Corey's NYC Bagel Deli

It was 1st time and I happy with my bagel sandwich. It was soo delicious and filling. My go two order is always a plain bagel with turkey, avocado, bacon and condiments. For me I like to hollow my bread a bit so it’s not so thick, but still delicious

2/5 – Disappointing “lux” bagel experience I was in the mood for a luxe-style NYC bagel and decided to try Corey’s NYC Bagel. I ordered an everything bagel with plain cream cheese, lox, toppings, and a cup of coffee. The total came to around $28 with tip, which felt steep for what I got. The bagel itself was just average — definitely not living up to the “NYC bagel” reputation. The flavors were pretty bland, and one of the toppings was cucumber, which didn’t really fit the mix in my opinion. For the price, I expected a much more flavorful and balanced bagel. Overall, not a place I’d recommend, especially if you’re looking for that true NYC-style lox bagel experience.

Im a New Yorker raised and born and i can tell you this def ain’t New York. This is so dry. & $10 just for this dry sandwich is insane. I dont mind payinf for quality but this is not. and the fact they don’t have rolls is crazy. NY would never. Never again.

Mediocre (at best) sandwich and 2ounces of potato salad for over $18 after tax. Never again. Only redeeming quality might be the wider variety of menu they offer.

BEST BAGELS IN CHICAGO. The only thing preventing me from giving 5 stars is the limited hours. Would be nice to be able to get a bacon egg and cheese or a slice of pizza late at night in true NYC fashion.

Highly recommend! We got the salmon lox with the chive cream cheese and it was delicious!

Excellent bagels!! They also serve a gigantic NY style pizza slice that is also really good. Prices are fair, but worth it. There is a trip hazard leaving the store covered by a black rug - a large raised spot in the flooring so beware if that as I almost tripped while putting napkins into my bag and walking out. Needs something lighter so that the optical illusion of flatness isn’t covered up by the rug! Lunch meats there are Boars head which are quality. I’d rather though see their own brand or get it shipped in from another deli than use a large chain brand deli meat. Great place though! Friendly staff.

We are from NJ where these are plentiful and high quality- this place met the mark! They even had Taylor Ham. Good bagel sandwiches made to order.

It's Marathon Morning, and our daughter is running in her first Chicago Marathon. We mapped out our strategy to see her in a number of places, but on a Sunday morning in downtown Chicago breakfast options are somewhat limited, and with the influx of runners and spectators, we assumed anyplace we tried would be swamped. Corey's NYC Bagel Deli was on the way to one of our planned stops so we decided to see how the line was....and were surprised that the place wasn't packed. Sure, there was a line, but it wasn't bad at all. To say they have a lot of bagel and cream cheese options would be a massive understatement. The first thing I look for in any bagel shop is a jalapeño bagel, but sadly they don't have one. They do, however, have jalapeño cream cheese, so Jim is pretty happy with that. I'd never have a pretzel bagel before, so I thought that I'd give that a shot with the jalapeño cream cheese. Corey's also has a variety of breakfast sandwiches and a make-your-own-sandwich option as well. There's fresh brewed coffee available, and aside from that there are a number of bottled drinks available in multiple drink coolers. For as busy as they were I was surprised how fast our orders came out (about 15 minutes). I'm not going to lie, there was A LOT of carryout business going on, but the foot traffic inside wasn't terrible. The staff was hustling this morning. Whether it was taking orders, making food, or delivering food, the staff was on-the-go and worked like a well-oiled machine. So here it is, Sunday morning -- Marathon Morning -- and my wife and I are standing eating Corey's bagels in Downtown Chicago. I was 100% impressed with the jalapeño cream cheese. Not only at the amount on the bagel (there was a LOT, but that's ok because I love cream cheese), but at the taste. There were chunks of jalapeño and cilantro. I don't know that I've ever had cilantro in jalapeño cream cheese before, but this was a most excellent touch. An interesting thing happens when you stand in the middle of the street eating a bagel when the city is packed with over 100,000 extra people. Passers by notice you. At least 3 people stopped to ask if there was a bagel shop nearby. "Yes, it's called Corey's and it's two blocks down and around the corner. Just hang a left at the light and you can't miss it". I hope Corey's appreciates the business we sent their way! :)

They were a few blocks from Hilton. The bagels were excellent Coffee was hot. I visited a few days in a row. Much better than continental breakfast at hotel.

