Eataly NYC Flatiron

Today, I explored an incredible place called *Eataly*, and it was nothing short of amazing! 🇮🇹✨ This Italian market is like stepping into a little slice of Italy, right here in the city. From the moment you walk in, you’re surrounded by the rich aromas of authentic Italian cuisine 🍕🍝. The variety of restaurants is outstanding, offering everything from fresh pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, all made with high-quality ingredients 🍅🧀. But it doesn’t stop there! Eataly also features an extensive selection of Italian products 🍷🥖—from premium olive oils and artisan cheeses to freshly baked breads and desserts that are simply irresistible 🥐🍫. Whether you're a foodie, a lover of Italian culture, or just someone looking for a unique culinary experience, Eataly is the perfect destination. Highly recommend visiting this food lover's paradise! 🌟

Eataly is a must see. We lived in Italy for 3 years and this will take you back with all the imported goods they have. We stopped in at La Pizza & La Pasta to have pizza and drinks and they were wonderful. The pizza was light, flavorful and filling! Right by the flatiron building! Definitely make a reservation so you won’t have to wait! This location is better then the World Trade Center location (in my opinion)

This is a charming spot for anyone who loves Italian cuisine. Whether you’re stopping by for grocery shopping, a quick breakfast, a leisurely lunch, a mid-day Spuntino or a nice dinner, you’ll always find a welcoming space. I’ll keep coming back for the delicious focaccias, the freshness of the pasta and fish, and the variety of fruits, desserts, and gelatos that never disappoint.

Good customer service. Vibrant market with high quality selections. Pasta made on site. The seafood section smells great, no stank or harsh fish odors, clean and fresh.

Fortunate to work nearby this awesome place. It’s a supermarket. It’s a restaurant. It’s a cafe. It’s a restaurant. It’s a little theme park. It’s a little culinary museum. It’s not a place to where you can purchase things at affordable prices. You can walk 1.5 blocks to Trader Joe’s for that purpose. Prices are often marked up 2-3 times of nearby supermarket. However, the experience you get here is unparalleled. Visiting Rome/Napoli/Firenze is not within your reach, then visiting this Eataly may satisfy your desires of Italian gourmet craving. Well, partially. And the pizza/pasta restaurant actually presents some values. Pricing is not bad at all and of course, you will experience some of the finest Italian pasta/pizza in NYC. If your NYC traveling plan includes a visit to the Flatiron district, then this place shall not be missed out.

As you walk into this location, you automatically feel like you’re in parts of Italy 🇮🇹!! It’s incredible how this concept of having Bars, Restaurants, Cafes, Bakery Shops, ect is so amazing!! You even have a space to buy your own groceries & Vegetables!!! Absolutely outstanding and my coffee was delicious and my food and Drink was so good!! The service was also on point and my bartender/server was very on top of my needs… thank you so much Eataly and I will be back!! If you want to have a taste of Italy 🇮🇹 in ever way, come here to Eataly!! 100% Authentic

Visiting Eataly is always a joy. It's a place where you can browse the wonderful merchandise or sit & relax with a simple coffee/pastry/gelato or appertif, lunch, dinner etc. The place just says take a break and be Italian for a moment. The dishes in each area restaurant are thought out and finely prepared. Your sure to find a gift for someone whether they are a foodie or not. The variety of Italian products from pasta, EVOO, cheeses, can goods, chocolate, housewares is endless.  Over the years I've found the staff to be friendly and accommodating. Whether you live nearby or you're visiting NYC Eataly is a must see! The surrounding area (Flatiron) offers beautiful sightseeing of Architecture, parks, small museums and other fine restaurants.

I loved the overall vibe of the place. Pizza was good, desserts and coffee were delicious. Staff was very friendly. My husband and I went there a couple of times just to sit, relax and have some coffee after a day of walking through the city.

The entire experience. All the foodand grocery options. The roof top was a special bonus!

