Daniel B.
Yelp
As a fan of the Rocky movies and The Sopranos TV show, how can I not like a restaurant that has sandwiches called "Balboa's Beefsteak" and "Spicy Gabagool?" My wife and I both discovered Eastcut Sandwich Bar using Yelp. Specifically, I searched for a takeout place near us. Eastcut offers online ordering which I like because I can pay online and just show up to the restaurant in-person to pick up. It was fast and convenient.
I placed my order on a Sunday at 2:30pm and the website (Toast POS platform) said my order would be ready at 2:55pm. I received a phone call from the restaurant at 2:53pm to let me know my order was ready and that they were closing at 3:00pm. At the time of writing this review, Eastcut is open Tuesday-Saturday, 11am-8pm, and Sunday, 11am-3pm. They're closed Monday.
I pulled into the lot right at 2:55 and the friendly employee who called me came outside to greet me with my brown bag order. I was in and out in a flash.
Here's what I got:
Share Plates
* Housemade Mozz Sticks ($9) - hand-breaded housemade fresh mozzarella with choice of tomato or ranch dipping sauce (I chose tomato)
Classic Sandwiches
* Spicy Gabagool (round $8.95, hero $13.95; I chose round) - Italian ham, hot capicola, salami, housemade fresh mozzarella, shredded lettuce, tomato, spicy mayo, house vinaigrette, sesame roll
Cutlet Sandwiches
* East-Katsu (round $8.25, hero $13.25; I chose round) - crispy chicken or eggplant cutlet (I chose chicken), house kimchi, tomato, pickled red onion, cilantro, sweet soy, spicy mayo, sesame roll
Sandwiches from the Flat-Top
* Kimchi Reuben ($10.75) - corned beef, Swiss, house kimchi, Russian, rustic sourdough
* Balboa's Beefsteak ($12.75) - grilled steak, grilled onion, American cheese, housemade fresh mozzarella, pesto aioli (nut-free), sesame hero roll
Sides:
* Curly Fries ($3)
* Sweet Potato Tots ($3)
My wife originally wanted a Brie Bird which was a Blackboard Special, but the restaurant was out of stock. The Brie Bird was made with house-roasted turkey, brie spread, pepper jelly, mixed greens, and tomato, among other ingredients.
In general, we thought the food was good. Nothing was disappointing nor underwhelming, except for maybe the East-Katsu for me. My wife and I had different opinions. She preferred the East-Katsu and Spicy Gabagool sandwiches while I preferred the Kimchi Reuben and Balboa's Beefsteak sandwiches (by far). We both enjoyed the Housemade Mozz Sticks as well as the Curly Fries and Sweet Potato Tots.
The East-Katsu was a little underwhelming to me because I thought the sandwich, overall, could've been a bit more flavorful; the chicken cutlet in particular. Also, the sandwich didn't travel well for takeout. My drive home from Eastcut was about 10-15 minutes and it was probably another five minutes before I actually unwrapped the sandwich. By that time, the bottom bun was already soaked and soggy. Who knows how long the sandwich had been sitting at the restaurant? I'm sure the East-Katsu is a better experience when eaten at the restaurant as a dine-in item.
I noticed how the sandwiches were wrapped differently, both in type of wrapper (foil, paper, wax-lined) and wrapping method (fold, roll, double-wrap), depending on the sandwich. That's a level of attention and detail that I appreciate. You can tell these guys take their sandwiches seriously.
I've been on a Sopranos kick this year (yeah, I know, I'm 22 years late) and the Spicy Gabagool immediately stood out to me because of that. Rarely have I seen capicola referred to as gabagool on a restaurant menu (or maybe I just hadn't noticed until recently). I love a good Italian sandwich and Eastcut's Spicy Gabagool was just that. Now I will say it didn't knock my socks off (again, like the East-Katsu, I was hoping for more flavor), but I'd order it again. I wasn't a huge fan of the sesame-seed hamburger-style buns used on the Spicy Gabagool and East-Katsu; just a little too plain and maybe too hard for me.
I thought both the Kimchi Reuben and Balboa's Beefsteak were excellent. The Reuben is one of my favorite kinds of sandwiches. I also love kimchi. However, kimchi doesn't always work well when people try to "fuse" it with non-Korean cuisines. Eastcut got it right, in my opinion. The kimchi flavor in their Reuben was subtle, but noticeable. I liked that the kimchi flavor wasn't overpowering which allowed the other flavors of the Reuben to shine through. As far as the Balboa's Beefsteak, it's the best cheesesteak I've had in the Triangle to date. The meat and bread were the best parts, but all the ingredients were great and worked well together.
Do yourself a favor and get the Housemade Mozz Sticks. Ours were crispy and terrific.
Eastcut opened on July 16, 2018. Its founders are from New Jersey and The Bronx. The restaurant is located in a small freestanding building in an unassuming neighborhood, sort of off the main roads. If you don't see parking up front, there are several more spaces in the back.