Went to this place on a whim because it was close to our hotel. We were on our way to Einstein Bagels, but it was so cold and windy we blew right into this place. It was a serendipitous surprise. We each got bagels, I got the salmon and lox. It was delicious, but the fun was the way the worker's interact with the customers. They have a bell you can ring and they have a cute phrase they all say in unison. It's a small shop, not much area to sprawl out and eat. We opted to order takeout and take back to our hotel to eat. While waiting the owner/ workers made sure to wish a regular a happy birthday. I just enjoyed the atmosphere. Didn't have a corporate feel which is always a breath of fresh air. If you're in the area and want a bagel, check it out.

Yummy bagels... love this place - high quality smoked salmon which I am super picky about employees are awesome and love that they carry ZOA energy drinks

I was in Chicago for less than a week and came here for breakfast at least 3 times. The number of choices for the create-your-own bagel sandwich was impressive. Everything was fresh and well-balanced, chewy and delicious. Will definitely be back next time I'm in town!

Let me preface this just by saying I'm from Jersey so my bagel standards are higher. This unfortunately isn't even close to nyc bagels and I barely got any cream cheese on my bagel. The bacon egg and cheese wasn't as bad but the bagel wad still lacking. Willing to try them again I've heard they've improved and it wasn't a bad bagel just not great.

Corey's NYC Bagel Deli screams New York City. It reminded me of a more modern version of my favorite NYC bagel shop. Corey's is a quick walk from Merchandise Mall. The inside is spacious but they only have a few seats if you actually want to dine in. The inside is setup to easily accommodate to-go orders. Corey's has a large menu but it's spilt nicely between bagel sandwiches and common popular sandwiches. The first thing I noticed about Corey's is that they serve Boars Head. That is an instant win for sandwich lovers! During my visit I opted for the Rueben sandwich. The sandwich had a nice about of corned beef for the price. I was able to get two meals out of the sandwich. They also didn't over do it with the sauerkraut or dressing. I was also able to try my husband's bagel sandwich (egg whites, sausage and cheese). It was tasty so I do plan to visit again to get my own breakfast sandwich. Another treat that the restaurant offers is a livestream of what looks like Time Square or another NYC landmark on the television while you wait.

Great bagels. Just like New York. Good takeout, chill spot. Quick service. I usually order off DoorDash.

I ordered a bagel not a rock. I've been craving an egg bagel for 2 months and I was gonna go to Gotham bagels but I didn't realize they closed at 2pm. So I came here instead, I should've just waited until the next day. Hardest, driest, plainest egg bagel I've ever had. Egg bagels are known for being moist and chewy, it was toasted but it should still not be that hard. The place itself was pretty cool, I went with 2 other friends and only 2 out of the 3 could sit down. Would not recommend or come here again, to Gotham it is.

Good mostly,just a little chewy.plain bagel 7/10 garlic herb bagel 10/10 and everything bagel 10/10.cute decour includes map of Nyc and rugs.overall,yum! Five stars!

Corey's is always my go-to for breakfast in River North. Chewy NYC style bagels with any filling you desire. My usual order is an onion bagel with cream cheese, nova lox, tomato and red onion, and an everything with veggie cream cheese. I typically order on-line and then walk over and pick it up. A little pricier than Einstein, but much, much better. The bagel dough has a touch of sweetness (maybe a bit of malt syrup?) but not enough to put me off of them. I've also gotten a typical NYC "bacon, egg and cheese, S/P/K" which is also a great way to start the day. Definitely recommended for a solid breakfast option in the River North area.

I love Corey's! They open at 6am each morning 7 days a week. Which makes it a perfect spot to start your day. Since it is Sunday I walked down there shortly after they opened and purchased my favorite Vegetable Cream Cheese to bring home to make breakfast with. It is beyond delicious and creamy and full of vegetables whipped in! Thank you Corey's also for your professional staff who are polite, helpful, knowledgeable, respectful, efficient and work well as a team. The lines always move quickly! There are a few places inside to sit and eat. The establishment is always clean and organized in a way that patrons can self service.

Get the garlic herb bagel! Trust me! Delicious. And many thanks to the man at the counter who steered me right when I asked his thoughts on which bagel I should get.

OK. I'm a displaced New Yorker who lives in Louisiana and is now visiting Chicago. Was hungry. Saw this place on yelp. Got a bagel and cream cheese. Outstanding. Really enjoyed it. See the picture. The service was very fast, professional, and deficient. This will not be the only time I eat here during my vacation! I highly recommend the meal I ate.

Glad I found this place, it was delicious!!! Except for the fact that they were extremely stingy with the cream cheese. If you order via DoorDash there is no option that will allow you to add extra cream cheese. Other than that everything I ordered on the sandwich was good.