Eataly never disappoints--especially when it comes to gelato. Smooth, rich, and perfectly balanced in sweetness, the gelato here continues to be a standout every single time. Tried the lemon cake this time and it was a pleasant surprise. The flavor was refreshingly zesty, with a hint of complexity that made it more than just your average citrus dessert. The sponge was light and airy--just the right texture to complement the bright flavor. Whether you're popping in for a quick scoop or browsing the bakery for a treat, Eataly always delivers on quality.

So....since the new location is not up on Yelp yet (corner of 49th and Avenue of the Americas by Rockerfeller Center) I'll do my review here. I've had your food elsewhere (this one location in particular) and loved it every time I've gone. The fresh pasta you have for sale amazing as well. However, I'm a bit saddened and upset with the opening of this new location in midtown. It's been advertised for the past year, and this week I've been trying to get to the location to purchase a sandwich or other items and all I've seen have been opening parties for Junior Middle Level Management dikwads with only a sign saying it was opening May 15 at 5 pm to the public. I get it, you're trying to promote company events to order catering from you, but I hope you remember that there's also that one person such as myself that works in the area and also wants to enjoy the experience with this new location. Today, being it was opened I said to myself I finally can go and grab me a sandwich only to find myself behind 100 NYU grads and family ordering...so I walked out. If this is going to be the experience then I'll have to pass. For you guys it's great because you'll always have customers and you'll be fine. Hopefully my company will order from you guys and I'll try your food then. Thanks.

I purchased a couple of pastries from La Pasticceria inside of Eataly. There were so many options to choose from and everything looked delicious. I wanted one of each, but decided on a slice of the Caramello and the Terracotta. The Caramello was caramel dessert and had what seemed like a chocolate mousse. The layers surrounded the mousse tasted like caramel and almost had a pudding consistency. Overall, it wasn't a bad tasting dessert just not my favorite. The Terracotta intrigued me because it looked like a cube of chocolate and I wondered what was inside. The outside layer of chocolate was divine. Absolutely delicious. As you keep eating, you'll taste a caramel center towards the bottom and a dark cookie like crust. This was my favorite dessert. I didn't expect it to blow me away like it did. I highly recommend trying this dessert.

I came here late night with some friends and everything had pretty much closed except the restaurant. We ordered the pizza and some pasta- it could be our American taste buds but the pastas and pizza were very light and we felt like it needed more salt or seasoning. Our waiter wasn't that attentive and we had to keep finding him. Overall food was decent but way overpriced for some mediocre food in my opinion.

Love love love! One of my favorite places in the entire U.S Lots of eateries and fresh Italian produce to choose from. I have enjoyed the pasta trio with a lovely glass of vino. I enjoyed making my own fresh charcuterie board and sitting outside in the perfect weather to enjoy it with great company. Staff are always knowledgeable and professional. They are quick to make sure you have a great experience.

I stopped by Eataly near the WTC and tried two pasta dishes from their quick-serve counter. Service was fast, portions were decent, and both pastas tasted better than expected--fresh and flavorful. Great option if you're in the area and looking for a casual, affordable meal without sitting down. Bonus: They also sell aged steaks, seafood, and Italian cold cuts in the grocery section--sometimes with discounts. Worth a look if you're shopping nearby.

Café Lavazza is located inside the busy Eataly grocery market. While it's a bit pricey, they offer a wide variety of pastries and gelato. I love this particular location because I can enjoy my coffee while sitting outside across the beautiful Madison Square Park.

If you haven't been to an Eataly, you're missing out! It's all things Italian and almost evening is prepared fresh. It's kind of like a grocery store but more even. There's a sit down restaurant inside as well and a cafe right by the entrance as well. It can get busy here so be ready for somewhat of a crowd. You can get fresh made pasta and most of the to to go stuff is prepared the same day as well.

Il Gran Caffe in Eataly is holding a Tiramisu Festival. This will run through early July. Six varieties of the renowned dessert are offered and are in disposable jars. I paired the pistachio tiramisu with a cappuccino. This tiny dessert had crunch and cream but somehow needed more flavor and was more solidified. At $10.99 each tiramisu this makes for a rather expensive dessert. Just being here is pleasurable. I have been coming here since it opened and eaten countless pastries and drunk many types of coffee. Service is fine but often more people should be manning the station.

