Scott G.
Yelp
Three stars means "A-OK" according to yelp.com's standards. If I had gone alone, or just with my wife and kid, this would have been at least 4 stars, but considering the experience of my parents (who came with us last night), it's 3 stars. Had they been doing this review, they might have given 2 stars. :(
The place is very cute and nicely designed. Even the bathrooms are spacious and comfortable. The owner's wife was very informative about the style of Italian food they serve, and she and her husband have a decades-long history in the restaurant industry. The owner's sister has made them some adorable ceramic table # decorations ... see my photos.
The waitress was excellent. She had a great demeanor, and was right on top of us practically from the moment we sat down. That's really important to me. We got our appetizers in a short time (the broiled octopus was pretty good, the mussels were good, and the special salad was good as well), but there was a pretty long break between appetizers and main course. When the mussel in wine sauce appetizer came out, my step-mom said that they were cold... like... almost warm coolness. They were sent back and returned re-heated and were satisfactory.
When the mains came out, my wife got the mussels Fra Diavlo (very good), daughter very much liked her Penne a la Vodka, I got a ribbon pasta like a papardelle in a tomato sauce, I can't remember the name but I liked it. My father got the whole wheat penne with Pomodoro sauce, which looked disgusting, and he said it was so/so. He needed extra sauce as it was kind of dry. The Pomodoro sauce was very smooth, and we're used to seeing it with some texture, but WTH do we know...a couple of Jews in a restaurant specializing in food made in the spirit of Sorrento, Italia.
Their philosophy here is sensible...they give you a minimal amount of toppings so that they can add more if you need, but not so much that they'll have to remake the whole dish. Easier to add than take away. My wife's side of meatballs were OK... they're a bit on the tough side, not the kind that crumbles at the poke of a fork. Kind of reminded me of beef sausage with a good tomato sauce.
My step-mom's steak came out, and again she's like "It's cold." They reheated it and I tried it... I thought it had a nice charred flavor, but maybe not worth $38. She ate some of it, and declared that she wouldn't return here.
I can only think that either my step-mom is getting some variant of alzheimer's disease that affects your ability to remember the difference between hot and cold, or maybe they have an open window in the kitchen to keep the cooks cool, but it's December, and if dishes are waiting in the kitchen with the open window, especially a breeze, and not under a good heat lamp, they're going to get COLD. Other than this, I thought it was pretty good and I may try it again. I think things like this are just kinks that take time to iron out.