Kyle P.
Yelp
**4.5 Stars**
We had a lovely experience at Dimmi Dimmi, an extremely difficult reservation to get, for my wife's 40th birthday. The hostess, our server, and another staff member made mention of the occasion, and definitely made us feel special.
It's a tight, loud space - depending on where you are, you might be competing with folks having cocktails and waiting for a bar seat or their reservation. But, in short, while the prices are a bit confusing in some areas, this is excellent Italian fare.
The cocktails are top notch, my rye Manhattan and my wife's Negroni were every bit as good as the many cocktails we've enjoyed at Armitage Alehouse down the street, at about the same price point.
The focaccia was really good, seemingly done in a skillet, but with a crispy exterior coated in sea salt and olive oil, and a chewy interior. If Ciccio Mio is the best I've had in this city, Dimmi's is just below that.
We were surprised, however, that the spreads you can get with the focaccia are almost as expensive as the bread itself, $7 for whipped ricotta and honey.
The charred brussels and squash was excellent, kind of like a sqash carpaccio with incredible flavor and texture. A unique, top notch appetizer we'd absolutely have again.
My wife's clam special was great, overflowing with clams in a sauce that was balanced, a touch spicy, and not too oily. Really, really good.
As for the chicken parm. Someone I usually agree with on here had a negative review as it's "just a piece of pounded chicken," but I disagree. Is $33 a lot for a chicken parm? Yea, it is. But compare this to Alla Vita ($33 and NO pasta) or even a Frasca ($26), and it blows them away. Perfectly crispy and juicy, with a really nice tomato sauce. I honestly think the chicken itself is the best chicken parm I've had in Chicago, not pounded too thin, with a ton of texture and flavor. I might like more mozz, but whaddyagonnado.
The pesto pasta that comes with it, however, was a slight miss. The pasta is cooked perfectly al dente, yes, but the pesto itself is far too pasty and lacking any lemony acid. And it needs it. Badly. You can tell the basil is fresh, but man, after a few bites, and especially as it cools, the pesto pasta becomes a chore to eat. That was a definite shame.
We concluded with the chocolate cake (and a complimentary olive oil ice cream, delicious, from Black Dog). The cake was flavorful, but quite dry. It reminded us both of chocolate cake in a NJ diner that had been there more than day or two, which would be a compliment if it wasn't $16! For $16, I'm walking two blocks east and having the sticky date cake at Armitage. And, our complimentary gelato? $9. For a scoop of ice cream!
Dimmi Dimmi is doing some really great stuff. That chicken parm has probably ruined chicken parms for me (Frasca is our restaurant of convenience, but for $7 less, it tastes like a frozen dish compared to this. And Alla Vita is good, but comes w no side). The squash was delightful, and the cocktails are as good as we've had at a restaurant.
But, the price points don't entirely make sense, particularly dessert and some of the extras. And the dessert falls way, way short of the price point. If you're charging Hogsalt prices, and you're two blocks from the best desserts in the city, you better deliver.
All this said, we will absolutely be back, assuming we can snag a reservation that is.