Walked in to my favorite Italian store in NY as it's been on my list to try out for a while. The place lived up to my expectations. Walked into the coffee bar followed by the Gelato station and a tasting table where they were sampling Panettone . Waked in further to aisles stocked with Italian cookies and chocolates , spices, pasta and more . The path leads you to am array of Italian sweet treat's , pastries tarts and tempting cakes colorfully topped with assorted goodies in different shapes and sizes . I picked the pistachio loaf and couldn't be happier with its texture and flavor. There was a long wait to get to pick your pasty choice but the beautiful ambiance and colorful eye catching display kept me going . The store continued to amaze me with the next aisle of pickled items like olives, pasta sauce options , deli meat choices and more galore ! There is a sit down restaurant , a meat section and a bountiful of food selections to eat & take home It's like an Italian wonderland that sucks you in and could get to be an expensive but worthwhile experience.

We visited La Pizza & La Pasta on a Friday for lunch. Everything my friends & I had was amazing - I particularly enjoyed the Lambrusco, margherita pizza, broccolini, and focaccia! The pizza is about as close as I've come to real Italian pizza in the US! I've been thinking about it ever since and look forward to going back.

My hubs had never gone to Eataly so as a rite of passage, we went to the large location in Flat Iron. I always love the energy and wide variety of stalls whether you are looking for groceries, speciality cheese and bread or wanting to enjoy a bite. We went for dinner and the service was quick and efficient. Our waiter offered us some suggestions but we had our hearts set on cacio e pepe, side of bread and mozzarella. I was genuinely disappointed by the bread, it was very hard and not fresh. I will say that the Cacio E Pepe was made with very fresh noodles and came close to what we had in Italy. Sadly nothing compares to Italy but we enjoyed it nonetheless.

This place is good stop by for the quick dessert! Post dinner, had a craving for their Chocolate Gelato and it was wonderful!! They do have options of non dairy which worked for me! The service is quick and the ambiance is fun to walk around or just to stop by and have a good coffee and dessert stop! Do go here on the late evening and enjoy a good dessert and coffee, they have plenty options to select from besides Gelatos!

Review for their holiday panettone: would recommend! Panettone is a sweet bread loaf served during the winter holidays usually with candied fruits or other toppings added. Eataly makes several variations: limoncello, pistachio cream, classic, and pear & chocolate. They're prepared with a lievito madre (mother yeast), eggs and Bourbon vanilla and the classic version I tried included raisins and candied orange peel. The bread was pillowy, soft, sweet with a strong note of citrus and a dab of bourbon. Goes terrific with a black coffee, maybe slightly too sweet though with a coffee wil help balance it out.

My absolute fav place to go when you just want to sample, have a good slow time savoring your food and relaxing is your focus. Had such a good time here browsing the aisles full of Italian goods, confections and groceries. Also an amazing place for good from such a variety of offerings. Had the rotisserie chicken, tiramisu and a glass of Prosecco from 3 diff counters. Has great seating, service is top notch and it's like you are in indoor streets of a city.

We made a reservation for 1:45. We waited 35 minutes for our first course. Food was good after walking all morning we needed to eat.

You don't come here for bargain prices. You come here for extraordinary variety and superior quality. And Eataly comes through. If you have skills in the kitchen, you can get fresh fish of all kinds, mushrooms you can't find elsewhere and the list goes on And on. And on. Produce, meats, pastas, cheeses, chocolates, etc etc. This is a destination grocer, and my wife and I come down from Buffalo, NY a few times a year to stock up.

We went here right after lunch hour but the place was still really busy. You decided to get a table in the Italian restaurant and the woman at the front told us she could see us if we promised to be done in exactly an hour. So we took her up on it rather than wait for a different table. Service was good and food was ok, nothing really special as it was just salad and a pizza NYC prices.

Il Gelato is one of my favorite spots downtown for sweet treats. This time I tried a Bombolato which took me a total of three attempts to finish! It was massive but tastes sooooo good I wouldn't dare let any of it go to waste!

