Door County Creamery

This place is packed, we didn't end up getting the coffee I wanted to get because it just basic coffee. They do have ice cream but the line was long and didn't want to wait. Prices seemed high. We were going to get food, but again it was very busy. Ended up going next door for coffee, which was great.

The hot honey sandwich is THE perfect sandwich. The bread is crunchy and soft, the cheese is gooey and all over. It has a touch of heat with sweet and salty mixed in. I will think about it forever. Highly recommend! Turkey and Brie was also great if you want something a little more lowkey. Very nice patio that is dog friendly as well.

The best lunch spot in sister bay! Dine outside or take your food to go and picnic by the water! This place is so effortlessly cool. Love the bLT and my kids love the pizza rolls! We make sure we stop in for gelato at least once every time we’re in town. Also, the owners were featured on Wisconsin public television a few years ago. Make sure you check it out!

Honestly. The hot Sammy was the best sandwich I’ve had in my entire life. Warm meats with perfectly baked bread. I was shocked how good the food was. A bit pricier but you absolutely get what you pay for. Outstanding..

Delicious sandwich, soup and cookie! The turkey and Brie is magnificent! I could only eat half because it was so big, but excited to finish it late. The tomato basil soup was fabulous and the cookie was the best way to finish! The staff was so friendly and the cooks are polite and handsome.

I didn’t walk into Door County Creamery with low expectations—quite the opposite. The place had a constant stream of people coming and going, which immediately told me it was somewhere worth checking out. After seeing the line move quickly and watching how many people left smiling, I figured there had to be a reason. I decided to try their coffee-flavored ice cream, and it was absolutely fantastic. The flavor was deep and authentic, with that perfect balance of roasted coffee taste and creamy sweetness. It wasn’t artificial or overly sugary—just smooth, rich, and perfectly crafted. Every bite felt like it was made with care and quality ingredients. The atmosphere inside was welcoming and upbeat. Even with how busy it was, the staff handled everything efficiently and with a smile. The shop was clean, inviting, and had that unmistakable Door County charm. Overall, this place exceeded my expectations and left a lasting impression. I’d go back in a heartbeat and recommend it to anyone looking for great ice cream and a genuinely enjoyable experience in Door County.

We love the creamery! It is a must stop when in Sister Bay; it’s very rare that we don’t make multiple stops there!

I'm a Milwaukee food writer and make it my mission to find great sandwiches. I had the Turkey Brie and it was to die for! Big portions, otherwise I would have tried another sandwich. Hope I have time to go back!

Great gelato. We tried two of their Stracciatella flavors, cherry and the base flavor. I'd give them an extra star because they are made with goat milk. We also got a couple of their chèvre, which were both quite tasty (particularly the cherry one)

super cute spot in door country that has sandwiches, gelato and sells various knick knacks as well! really nice to sit outside on a hot summer day for lunch. i really enjoyed the hot honey and mozzarella sandwiches - the hot honey sandwich had crispy onion that really pulled it together. the mozzarella is a basic but a classic, you really can't go wrong with this one. you order at the counter and they'll text you once your order is ready!

It was after the breakfast hour but the restaurant was still serving breakfast sandwiches and that is what we were looking for, breakfast. We ordered two bacon and egg sandwiches and grabbed a table outside to wait for our order. Nice options for breakfast sandwiches and indoor and outdoor seating available. The girl at the counter was not overly friendly but took our order and we paid and waited outside until we were texted that our order was ready. The sandwiches came with fruit that was pretty good (with the exception of the strawberries that were turning brown) and chips. Three of us were splitting the two sandwiches which was plenty of food. The major complaint and we did not address it due to being hungry and not wanting to have to wait for them to remake our sandwiches was that they served us the wrong sandwiches. We specifically asked for the bacon and egg since it was served on a croissant roll. Which is what we wanted. But our sandwiches came on a thicker bread that my friend could not eat due to stomach issues. Additionally, neither sandwich had an egg on it. So we had a huge hunk of cheese, bacon, the greens and sauce. It was OK but again not what we asked for. I was a bit distressed by the behavior of one of the workers. Behind the counter there was a tray of pastry, croissants, cookies, etc. As my friend was ordering I watched an employee stand in front of those baked items looking them over. She then handled one of the croissants to look at it, put it back down then took a cookie and walked away eating the cookie. And she did not have gloves on. That was a big distressing. So I was glad we didn't get our sandwich on the croissant but again, not a great dinning experience.

