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

Compton's - Review - East Village - New York - The Infatuation

"Compton’s, a sandwich shop that was born in Astoria, has a third location in the East Village. They do a good chopped cheese, and also have pinball machines in their stores for a little doom scrolling-free entertainment while you wait for your sandwich. We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Will Hartman

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/comptons-east-village
View Postcard for COMPTON'S
@philtoronto
Want To Go
View Postcard for COMPTON'S

kekko la rocca

Google
We had lunch at Compton's after an intense day. We were welcomed by a young professional, Julian Flores, who immediately made us feel at ease and recommended some excellent sandwiches; his courtesy, professionalism, and kindness really impressed us. The food was excellent, the portions generous, and the service impeccable. In particular, we tried the house must-haves: the Vodka Chicken Parm and the Chicken Burrata Club, with tater tots as sides. Definitely worth a second visit. Great value for money. Greetings from Italy 🇮🇹

Rich H

Google
I stopped in here earlier for lunch I ordered the patty melt and side of fries to go the patty melt was really good the fries were really good as well!. The service was fast the cashier was pretty cool to!. The atmosphere had a retro feel to it with the two arcade games inside!.

Todd Fellerman

Google
Was very impressed with the quality of the sandwich and fair prices. Bread was perfect and all of the ingredients were fresh and solid amount too. I had The Tuscany, which was perfect. Looking forward to coming back to try many other sandwiches!!

Michelle Dutton

Google
So excited that they've expanded to the East Village! Their burrata BLT is my all-time favorite sandwich! But if I'm being honest, everything they make is incredible. Andddd don't forget the sides - their mozz sticks, corn nuggets, and onion rings are all *so* good. + A side of their vodka sauce with everything please.

Jai Das

Google
When I first saw Compton going up, I didn’t expect much, but I finally checked it out, and it’s legit. Great vibes, free games, solid sandwich lineup, and the person at the front was super friendly and helpful. Definitely coming back, East Village people, this one’s worth a stop. They got me more than right!!

Jeff Stettin

Google
The bread, the bread, the bread. Enjoyed an OUTSTANDING turkey sandwich from Compton’s today. It’s actually my second sandwich as it was a two-for-one deal and I had the other last night (and yes the second one held up). I know this is a growing chain but the sandwich did not feel chain-y. It was the kind of sandwich you’d find at a great family owned shop along the shore. The bread was real with a crisp exterior and a good chew…not the white bread stuff you get at those places I avoid. The turkey was fresh, plentiful (no need to ask for extra meat), sliced thin and of high quality. The veggies and dressing were fresh and delicious. I’m grateful we now have a ‘made with love’ sandwich place in the EV. and I look forward to trying their many offerings both cold and hot.

DAVID PALUCH

Google
I live in the Neighborhood and there has been no good sandwich shop, now after having the Tony cold cut I can say we have a good sandwich shop. As well I have to give credit to the young man working the counter, unfortunately didn’t get his name but he is from queens, offered great customer service. 5 stars all day and I will be returning to try what else they have.

ELAN G.

Google
COMPTONS Sandwich Shop in NY is a must-visit! Fresh, flavorful sandwiches stacked high with quality ingredients. The vibe is cozy, staff super friendly, and every bite is perfection. A true gem for sandwich lovers! Can't wait to go back!
google avatar

Alexander R.

Yelp
Saw Compton's promoting their new location here online and decided to check it out. Placed an order for pickup and it was ready within 10mins. Normally not a chopped cheese person but there was a BOGO so decided to give it a try. Sandwich overall was pretty solid and good value, but the semolina bread it came on was really the highlight of it - super great texture, fresh, and tasted high quality. Excited to come back and try some of the other sandwiches!
google avatar

Alex M.

Yelp
Food here is 5 stars, no question. Outstanding menu options are paired with unique flavors, especially with the Gold Rush sandwich. By the second half of the sandwich, I would take a look at the next bite, eager to find out which ingredient was causing the flavor explosion in my mouth. An unusual wait time for a non busy time of day threw a wrench into quick takeout plans. Be prepared for loud music as well, as in much louder than you would expect, although I could have been affected from being in there too long.
google avatar

Adam S.

Yelp
I've always wanted to try this place when living in Astoria almost 5 years ago. Finally was able to now that they have a location in East Village via Uber Eats. Sandwiches are great, definitely recommend them any time of the day.
google avatar

Lara F.

Yelp
Very little filling...tried the tuna it was all lettuce waste if $ and you can't add extra fillings (just like Joey Roses all bread)
google avatar

Sileeta E.

Yelp
Love the rob definitely my fav sandwich can't wait to try more! Love the old school pac man arcade game too

Dylan R.

Yelp
Average chicken parm hero. Better off at joe and pats right up the street. $17 bogus.
google avatar

Jeff S.

Yelp
The bread, the bread, the bread. Enjoyed an OUTSTANDING turkey sandwich from Compton's today. It's actually my second sandwich as it was a two-for-one deal and I had the other last night (and yes the second one held up). I know this is a growing chain but the sandwich did not feel chain-y. It was the kind of sandwich you'd find at a great family owned shop along the shore. The bread was real with a crisp exterior and a good chew...not the white bread stuff you get at those places I avoid. The turkey was plentiful (no need to ask for extra meat), plentiful and of high quality. The veggies and dressing were fresh and delicious. I'm grateful we now have a 'made with love' sandwich place in the EV and I look forward to trying their many offerings both cold and hot.

James C.

Yelp
Ordered the Spencer Steak sandwich recommended by the cashier...very tasty, will definitely be coming back soon, the cashier was very knowledgeable and helpful with a great customer service experience...
Wood grain pattern