A bit smaller than some of their other locations but still with the basic Italian groceries and a somewhat limited selection of quick serve options. Their main meat and pasta making station closed at 7:00 pm which was disappointing, leaving only the sit-down restaurant or focaccia sandwich area as options. It was a pleasant environment and the staff was working hard.

This is a very well known location in New York. Eataly is NOT a restaurant, it's similar to a shopping mall in the sense that it's comprised of multiple different smaller shops and cafes that all sell/serve Italian goods and foods. The bathrooms have very long waits. The location itself is very nice and feels Italian somewhat, and has great options for purchase. Overall, this place is good, but I wouldn't call it a must-see.

I love this place when I'm in NYC! It's a fun place to shop and see new product while getting some epic Italian! I've become obsessed with their pasta sampler. A great way to not have to choose which pasta when you're by yourself.

Just come here to have coffee at Cafe lavazza. Coffee always tasted good & so are the cakes. Theres seating available. As expected food & drinks are pricier than usual but worth it. love the vibe of this place. Always enjoy browsing all the Italian goodies & restaurants inside the same building. Bathroom is available. Accessible to public transport as well. Near Madison square park too.

This place can be really great. There's so much unique food made onsite and dry goods imported from Italy. If there's ever any oddly specific produce, meat, cheese or pasta needed for any recipe this is the place to go. Food can be pricey but it's a great place to bring tourists and family on their trip to NYC. There's always lots of classes and demos.

I recently hosted a cooking class at EATALY and I was so happy with how it all turned out. The staff was delightful to work with, the food was delicious and the guests had a blast. Would highly recommend!

I always love coming here. I came for my morning coffee and sat on the bench. I loved looking outside while sipping my cappuccino. To have your coffee look like this, you must order a cappuccino with whole milk. It won't work with almond milk or a latte.

Every time you're in the Flatiron area, make sure you stroll through Eataly. If you can't find it here, you probably won't need it. It's always fun, and mesmerizing, watching the Eataly eateries creating their magic (refer to the video). If you're not aware, Eataly also has a rooftop restaurant, Serra by Birreria, that is very good. They've covered every angle, are experts at their crafts, and attract the entire world.

Some may call Eataly a "tourist trap" and while I don't disagree, it is still an excellent stop for foodies local and otherwise. I got the prime rib sandwich here a few days ago, and while the price has gone up significantly (now $30... RIP) it is still generously piled with layers and layers of beef, seasoned with just the right amount of sea salt and EEVO (and nothing else). Not too fatty or salty, just *chef's kiss* perfection in simplicity. I shared half a sandwich with some veggie sides, and it was more than enough for me as a lunch portion. They make this sandwich to order, so it took maybe 5-8 mins to get my order. Stopped by the gelato stall afterwards to get a small scoop of indulgent and creamy pistachio gelato to round out a delicious meal. The entire food court is grab and go but they have open seating throughout the store and we did not have issues finding a place to eat.

I attended the pizza making class on a Friday evening. The instructors were really nice and charismatic. You get a free glass of wine, take home dough, pizza, and appetizers. If you don't want wine, you can also get San Pellegrino Limonata. Definitely seems like a couples activity! I do wish there were different types of appetizers or larger pizza since the class cost $100+. The place was beautiful but I do wish there was a bit more for a 1.5 hour experience.

This place was PACKED with people! Had a lot of different options and all looked so good. Ambiance was top tier and they went hard decorating for Christmas. Got some sandwiches and they were all pretty good.

The restaurants are honestly hit or miss but I love shopping here. The homemade pastas, butcher, etc are great but my favorite is the produce section. You'll find herbs, fruits, and veggies that you won't find in your typical grocery store. It is sometimes crowded with tourists but honestly it's worth a visit.

I visited on a Saturday night to try the Semolina cake and cappuccino. The cake was good but would have been better if warmed up. The cappuccino was delicious, slightly sweet, and definitely worth ordering. Seating is limited as it gets busy, but the atmosphere is very aesthetic!

