El Rey Rosticeria y Restaurante

Amazing diamond in the rough! The food was authentic and delicious! We came here before a near by concert for Quick bite. Everything was great service atmosphere cleanliness and price!

Do not get Mexican food anywhere else- you will regret it. This is the closest thing I've found to literally feeling like I'm back in Mexico, but they also have a twist on some traditional. The quesabirria was my favorite meal I've ever eaten in my entire life. Service was amazing.

Just had an amazing dinner here for our anniversary!! They had complimentary chips and dip, as well as tortillas with your meal. The amount of food was incredible and even better for the price! Everything was delicious; best meal I’ve had in a long time. The staff was also so helpful and accommodating. Thanks again, we will be back!

Unsuspecting spot for some good Mexican food. Everything tasted fresh and was really good. Portion sizes were perfect and prices made sense for what you're getting.

A simple, no frill authentic Mexican restaurant. We sat outside, had shrimp burrito and tacos de birria. Both were delicious. The waitress was friendly and efficient.

Great spot, especially if you're eating outside. The staff is really cool, had to pick up order one time where they forgot chips and when I came back they gave me double and extra guac. Can't ask for a better deal oh also the food is delicious!

The enchiladas were great, seating inside was nice. Definitely coming back for more Mexican dishes, especially when the sun comes out and sit outside.

El Rey Rostoceria y Restaurante is located in a residential area. Street parking only, it means it can be difficult to find parking at times. Food: Free chips and salsa while you wait. We added the guacamole, and it was fresh and homemade. Birria Tacos was delicious. The consome was very flavorful, beefy goodness. You can eat it as a soup or use it to dip your birria tacos. Authentic tasting. My brother enjoyed the Beef Enchiladas. Big portion and flavorful. He loved it so much that he ordered a side order of the black beans. Carne Asada Tacos was bland and tough, according to my sister in law. Need extra salsa. The service was friendly and attentive. We love the decor, the vibrant atmosphere.

It's a cute no frill place. It has sufficient outdoor seatings. The waitress was friendly, efficient, and professional. We had shrimp burrito and tacos de birria. Both were delicious.

Ate here for lunch on Saturday, March 29, 2025. Tacos and Layuda were ok, but my tacos pastor was a bit dry and missing pineapple.

Positives: Excellent food and presentation. (See pics) Excellent friendly service. Good feel to the location. Easy free street parking. Negatives: Dirty Tables Outside you clean yourself. Toilet paper in restroom not installed. Probably the most expensive Burrito I have ever had and I pay Los Angeles/So Cal prices. (Asbury park rents must be expensive?) [Would give them a 4.5 for food alone.] No reason not to dine here if your budget can handle it. Thanks for staying open late on Labor Day.

First of all, only tried this place because of Yelp reviews. Was not let down. My yelpers came through putting me on to a new place that I loved with a capital L. I had a chicken burrito and my boyfriend had chicken tacos. I loved my burrito and he enjoyed his tacos! We ordered to go and the waitress was very accommodating. She was super sweet and you could tell she enjoys her job. Overall, 5 stars in my book. Tell a friend to tell a friend because this place is a hidden gem.

Another visit in our quest to find the best Birria Tacos. Solid meal at El Rey although I don't know if I am in a rush to go back. The Salsa Verde and their chips are excellent, refills on chips will cost you $4 Shrimp fajitas were Asian inspired if you will, no cheese, no sour cream included. Sour cream was $1 Rice and beans were above average. The Birria tacos were excellent, chock full of slow roasting beef and their consommé was scrumptious. BYOB, bottled water is served (no tap available) There are approx 8 tables for dining, parking can be difficult, restaurant is in a residential neighborhood. On to the next restaurant

Pssst, wanna know a secret? I don't want to tell you. Oh, I suppose as a Yelper, I will, but only because we are friends. Come closer and let me whisper it to you. Found THE BEST Mexican restaurant in Central Jersey. The ambiance, the service, and the food are out of this world! Let us discuss the food, first. We had Tacos de birria and Al Pastor tacos. They make everything fresh to order, so it will take a small while. While you wait, the wonderful hostess will give you homemade chips and salsa verde and another sauce that is possibly chipotle lime crema. They are not the average store-bought condiments but exponentially better. They make it themselves and they are phenomenal. Finally, the food came and we must say, these dishes were generous and exceptional! Both Hubby and I concur, the star of the show was the Tacos de Birria. The braised beef was stewed to perfection. You can do the famous dip and drink it as soup. The Al Pastor tacos were very tasty as well but the birria was so savory. Lots of napkins were utilized. Secondly, the service was also amazing. The entire staff gives you a warm welcome and always makes sure everything is right. Exceptional service, food, and great affordable prices - sign me up! Needless to say, we intend to be back and next time, we will be bringing friends.

We enjoyed our first time experience here. Definitely satisfied our cravings. I had the Birria Tacos and it was delicious, with the consome perfect combo. My brother had the Beef Enchiladas, and he cleaned up his plate. He enjoyed it so much that he ordered another side order of the black beans. His wife ordered the Carne Asada Tacos and she said it was a bit bland and tough. Four STARS ! Service was excellent, very friendly and warm. I really like the vibe here and the warm atmosphere.

