Scott N.
Yelp
I have been meaning to write this review for a while and, since I am headed to Deli City this Friday for lunch, the spirit has moved me.
Deli City makes the best corned beef I have ever eaten, by a considerable margin. This is not an idle observation. A good corned beef sandwich with Russian on rye is about as close as I come to a religious experience, so I would not dole out this sort of praise without substantial reflection, based on numerous tastings.
Deli City's corned beef is extraordinarily flavorful -- a rich, beefy, tangy umami immersion. It is moist and extremely tender -- it would fall apart in the face of a hard stare -- but with a perfect, toothsome texture. It is served warm, of course (cold corned beef makes about as much sense as cold chicken soup) and in generous portions. It comes as a sandwich or as a reuben. (I wish it came as a wallpaper.) The reuben is nicely prepared, with the ingredients in the right proportions.
There is no agreed international standard for corned beef deliciousness and people's definition of perfect corned beef flavor and texture no doubt varies, but Deli City's corned beef is so damned good that I feel confident in stating, as a matter of objective fact, that it is better than Second Avenue Deli's (the old one and the new one), better than Katz's, better than David's Brisket House, better than anything I've had in Montreal or L.A. Needless to say, no place else in DC is even worth discussing.
The place has been around for decades. It is so "old school" that the menu refers to swiss cheese as "switzer cheese," terminology that has probably not been used at any other eating establishment since the Eisenhower Administration. Service is welcoming and efficient. The furniture is a bit tattered, but it's a comfortable place.
There is, of course, plenty of other stuff on the menu and most of it is good. The pastrami is the other standout, no doubt the best available in the District and competitive with anything in NY. The corned beef, however, is in a class by itself.
Fortunately for the staff of the restaurant, but unfortunately for the rest of us, Deli City is not open evenings or weekends. And it is undeniably a longish trip from downtown for a lunch-hour jaunt. But who cares! If you like corned beef, take a long lunch and go eat something sublime.