Christopher C.
Yelp
We stumbled upon Dumpling Story after finding out the line for the other dumpling shop we intended to go to was out the door and seating was limited. Dumpling Story, if the name of the restaurant doesn't give it away is a restaurant that serves dumplings. Soup dumplings specifically.
The restaurant has a modern aesthetic with an IKEA ambiance that resembles something that one would find in Williamsburg or Astoria. You order your food either by scanning a QR code on the table or through an iPad that they'll bring to the table. The variety of dumplings offered is impressive for the size of the operation.
There's the traditional pork soup dumpling which had decent flavor and a good amount of soup, but the skin lacked the rubberlyness that one would find at this price point. Simply put, if you're expecting to find Din Tai Fung quality and precision, you're in the wrong place. What they do, do well is homestyle Shanghainese dumplings with a twist. The Peking Duck and Pork dumplings was a nice twist with a decent amount of flavor. The braised beef noodle soup with the sweet potato noodles had a nice contrast between sweet and salty. The pork and leek wonton soup was a disappointment, lacking the nuance and precision needed to elevate the dish. In fact, somehow they were able to include a large piece of leek into one of the dumplings.
The ordering process while simplistic lead to some confusion if you're not careful. They tried to upsell you into getting the meal, which includes a braised pork bun, a drink and dessert with an order of dumplings. If you're there by yourself for a quick meal then that's fine, but if you're there trying to try different variations of their menu, it's an unnecessary obstacle that really turns off the customer. Also, I understand this is Chinatown in NYC, but the price point felt a little high for the portion sizes and while they do execute most of the dishes proficiently, be aware that this is a tourist and hipster destination. If you're looking for an authentic soup dumpling experience where all the Asians go to, this will not be the place, but if you're around Chinatown and are craving dumplings, you can do worst than enjoying a meal at Dumpling Story.