Have been here multiple times in past few weeks to buy pasta for dinner, fruits, chicken, cheese. The place looks so cool with all different kinds of fruits. I have started getting their whole rotisserie chicken which is only $15 and has great seasoning. The cheese section has lots of variety with nodini di mozzarella being my favorite. The checkout lanes were always short, I usually take the self checkout and get done within a minute.

They work well. Its always stable and good pasta and pizza. Service is fine, not spectacular nor horrible. Ambiance is that of a market, which ties well with the style of the place.

Amalfi Pop-Up Rooftop Experience. I'm so sorry to leave this review. We were very excited to eat here. Unfortunately the Rooftop food was Cattivo! No good. I was surprised at how low quality it was. I'm well aware of Eataly's good reputation but the roof-top restaurant was not in the same ballpark. The service was kind but inattentive. The ambience was beautiful but LOUD. The food was not worthy of its perigee let alone its cost. For starters we had mozzarella and tomato Caprese. The tomatoes were ok (hot house) as was the mozzarella but the dish had Almost no olive oil, salt or basil. It was watery on the plate, indicating it had been sitting out and the mozzarella was weeping. This made it bland. We had fried calamari next. It was fried well and tender. Unfortunately. The calamari was so salty it was surprising. Especially since the dipping sauce didn't cut the salinity. It was in the batter. Next up, mussels. $27 They appeared fresh and well cleaned. Unfortunately there was no flavor to the broth. Even a drizzle of olive oil and perhaps parsley would have been great, but nothing was added aside from what tasted like hot water. As a result it was bellow serviceable. Next was TAGLIATA DI MANZO $36 Grilled Double R Ranch Hanger Steak, Salsa Verde. Surprise! it actually sucked. I ordered medium rare it arrived quickly, well done. Plus it was not a hanger steak. It was clearly a flatiron steak. Not nearly of the same quality. It was grey and mealy throughout (hanger doesn't do that. It has a longer muscle fiber and is more difficult to dry out) the salsa verde was a smear that had lost any gloss, telling me the steak had been sitting around after being dressed. Also wasn't seasoned well. I ate half of it. The roasted potatoes were delicious, though. Next was SPAGHETTO ALLA NERANO $27 Housemade Spaghetti "Alla Chitarra", Fried Zucchini, Parmigiano Reggiano. Perfectly cooked noodle in a sauce that could only be described as watery. No seasoning, nearly no olive oil, couldn't taste if there was any parm in there and no additional was offered. I understand a light pasta made with reduced pasta water. It can be incredible. This was not that. Watery, bland and odd. I'm not if sure if the sous chef walked off the job that night or what the deal was. The basics weren't on the plate. Did we send it all back? No we didn't. Why? Have you ever worked in a kitchen? When it's this far off it's not coming back any better. I'm sure they would have offered a refund or some redress. I know this low quality isn't their reputation but we just needed to leave. Walked to the bar to get the check. Paid. Left. Would I give the downstairs a try? Absolutely. This can't be indicative of their usual quality.

I love Eataly and should visit more in person! I will say, much of the recent premade savory food lacks spice and flavor -- pastas, sauces notably while the produce quality can be hit or miss but their desserts, pantry items, cheese selection, and freezer finds are basically bar none! There is so much to discover if you're shopping in store. You can watch live as their talented staff whips up various Italian/Italian-American classics.. or you can order grocery delivery as we typically do. Perfect store to pick up some antipasto before a Central Park picnic! I was recently surprised with a box of small desserts which included mini cream puffs, a mini chocolate torte, and some other cute little things, all of which were HEAVENLY (especially the pistachio cream puff.) Got a fruit tart during the same surprise which had a light sweetness with an equally light tart bite and was such a treat despite its messy presentation from a rough delivery trip which left a lot of fruit in a corner (I'm sure they originally had it arranged beautifully.) The fruit on top was perfectly ripe and it was a perfect size for a gathering of 6-10 people.

This place has almost everything Italian under one roof. If you enjoy chaos, then come here. Every single inch of this place is packed with Italian delicacies, snacks, treats, coffee, cheese, pasta, pizza, wine, bread, pastries and people who want to enjoy all of these things all at the same time. Just awesome!