Absolutely LOVED their gelato! I wanted to try so many of the flavors, but the one that I got did not disappoint (and I am sure that all are equally as delicious). I am so bummed because I didn't have it in me to also order their real food (i.e. the sandwiches) that I wanted to try, but I will have to save that for next time. The inside of the shop is also cute where you can get some Door County Creamery cheese to take home amongst other foods/gifts. I went at kind of an odd time (about 3pm) so it was not super busy, but I can imagine that they would be busier and slower in service during peak season and breakfast/lunch hours.

Love this spot, outdoor seating only but tables are all along the wrap around deck. Highly recommend mozzarella sandwich & Arnold Palmer! My kiddos love the pizza rolls. Haven't tried the gelato yet but it's on my list (it's the only thing I managed to get a photo of). Place your order then browse the charming gift shop while you wait for your food. The staff has always been friendly even in the busiest of times, definitely a must stop in Sister Bay!

Gelato was delicious and the food smelled amazing! Beautiful shop with great service. Cute place to sit outside and the help was very courteous

Have been looking forward to trying the food at door county creamery and it did not disappoint. We got the burrata salad and the roast beef Philly sandwich. Both were really good and we would recommend!

Omg my sandwich was so tasty!! I had the hot honey (chefs kiss). I came to visit on the weekend so there was a little line witch was no big. However, the line went fast and my food didn't take that long either. While i did wait in line and to get my food they had stuff to look at if you were interested in buy some gifts or souvenir.The inside was a little small but so much to look at. If you haven't heard of this place or was thinking about trying it you must!

We like going here for the sandwiches and salads which are amazing, hearty, well-balanced in flavors. The fresh bread rolls they are on, the quality cheese and goat cheese, the fresh greens, the fact they don't skimp on the sauces and spreads: all make a fantastic picnic feast. Highly recommend the beets sandwich. Prepare to be blown away.

When at sisters Bay you have to eat at Door County Creamery. They don't have too many selection of ice creams but the flavors they have taste great. We had Various ice creams but really liked Door County Cheery and Ultimate Oreo. However if you can have just one then you have get Chocolate Raspberry Truffle. This is the best flavor they have.

Some of the best ice cream I've ever eaten. I would highly recommend stopping here. Nice outside spot to sit.

Must stop here for gelato and a meal at least once or twice when visiting Door. Can't get enough of the goat cheese as well. We usually take a pack to go on the way home.

We had the turkey Brie sandwich once before, and it was fine. In fact, quite yummy. Inconsistency is the word of the day. Something wet was running out of the sandwich and made everything soggy including the bread. The meat was too wet and soggy. If you like salt, you'll love the beef barley soup. Sooo much salt. The owner might want to monitor the way the employees are cooking their dishes or they could go under. It happens all the time. The "cook's" sandwich making process is a big part of the problem. You can't stack sandwiches with bread on top of the other sandwiches' meats exposed, he had them stacked in preparation. Take note, owner! Mind your employees!

We go to Door County Creamery in Sister Bay every time we visit. We had the turkey Brie sandwich and French Ham Sandwich. Fun to share half and half. Outdoor dining.

Me encanta todo de este lugar, es de mis favoritos en Door County desde hace muchos años. Su comida es deliciosa y utilizan ingredientes de alta calidad, el servicio es siempre bueno. Me encanta que puedes pedir en línea y tú orden siempre está a tiempo. Totalmente recomendado.

Adorable place with food, drinks and gifts. We tried the chocolate croissant and overnight oats. Both were delicious. You order inside, take it to go or sit outside. Great atmosphere. We really liked it.

Visited again since we found this gem last time in Door County. I had the gyros and it was definitely their awesome take on a classic! My wife had the Fall Salad and she said it was very tasty and clean. It looked amazing. I'm sorry I don't have any photos as we were starving when we were called to pickup our lunch. Seating is all outside now but they text you when the food is ready.