Alright, so, I love bagels. Bagels are my love language. My bar for bagels are incredibly high so if you aren't a picky bagel eater, take my review with a grain of salt! Pros: Service and turnaround is amazing. My simply yet classic order, a toasted everything bagel with veggie cream cheese, was ordered and handed to me in a run time of ~4 minutes on a Thursday morning. Bagel flavor: I've tried two bagels here - plain and standard, my baseline bagels. They have an odd sweet undertone to them and even when going in the morning, taste slightly stale/dried out. What makes NY bagels so delicious is the crispy outside and warm inside that comes from the boil and bake method - these don't have that crunch, even when I order them toasted. Would I go back? I don't know - I still need to try an egg and cheese and a egg salad bagel to round out my orders so maybe. I'll make my fiancé try a couple as well and report back with his notes!

This place is popping on Saturday mornings and for good reason. My friend and I came and ordered inside- our wait was not long at all. We got the create your own breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel, egg, bacon, horseradish cheddar, toasted. I would have preferred double toasted as the bagel was too chewy. A little hot sauce would have been good with this but otherwise delicious. We also got the garlic and herb bagel with jalapeño cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion toasted. This was delicious as well and not spicy. I preferred the garlic and herb bagel over the everything bagel. Not the best bagel sandwiches I've had, but it hit the spot and glad I finally tried it!

Good selection of bagels, toppings, and home made cream cheeses. The sandwiches are make your own, except if you order a bagel sandwich "meal" (which is around $15). The bagel sandwiches we got were ok but not worth the high prices to me. It took a while to get our food and when we did, they called out my name and some lady stole my food. Crazy! I thought I must have misheard what they called because I've never had that happen before. Sure enough, she took my food and ran so thankfully they made it again for me but a lot quicker the second time. I appreciated that. Small shop, and they do have some seating, but if it's busy I wouldn't assume you'll find any. Not my cup of tea but if you're crazy about bagels/sandwiches you might love it.

We ordered the plain and everything bagels. They were okay but not as good as NY bagel & Bialy.

Don't waste your time or money here. You are truly just a transaction at Corey's Bagel on N Dearborn. The food is fair, not great. The quality of service and attitudes exhibited by the team members and management are telling of a place that gets to treat customers the way they do because of a lack of more appealing options in the area. They consistently get simple orders wrong and when this gets pointed out to be corrected, you are met with dismissive and arrogant responses by team members such as "I don't care." Money isn't frictionless. Don't settle for being treated poorly at a place that serves average food at little value. You should feel good about where you spend your money.

Bagels were delicious. The staff were very nice in explaining options. Location is very close to us so we will likely be back. The restaurant is very clean and welcoming.

Good quick breakfast sandwich spot. Go with the classic sausage egg and cheese! Extremely fast service too.

I've ordered their tuna salad on a bagel before and I usually need a fork because there is a fair amount of it on the bread/bagel. As the pictures show, I doubt if a half scoop was present on my latest order (placed through DoorDash). For a $15+ tuna salad sandwich I should have received enough to taste beyond the onions and the bagel, which dominated my taste buds. This is beyond false advertising when one compares the picture on their menu with what was delivered today. I really l can't believe that someone prepared and the. packed my order and sent it like this. The sandwich is cut in half so the preparer cannot argue that they didn't notice. Furthermore, making the argument that this happened possibly because it was lunch time and busy is absurd because lunch happens everyday and I can imagine that this deli, like many others, is usually quite swamped M-F especially during the lunch hour. EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTING

Bagels of course and more such as coffee and deli salads at this small place that's especially busy at breakfast. Corey's is a New York style deli. It has a lot of bagels to choose from, as well as salads and sandwiches. Gets pretty busy and there's not much room to eat inside. They have a few seats but most people get takeout. I was expecting to get takeout but was lucky enough to find one available chair. It's a pretty tiny place and there's only a couple of counters with a few chairs at each. The deli has a lot on display beyond just bagels, such as the many pasta salads. It was late in the morning so I got something on a bagel. The lunch options kind of combined with it too. I had a NYC Vegetarian on a sesame bagel. It's about $9 but it's big. This comes with a choice of dressing, and has lettuce, onions, and tomatoes. It's simple but good. They also have many other meaty favorites like pastrami and reubens. Good place especially at breakfast. It has a large variety of bagels and many toppings to choose from. They also have pizza if you want some of that instead of sandwiches.

I got the 1 egg breakfast sandwich and added Bacon, Pepperjack Cheese, and cream cheese onto an Everything Bagel. I Grubhubbed this and it was delivered as ordered. Delicious breakfast sandwich.

The bagels were delicious! I chose the jalapeño cream cheese, their bagels were very chewy, and this lox was loaded with cream cheese and lox slices. The capers, cucumber and tomatoes were all pretty fresh. Absolutely love the lox bagel!