Wow. This place is fancy. Gorgeous decor and such a cute deli and grocery selection. Everything in this place is imported and packaged beautifully. There are a few dining options, we sat at the front of the pantry and enjoyed strawberry mimosas (DELICIOUS), locks plate, spicy salami pizza and mushroom ricotta pizza. Not pictured because we ate it too fast is the gelato that we found adventuring towards the end of the store. I got the pistachio and my cousin got strawberry and it was the perfect dessert to wrap up lunch. We received everything very fast and everyone who works here is very kind.

A coffee shop located inside the Eataly grocery market. They have coffee, baked goods, chocolate specialty drinks and gelato. There is seating inside and good for people watching those that are walking past the flatiron building. Tried their iced mocha, not impressed as I've had better back in Vancouver. Couldn't taste much chocolate if at all for a mocha and for a place with a specialty drinks list that is mostly hot chocolates. The coffee taste was ok. Got a large for $7.

When Eataly first opened, I remember it being a must-visit landmark in Flatiron. While I and many others were enamored in the early days, the excitement seemed to taper off. It had been a couple years since I'd been, but after lunch in Flatiron this weekend, we decided to stop in for a few specialty grocery items. I had honestly forgotten how great Eataly really is. Amazing cheeses, freshly baked breads, ample seafood, fresh pasta, an incredible butcher and poultry selection, hard to find dairy products, massive selection of Italian pantry items and dry goods, rare fruits and vegetables, and a bigger mushroom selection than probably anywhere. Not to mention the various restaurants serving Italian wines, cheeseboards, whole roasted fish... We spent about an hour browsing around and picking out some items for a weekend supper. Of course there is a mark up, but Eataly is not as expensive as it could be, especially given the quality and curation of goods. They even carry my favorite Battenkill creamery milk I love with my coffee. If you're willing to handle the crowds, Eataly is still an impressive establishment worthy of a visit.

This is always a favorite stop of mine when in NYC! A great place to grab something delicious to take home or snag a seat at one of the bars for drinks and great Italian food! Such a cool Italians market vibe. Do not forget to buy some fresh made pasta and sauce while you are there! It is soooooo delicious! Also the prices on everything really are not bad especially considering the quality and location!

On my last night in NY, I wanted to have dinner at a more laid back location. I have been to Eataly in Chicago, and wanted to check out NY. It was very busy to my surprise on a Thursday night. I had the most delicious dinner, of course I went with my favorite option Seafood and Pasta. I had a glass of white wine & Linguini All'astice. If you're in the city check it out for lunch or dinner.

I really should give this place a 5 star. Only thing holding me back was the employees at the gelato bar. Customer service wasn't great. They seemed overwhelmed. But when I tell you this place is amazing and a one stop shop for everything...it met all my expectations. They even had a pop up rooftop bar.

Expensive but delicious Italian food. Spacious cafeteria style seating inside. Really tasty focaccia sandwiches.

Been here a few times for quick snacks and for brunch. All visit had been lovely. The food is very fresh and tasty.

I came here because it was the closest place to my hotel that was open. I thought it would be good, but I regret spending my money on this dry bolognese pasta. It was the worst pasta that I tried for $30+ dollars. Don't waste your time and money on this place especially in NYC when there's better options.

Aside from Little Italy, this is the closest, I will get to being in Italy. It's a food court/market with authentic Italian products! I overheard many people speaking Italian that were customers, which has to tell ya something. In addition, the food court has various options from a restaurant to pizza, sandwich shop..I wish I could recall my sandwich but it had prosciutto which tasted amazing! My husband has pizza-meat lovers type and it has been one of the best pizza slices I've had, considering in this same trip we had "joes pizza" from Times Square..doesn't compare!! Eatly captures, the ambiance of an Italian market for sure in the most pretty aesthetic.

The pasta is was fresh and tasted like spring with the pesto, tomatoes, and fresh ricotta. I had a delicious glass of Lombrusco. The service was good, did not rush me. The ambiance was nice to me, I sat at a bar and you could see the items for sale and people walking by. I would love to go again sometime.