These were the best sandwiches we've ever had. These guys have nailed it. We tried 4 different sandwiches and French onion soup, purchased two bottles of wine. They also have a large local cheese selection and gift shop. Seems like a family run operation. If I lived in the area, I'd eat here weekly I'm sure. The Hot Honey and Roast Beef were just wow. Skip the fancy restaurant for lunch and come here.

DCC honesty keeps getting better. All the gelato, wild ramp goat cheese, and sandwiches are incredible. We went back 4 days in a row for the kids pizza roll ups, too.

Food is fantastic! I keep thinking about the BLT and chocolate chip cookie! Love the coleslaw that comes as a side. I do wish they had some cheaper children's menu options - paying $9 for a 2 year old's meal isn't ideal. Their store is so well curated. Unique finds, unlike some of the other stores in Door Co. Wine, home decor, kitchen/entertaining items, really cute kid stuff, and great goats milk soap! Not to mention all their other food treats!

If you have a love of goats, this is the place for you to visit. Earlier in the day we saw goats roaming around and then stumbled upon the is adorable ice cream and gelato shop. There is goat merchandise everywhere so we could only assume the gelato and ice cream was made with goat milk, which in fact it is! You guys when I tell you this ice cream knocked my socks off PHEW! It was SO GOOD. I ordered the salted Carmel and it was just perfection, so creamy and delicious.

Great gelato and really delicious sandwiches. The gelato was flavorful and so delicious. Came here 4 times on my 5-day trip :)

Very good but expensive cookies. $3.50 each. If you need a cookie, pay it. If you can wait, learn to bake and make them for 35 cents.

Some friends and I travelled from Louisiana to Door County this fall to see the leaves change. We stopped in at this place, and I wasn't that hungry. A friend and I split the turkey sandwich and when I tell you I STILL HAVE DREAMS ABOUT THAT SANDWICH. It's been a month and I came onto Yelp to find a picture to see if I can recreate it. It's that good. Just try one. If they were still open at this point in the year I might drive the 18.5 hours to get my hands on another sandwich.

I came back a second time on my trip for the turkey brie sandwich. It was incredible.

We had the French ham sandwich to go, delicious! Came with chips and 2 small pickles. The shop was really cute and gelato looked great

Maybe the best food in Sister Bay. Excellent service, as well. Breakfast, snacks, delicious baked goods...so many great options.

We've had gelato across the US and Europe. Quite simply the best we've ever had!!! The sea salt olive oil will blow you away. We also had peanut butter stracciatella and cookie dough. This is 10 stars in my opinion! Looking forward to having again the next 3 days and I'll be going with the pint!

This place was one of THE best parts of our trip to Door County. Stopped in on a whim and booked the farm tour for the following day, which comes with lunch at the end. The owners and all the employees have such a clear love and passion for what they do and the products they produce; and it shows in their cheese, their food, and their store. LOVED the tour. Informative, fun, and beautiful. Gelato was top notch. Sandwiches were unbelievable. My wife's Turkey and Brie was "one of the best" sandwiches she's ever had. Thank you, Door County Creamery, for being such a memorable (and delicious) part of our vacation!

Door County Creamery had an excellent lunch! Thai red curry soup was excellent, not overly curry-y and the coconut milk wasn't overpowering either. The cream was an excellent addition, as was the small bag of bread that accompanied the soup. The Lox and Cream on pumpernickel bagel was equally (surprisingly) delicious. Normally I like my mix and cream simple: bagel, cream cheese, lox, side of capers, onions and tomatoes. But this one was pumpernickel bagel, heavy whipped cream cheese, lox, topped with arugula, pickled onions, an "everything" bagel seasoning and some type of mustardy, pesto sauce. It was a great blend of spices and enough for us to share 1 for lunch. A little chintzy on the chips but it's aight, the lox and cream was where it was at. Outdoor seating was limited, no social distancing in or around here, but everyone was respectful as much as possible.

