Doug M.
Yelp
This is not a Mexican restaurant. Yes, it is food from or of Mexico, specifically the Yucatan peninsula or perhaps Mayan originality. But don't come in expecting a bowl of chips with salsa and a margarita or three. You won't find them here.
DO come in thinking of this as a tapas-style Yucatan/Mayan restaurant, one with richly flavored, crafted dishes. Now one of the owners did stop and chat with us (the other was busy cooking), and politely pushed back when I said I thought of El Molino as more of a Latin Tapas restaurant than a Mexican restaurant. He said it is Mexican food, and he's not wrong - but it's not what 'Muricans think of as Mexican food. Perhaps had I thought at the time to say Yucatan Tapas, he would not have objected. Regardless, we had great, flavorful food in a relaxed atmosphere.
The wife and I being teetotalers, I can't offer comment on the alcoholic drink menu. But we did order Champurrado de chocolate (Mexican hot chocolate), which was pretty tasty. For our food selections, we had never had any of the choices before. Even the taco was different - described as achiote-citrus pork, marinated onion, habanero. As was the tostada de ceviche Mexicano - shrimp, tomato, lime, onion, chile, cilantro. As I alluded above, every item was richly flavored, as well as being pleasingly crafted and presented. Their tortillas are not just cooked in house, but the (blue for ours) corn masa is actually milled in house.
Being, in my mind, a tapas restaurant, the menu is divided into antojitos (snacks), ligero (lighter fare), guisos (stews and braises), moles, and platos fuertes (larger plates). So there are over 30 choices, a pretty wide selection. And as with tapas restaurants, the prices can add up quickly. This is not atypical, even though I'm always a bit surprised when I get the bill at a tapas place. Of course, there is always the option to choose a couple of the platos fuertes as typical entrees and avoid the tapas route. Each item ordered came out when it was ready, rather than all at once. We were there early, so it wasn't yet crowded. Some dishes came quickly, but others took longer than I would have expected. That was no problem for us, as we were enjoying a relaxed dinner. But as the evening progressed, others may wind up with a longer wait for food than desired. For us, the flavors and attentive staff (which I neglected to mention above) made it a five start meal.