A really nice Mexican restaurant with a beautiful outdoor area. The inside space is smaller and has beautiful furniture. The service was good and fast. The food was delicious and spicy. I love the ambience here. It's a good spot for groups. Definitely recommend coming here on a nice day to sit outside.

delicious food, great service, very reasonably priced and is BYO! Always a wonderful experience

Another great meal at El Rey tonight! We had our regular shrimp dishes but the big news tonight was the new why they serve the chips and salsa. The two floors of salsa were in clear ketchup type squeeze bottles. Brilliant!! So ease to apply to the chips with little to no drips. Plus. They do not waste product!

Food was fresh, homemade hot sauces and chips. The inside is cute and outside comfortable. The menu is expansive and authentic.

Yeah, genuine comida mexicana (Mexican food). This place has only been on this off-beaten path in Asbury Park for 2months and all the reviews are super, including mine. Reasonable prices with a cozy indoor or outdoor setting. Great artwork too, come in and enjoy great Mexican food offered by this family. They serve breakfast, lunch and presumingly dinner. Tacos, Burritos, Quesadillas, Fajitas, Enchiladas and full dinners. I can echo the previous reviews. Tried the Birria Tacos, the best , of course w/salsa picante & extra cilantro. For you foodies who enjoy comida mexicana, this is the place. To wash everything down, I got an Horchata, a mix of strained rice, milk and cinnamon , a very refreshing drink to calm down the "heat". Both of the items I tried are not on the menu. Birria Tacos $15, Horchata 32 oz $4.

This place is so outstanding that next time I might even try the birria pizza, but we stuck to the classics on this visit, including birria in its proper form, tacos, with juicy meat and dazzling consomme. The carnitas tacos were great, as was the choriqueso appetizer and even the intense green salsa with the free chips. The service was friendly, fast and well-informed and the outdoor tables were fun. This is a must-visit alternative to the main touristy section of Asbury but isn't far away from it.

I really like the chips and dip and the seafood pot. It's too good, the seafood are every flavorful!

Cool decor, very clean. They have sitting outside under umbrellas. Borrow tacos seems to be a special here. Sauce is delish. Service fast and friendly. Complimentary chips with tomatillo and cheesy sauce(?). Big portion, fair pricing. Recommend!

Wow, what a nice surprise to find this place tucked away from it all. Got the trip tacos and as it was mid afternoon post tourista season, they were ok with my ordering pollo, carnita and chorizo. The complimentary chips are a nice touch. On to the tacos. Plump and full of meat. I would have preferred limes instead of lemons as i had to pick seeds out of my tacos. Clean, friendly, with the food being quite good. As a local, I'll be back again, and again, and again....

Lovely casual place for great Mexican food. Had tacos birrea and enchiladas, both excellent. Jessica was our waiter and provided us prompt and friendly service. We will be back.

Ok seriously so gooooooooood. Trust me. I need 85 characters so : I got the birria!!!!!!

Sometimes people think a five star review should be reserved for an expensive, exclusive ("fancy") restaurant. But why? El Rey is an inexpensive, casual, BYOB, that serves the best, most authentic, Mexican food in this area. It is located in a residential neighborhood, a few blocks from the "hot" "hip" restaurants on Cookman Ave (that are more pricey for food and alcohol). There are a few tables inside and more tables outside. We discovered this gem a month ago and last evening ordered takeout for the second time. We have had Guacamole with chips, Camarones a la Diabla, Tacos de birria with cheese and dipping soup, Al Pastor Burrito, and Shrimp Burrito. Prices are quite reasonable (see attached menu). Services is prompt. Senor Sanchez has a great personality and is dedicated to serving quality food. Which brings me to the most important point: portions are large and the food is OUTSTANDING! Go to eat here or to pickup takeout! If you try it once, you will return!

Delicious food at reasonable prices. The staff and seating areas were great. The Norris tacos were tasty and packed with plenty of meat and toppings, the consome was also delicious. Our meal was served with complimentary chips and two tasty salsas. Authentic, and good, that simple. I'd recommend it and I'll be back if I'm in town!

The food was good and I liked the outdoor seating but instead of a 5 star I had to drop it a level because of how long the food took which we were the only customers there and also the 2 dipping sauces they had for the tortilla chips were both too spicy for my kids and when asked for something not spicy or atleast mild, they didn't have anything but other than that it was a legit neighborhood mex spot.

Quesobirria is a must. Very happy we tried this place. Great staff. Great food. Everything was nice and easy. Def will go back

Had the place confused with another Mexican restaurant. Service was friendly, although there was some basic communication challenges There a handful of tables inside and maybe eight tables outside. Food is fresh and the salsa and sauces were excellent. 3 shrimp tacos I think for $15.

This place is great! I have been dying for authentic mexican food since I left florida! This is it! This is the best place around! Pricing is reasonable! Sanchez is a very nice person and is super attentive. I especially enjoyed the selection of authentic Jarritos. I will be coming back.