We were only in Door County for for five days on a girl trip in mid-august. We did a bit of research and the creamery was one of the must do's. In all fairness that's one of the things I really liked about the area... Didn't have a bad meal the whole time. So many good restaurants and such good food for such a small little area. We stayed in Sister Bay. The creamery is a must such a cute little place. All kinds of cheese and goat cheese items. Wine ECT. We did miss out on the goat gelato we are just too full had some kind of turkey brie sandwich that was amazing the salad that came with it was not good but the sandwich in the bread was delightful. We shared a petite cheese platter that also had some figs and fruit and some other little things on it. Oh my gosh it was so good and we are so full. Because we decided to do one wine tasting a day on our trip. They said they did not do wine tasting but that we could sample wine if you're interested in buying a glass. We didn't do wine there.

The most delicious sandwiches, we could've eaten here everyday! Also their goat cheese they sell here as well is so fresh and amazing! Definitely planning on coming back next time we're in the area.

Coconut candy bar Gelato was amazing! Goat beef stick and cherry chèvre also really awesome! Cute gifts available in the shop. The staff was nice and answered questions.

Amazing gelato. Highly recommend the yogurt and berries flavor if they have it. I dream about it!!

Stopped in while spending a day in Sister Bay because I saw a sign that they had gelato, and well, who doesn't like gelato? After sampling a few different flavors, I settled for orange. It was a small cup of smooth, creamy deliciousness. There are tables to either sit out on the patio or inside. I noticed they sell lunch items also, but my main mission was the gelato. I was not disappointed!

I dare you to post a bad review here. Been coming for years and somehow it gets better every time. Just go. Get some food to go and sit by the beach and enjoy. BLT is incredible. That beet sandwich is unreal. Salads, etc... never had anything that wasn't absolutely delicious.

Holy cow! Or is it goat? This place has delicious lunches made with fresh ingredients. I could probably eat here every day for the rest of the trip and be happy. I ordered the special suit under a day which was a Thai chicken curry and it did not disappoint. Perfectly seasoned and with a kick. We each ordered sandwiches - Mine was a mozzarella, prosciutto and pesto creation on a crusty loaf. Each sammie came with a mixed green salad and pickle. Beautiful out door seating and samples galore inside the shop! Win!

This was on my must see list for my trip to Door County since it looked so unique, it definitely matched the high expectations I had for it. It's located in a cute area and had a lot of wine, goat's milk soap and food options. I bought the pink sugary and lemongrass goat's milk soaps. So far Ive tried the pink sugary and its really smooth and creamy as far as soaps go, it's seems very natural. Ordered the beet salad which was frickin' huge, definitely a two or more person salad. It was good but made me realize I don't particularly like beets but the fresh chevre, watermelon radish, walnut and balsamic part of it was good. Also bought a Tozai Snow Maiden Sake. I don't usually ever drink sake but just like I judge books by their cover, I judge wine and I guess sake, by their wrappers. This bottle was just too pretty to pass up, it ended up being surprisingly good served chilled and was also very smooth and creamy. Couldn't pass up a pastry while I was there so decided on the peach ginger pop tart, which was a funky flavor and had an incredibly yummy, buttery crust. Sat outside eating my salad and it was the definition of pleasant on a fine DC summer day. Door County Creamery is pure goodness.

It's not all that often that you find a spot that's so quintessentially local that it's maintained its quality and appeal even after becoming a go-to tourist spot. Door County Creamery is all those things, and they do everything well. Star 1: How were the service and atmosphere? Imagine with me if you will a quaint little Swiss creamery. You've got cows pasturing in the back, friendly service in a cozy atmosphere, and a wide range of diary products. Got it? Well now move it to Wisconsin and turn the cows into goats. Bingo. Star. Star 2: How were the portions relative to the cost? So it turns out goat products are slightly more expensive than traditional cow products, but that shouldn't be surprising. The prices at Door County Creamery are reasonable. Star. Stars 3 and 4: How was the food? I'll confess right now that I don't really care for goat cheese, so I was a bit hesitant upon strolling into a goat creamery and ordering, of all things, salted caramel goat milk gelato. Did I enjoy it as much as traditional gelato? I didn't, but it was damn close, and I can say with confidence that this was the best goat cheese or milk product I've ever had. The cookie was rock solid as well although probably could have been a bit softer. Two Stars. Star 5: Would you eat here every day if you could? Absolutely. This is THE Door County staple. Star.