This place was a complete rip off. $10 for one of the worst sausage egg and cheese I've ever had. Bagel had 0 positive qualities about it.

This was place was fantastic. Excellent bagel which was very much in the NYC style. I had a lox sandwich with the chive sandwich. (Only downside is there is limited seating of four stools at a counter) definitely will be back

If 10 stars was an option I'd be selecting it. Can't decide what I enjoy more between the service or the delicious bagels. Good thing I don't have to! Long time loyal customer

You know the feeling when you're super hyped to get something you've been 'hankering for?' I rarely treat myself to a bagel - maybe, 4-5 times a year. And today was the day. I decided to order from Corey's based off of 4+ star reviews on google and Uber eats(I should have checked Yelp). Needless to say this place was a disappointment. With NYC in the name, I would have expected more. I get it, we don't live in New York - so I'm not comparing this to bagels in NYC. Legit this was a terrible bagel. You know the bagels you get from grocery stores, like when Mariano's or jewel makes their own? Hard, dense and flavorless? This would be below grocery grade. Recommendation: There's better places in the city to order from; Chicago Bagel Authority, Gotham Bagels, etc. Or in a pinch go to jewel - either way you'll get a better product. Bagel went in trash

Got the salmon sandwich with lite chive cream cheese on a toasted everything bagel and they for sure didn't skimp out. It was delicious! Comes with a side too which was a pleasant surprise Food came out quick the place was clean and the staff was nice 10/10 bro

Great bagels! Stopped in for a quick breakfast sandwich. Had to take a minute to look at the menu because you basically just make your own and tell them what you want on it and what type of bagel. They had a good selection of bagels. It might have taken 5 or so minutes for us to get our food. We decided to eat inside since it was rainy that day. There were a handful of barstool type chairs with a small ledge to eat. Nothing fancy and definitely not a place for a whole family with kids to come and expect to sit and eat. All the workers were very friendly and lots of people must've ordered ahead and were just in and out for pickup.

I've tried plenty of bagel shops, but this place serves unbelievable kettle boiled bagels. Oh, did I mention they have pizza too? Yeah, it's amazing. You need to try the Nova Lox bagel & the chicken salad on an everything bagel is out of this world. You can buy a dozen of bagels to go, breakfast bagel sandwiches & lunch. Service is so quick & everyone is very nice and friendly when you come into the store. Great location & sweet atmosphere inside. Also available to order through food apps. A must go!

Ehhh, my buffalo chicken bagel sandwich was kind of whatever in my mind. I'm actually pretty surprised they don't have any actual spicy options for those who want to kick up the spice level. My team and I came here for lunch since it's nearby the office and in a way I had wished we went elsewhere, but surprisingly there aren't a whole lot of good easy pick up spots in the immediate area. I wouldn't go out of my way to come here, but I guess I'm willing to try another one of their bagel sandwiches. I didn't feel like the staff was all that friendly here either.

Very delicious bagel sandwich's! Nice deli-arrangement if you'd like to bring food home! Ample meat ! Fresh tasting .... Friendly atmosphere .., I was so full I took half my sandwich home!! My daughter ate all of hers.., Pickles are deli good also... I'll be back ! Yum

It was my last day during a weekend trip to Chicago, and I wanted some breakfast close to my hotel. I knew I would be visiting Jollibee later on and ordering enough food to feed a small army, so I wanted something fast that would hold me over. A bagel sounded more than sufficient! I did a quick Yelp search and found Corey's a few blocks away. I walked over to find a spacious storefront on N Dearborn. Their walls are adorned with take home bagel chips that they insist they're known for (I partook and bought a cinnamon raisin bag). The menu and options are consistent with that of a bagel shop - breakfast sandwiches, deli options, and in-house cream cheese options. I may have told my fellow Yelpers in a previous review that I'm extremely picky on lox sandwiches, but I went with theirs anyway. On the menu, it's called a lox sandwich but it's detailed as smoked salmon. It was confusing but I crossed my fingers and ordered it on an everything bagel. It came in a large box as opposed to aluminum foil, so I decided to eat it back at the room as opposed to awkwardly attempting to eat and walk. This bagel sandwich was large and in charge! I took off the tomatoes and cucumbers while ordering and it was still a mouthful. I was extremely happy to find out that I was indeed fed smoked salmon instead of lox. Lox purists may be upset, but that's a them problem. The chive cream cheese was also delicious. I wish there were more capers, but my main reason for 4 instead of 5 stars is that the bagel didn't wow me. It was a good bagel, no doubt, but it didn't have that chew or fluffiness a truly good New York bagel has. This bagel is definitely delicious, but I'm not sure it'd fare that well in the Big Apple. I am a simple gal when it comes to bagel sandwiches. I enjoyed (half) of the large bagel, and I would do so again. If in the neighborhood and you have an intense hankering for a bagel, Corey's place is a solid choice.