Jessica was our server and she was amazing! She answered all our questions and made allergy accommodations. She made us feel really comfortable to dine in even though it was late. Loved everything! Great food and service!

Awesome little authentic restaurant with great staff and even better food. We got chips and guacamole, chicken, steak, and chorizo mixed tacos, and a chicken quesadilla. Everything was simple and delicious. The horchata is the perfect end to the meal. Couldn't recommend this place more and we will definitely be back.

This is a great authentic Mexican restaurant. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. There are only 5 tables inside but a beautiful outdoor area. Guacamole was delicious and fresh. The birria was delicious.

The food is always fresh and delicious. I always order the birria tacos and guacamole/chips. Coming from NYC, I was worried about finding an authentic spot. I have found my place :)

The food was delicious! I enjoy going there every once In a while the service is great and the staff are friendly. Although the TABLES for some reason STINK? Otherwise the restaurant is amazing.

Delicious Food. Very authentic Mexican. I loved the art on the walls. It's a small restaurant but very good.

This small place has the best tacos al pastor. Not even in New Brunswick. The outside sitting Is so cute. I think inside is small. Service is great and you can BYOB.

Amazing birria tacos! Big servings, affordable, and super friendly and attentive waitstaff. Great for big groups, families, or couples and a BYOB.

Deliciously authentic! The owner and staff were welcoming. Definitely stop by and give them a try. They have 15 tables. 5 in 10 out. I understand they are quite busy in the evenings, and they don't take reservations. They are absolutely worth either going early or waiting for a table later! And of course, there's take-out.

This places is absolutely delicious and very authentic. They have a large, reasonably priced menu full of amazing options. Everything was flavorful, fresh and prepared quickly. Really looking forward to coming here again.

Great place with authentic flavors and spice. The sauces have flavor and aren't bland and tasteless. The service was great thank you Sanchez for providing my friends a great night. Cute comfortable patio to enjoy the night out on the town

Our server Susana provided a warm welcome to what I hold is the most authentic Mexican restaurant in Asbury Park. My shrimp tacos were fresh and delicious. The pork carnitas will make you swoon. Our companions judged their birra tacos mouth watering. It's a humble family run business away from the bustle of Bangs Ave, but well worth the trip! BYOB

Was really impressed with the flavors and how authentic it was. We had the birria tacos and mango frescas

One of the best hidden spots for authentic Mexican food in Asbury and their Birria Tacaos are to die for. Good people as well!

El Rey is a great spot in Asbury for authentic Mexican food! We got the guacamole, birria tacos con queso and steak tacos. All of it was delicious. Service was also very good. We sat outside in their nice side area. The staff is super friendly, and Alfonso is the best! Def give this place a try when you're in town.

Great food, perfect outdoor atmosphere for friends & family...... We enjoyed the food and plan to bring all our guests & family members to this great find in Asbury Park. First come first serve; even on a Saturday night..... But it's WORTH IT !

So nice to have authentic food, I feel like everyone in the area loves surf Taco and the other Tex-Mex or Americanized versions and I just don't understand why you would want that when this is available. Good food, good prices, great service, and outdoor seating is available. It's everything I ever wanted and surpassed my expectations. The sopes and shrimp tacos were amazing.

Authentic and tastey! Friendly staff. I'll be back. Looking forward to trying the belmar location sometime soon as well

Simply delicious, excellent service and super friendly. Everything was super fresh and tasty.

Awesome tacos and great service. Friendly staff. Tiny restaurant but delicious Birria tacos and tacos Campechano (mix of chorizo, chicken, and steak). Sauces were very good! Definitely recommend and will go their again.

Don't let these foolish reviews trick you. Likely the worst Mexican food experience of our lives. Starting with no salsa for the WORST chips you'll ever have, then charge you $4 for "picco de gallo" so you can have a little something on there instead of their sorry excuse for sauces that you spray from a bottle instead of dipping your chips. Want a water? Smallest bottled water for $2. Don't even think about getting fajitas unless you want the worst deal ever. Girlfriend wanted sour cream and lettuce to come with it like it is every other restaurant but got up charged $6!!! For a plate of lettuce that they called a salad. No plate to make her fajitas on even! My $15 burrito was 1.) super small 2.) ALL FILLER!!! Barely any meat. To top all of this off the "waitress" never checked on us throughout the meal. The bill was $51 for what should've been no more than $30. Everything that could've went bad did go bad here. Wouldn't recommend to anyone.

Amazing authentic, tasty Mexican food with awesome wait staff and an amazing, amazing ambiance. Go to place for Mexican food

The reviews were accurate. We had the chicken burrito, green enchiladas, and the guacamole. All of it was great, we'll be back.

Awesome food. Try their horchata and the birria tacos or the chicken cutlet with rice and beans. The service is amazing. But, I really enjoyed the decor of the restaurant, filled with Mexican and Maya/Aztec theme. Must visit if you are in the area.

My son and I went today and had the birria tacos. I don't think I've ever tasted such incredible delicious flavor.... ever. Definitely worth a taste. Host and server were extremely polite and attentive and service was fast. The smells coming from the kitchen were mouth watering. A new favorite place for authentic Mexican cuisine!!!