What an amazing little spot in Sister Bay. This review is for both the Farm Tour & the shop. The tour is well worth the $. You get to try cheese, gelato, play and pet so many goats, see how the farm operates and then have an amazing lunch on the patio. I would do it again in a heartbeat. This is a family owned shop and the prices are reasonable, the food is SO good and the owners are so nice. A must stop when in Door County

Door County Creamery is more than just goat cheese and gelato. My mom, sisters and I each bought a bar of goat's milk soap. Super affordable at just $6.00. The cherry blossom scent was my choice. They're made by one of the owners who raises goats nearby. We would have eaten here if we had one more day, and didn't stuff ourselves with local cherries and cheeses at our complimentary hotel breakfast buffet. I guess I'll have to return to Door County, which is alright by me.

Cute small place with sandwiches coffee wine and ice cream. The chocolate cookie with black coffee was six bucks plus change. Very chocolate cookie, coffee hot and delicious.

I don't know why yelp says this place is closed cause I was just here a week ago. They are very big on goat cheeses and (probably) goat ice cream so come if you're a fan of that. I got the irish cream and almond fig ice creams. Very smooth and creamy!

My all time favorite place this summer, everything I've tried so far is amazing, the summer salad is especially good!:)

We went to to Door County Creamery after searching for the highest reviewed lunch place in the peninsula. We were not disappointing! I got the mozzarella sandwich which was perfection! But the real test was that both of the people I was eating with raved about their food as well. One of my companions got the soup and cheese board... can we just talk about what a great idea that is? Soup and cheese and bread... umm how did I not know that was a thing? The creamery also serves gelato, which you should save room for... if you can.

Everything here is gourmet and delicious. Highly recommend their cheese and charcuterie platter. We order one for pickup when friends visit and it is a hit.

"This is some of the best food I have had in years." Said my husband as we were eating here. We ate here a few years ago and thought it was great then. It has only gotten better! We ate here two lunches in a row. Amazing Kale Salad both days, and amazing sandwiches. Our favorite sandwich was the Lamb Gyro ~ phenomenal! And the bread products and cheese here are outstanding. And to push ourselves over the edge, we had the cherry gelato ~which was the best gelato/ice cream we have ever had (even better than that place in the Marais in Paris we loved!) Loved sitting on the patio soaking up the sun and it was great to meet one of the owners -say Thank You if you do. If you are walking by pondering where to go, ponder no more and go in!! We will be back.

The gelato is amazing but the absolute must try is the sorbet. The sorbet is so creamery you will question whether it has dairy or in. It is sorbet like no other. Absolute favorite is coconut (wish that had it every time!) blueberry, lemon, and strawberry are fantastic too.

Amazing cheese choices ! Cute little cafe for lunch. The tables outside were full, so we took our lunch to go and walked one block to have lunch at one of the many picnic tables on Lake Michigan.

You're in for a good time here. The place is pretty busy and it is laissez-faire on the samples of cheese, which is nice. There are fun gifts including soaps, wines, and everything else in between. However, the reason you're here is the food. A disclaimer is my SO and I aren't big on goat's cheese (I can handle it slightly more than my SO can). That being said, the spreads were tasty and the gelato held no hints of that aftertaste we so despise! We tried the charcuterie board (a bit pricey, $25 but well worth it) as well as the sandwich of the day which had gruyere cheese and ham. I have to start off by say, the bread here is fantastic (I know we're here to review a creamery, but I still can't get over how fresh and tasty the crusty bread was). The charcuterie board is a necessary splurge. It is wonderfully presented, and we requested for non-goat cheese options on our board, which was generously accommodated. It came with olive-oil drizzled bread and delicious meats (they were all very tasty and there was good variety). To be honest, the cheeses we tried on the charcuterie weren't amazing/the best I have had (but then again, it was because we were picky and not eating the specialties of the place), but still very worth the try. The sandwich was served with a side of pesto pasta that was also quite delicious. Overall, we had a very pleasant afternoon; there was outdoor seating so we were able to eat outside and people watch. We were able to walk off the extremely rich meal we had by strolling along the street and looking at the shops around the area. I would say this is a Door County must!