This east coast bagel/deli snob was rather impressed with Corey's. I got the smoked salmon bagel sandwich. The bagel itself was pretty good, but felt like it was missing something. Not sure why people in Chicago believe cucumbers belong on a lox bagel, but I digress. Everything else on the sandwich was great quality (nova lox, capers, onion & tomato). BUT the main reason I'm writing this review is for the pickle that came with the meal. That is what a NYC deli pickle is supposed to be like! I've yet to find anywhere else in Chicago that has quality pickles like Corey's. Now if only they can let me in on the secret of where they source these epic pickles!

Went here to bagel sandwiches and ate so glad that we did! The bagels are fresh and delicious. The sandwiches are stuffed full of delicious items. I got turkey and provolone-very tasty. There isn't much room to dine in, so we took it to go.

We are tourists who wanted a fun breakfast. Ordered online for carryout. Staff was surprisingly not friendly and that might have been ok if they hadn't left out half our order and the stuff they did give us was not great. Had to call and get a refund which they did do without issue.

Good bagels and so much cream cheese! Definitely a bang for your buck! The staff was very friendly.

Excellent Bagels - texture is just right, not crispy but not soft either. Has a little sweetness to it in the egg bagel which I liked. Gigantic slice of NY Pizza was excellent. Crispy crust, excellent cheese and sauce. Boars head meats are served here. I was in the mood for Pastrami, but nope!! Make your own or get it freshly made, not from a company that mass produces cold cut meats.

The bagels here are excellent!! So is the cream cheese! We came here twice in 4 days!! Both times we ordered the salt bagel with veggie cream cheese and the sesame bagel with lox spread. So perfect! The bagels weee chewy and soft, and they didn't skimp on the cream cheese! Everyone here is friendly! Remember to ring the bell on your way out! If you like bagels, check out Corey's. You won't be disappointed!

We are big fans of Corey's, and we recently used Corey's for an at home catering order. Ray was extremely easy to work with, providing recommendations on the best approach to our order and helping us customize given my desire for variety. The delivery was extremely smooth, with the delivery coming in time and all the breakfast sandwiches still really warm. I would absolutely recommend Corey's for a catering event or for stopping in when you're craving a bagel! Unique flavors, extremely friendly and attentive staff, and a great local business to support!

A very average bagel place! It's a shame as I was trying to find a place that was going to be superior to a chain bagel place nearby but was disappointed with the bagels. I had an everything bagel which I would've renamed "hardly anything" bagel. The strawberry cream cheese was excellent though. If you are visiting from out of town you are best to skip this place.

Great simple place. Relatively cheap compared to others nearby. Good temperature inside, about 6 seats so may not grab a seat if it's busy. Free water available. Bagels were a little under toasted but if I return I'll ask them to double toast. Came to visit to Chicago for a week and came twice for breakfast

Asked for a scooped bagel toasted with cream cheese, to go. Got home and realized it was the right bagel and cream cheese but it was neither toasted nor scooped. I ate it anyway because I didn't want to go through the hassle of going back, but this was not a hard order to fulfill. Will give another try though.

Fast, fresh, and available 7 days a week. Stopped in b/c it was one of the few early morning Saturday options and was impressed. Got the Nova lox sandwich and it didn't disappoint.

The only good thing about this place is that it came out super fast. I got an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. The bagel tasted stale and had a weird texture. It also wasn't warm when I got it and since it was ready about 30 seconds after I placed my order.. maybe they pre toast the bagels? There was a good amount of cream cheese on it tho.

Is it too strange to be so in love with a bagel place? I've been coming to Corey's ever since the pandemic started. I'm not sure if it's the "staying at home" that's creating this bagel craving for me or the fact that I've gotten addicted from trying it for the first time, but either way, it's always a great food experience to come here. My go-to is always their Lox Bagel. The salmon is extremely fresh and tastes great. The combination of cream cheese, capers, onions, raw salmon and a toasted bagel just hits differently. I've flown all the way to NYC to try Russ & Daughters lox bagel, but I think Corey's might have won in this battle. Fight me on this one. The staff is also being COVID cautious which is always highly appreciated. Everyone going inside the store has to wear a mask and there are multiple hand sanitizers throughout the store. The staff is also super friendly and very efficient with their service. Till next time!