At Eleventh Street Pizza, savor authentic New York-style pies and thick, crispy Sicilian slices topped with local ingredients and a delicious sourdough crust, all in a cozy downtown spot perfect for late-night cravings or casual hangs.
"While this list is about pizza, it’s hard to talk about Eleventh Street without mentioning the garlic knots. Unlike the chewy, greasy ones you probably grew up with, these dense sourdough versions are blanketed by paper-thin Parmesan shreds and won’t pierce your throat with an acidic sting of garlic. Pair them with the venue’s signature pork and beef meatballs or spicy Caesar salad, and it’s almost a complete meal. Of course, you’re coming here for pizza, and these guys have the whole pepperoni and hot honey thing locked down. Customers love the seasonal, limited edition pizzas, whether it’s a caviar and potato pie (which might be coming back) or a summery release topped with corn and serrano chile. The downtown location, open until 4 a.m., is best suited for pickup and quick munching, while the Dadeland venue is great for family-friendly, sit-down dining." - Ashley Brozic
"Pizza and sporting events are a classic combo, which is why grabbing a slice or even a whole pie at Eleventh Street Pizza is the perfect beginning or ending to the evening at Kaseya Center. The NY-style pizzeria, housed in the former Fooqs location, serves up classic and not-so-classic pies like the wild shroom topped with maitake mushrooms, thyme, garlic, shallot, mozzarella, garlic confit, caramelized onions, parsley, and sourdough breadcrumbs." - Dara Smith, Olee Fowler
"Eleventh Street Pizza is a great New York-style pizza spot in Downtown. The pizzas are foldable yet firm, and made with sourdough crust. Our favorite is the pepperoni and hot honey pizza, which comes topped with Calabrian chili paste, caramelized onions, and little pepperoni cups. There are also thick square slices, and they do a pizza Happy Hour Monday through Friday with $10 cheese pies. The pizzas feed two to three people, especially if you add on a side like meatballs or caesar salad. It’s mostly a to-go operation, but they have tables in case you want to eat there. There's also a second location in Downtown Dadeland." - ryan pfeffer, virginia otazo
"Eleventh Street Pizza is a great New York-style pizza spot, and where you want to go if the line at Miami Slice sucks. Their slices are foldable yet firm, and made with a delicious sourdough crust. Our favorite is the pepperoni and hot honey pizza, which comes topped with Calabrian chili paste, caramelized onions, and little pepperoni cups. The huge Sicilian square slices are great too. It's great for to-go, but they also have indoor and outdoor seating where you can enjoy your pizza with a bottle of wine." - ryan pfeffer, mariana trabanino
"Eleventh Street makes one of the best pies in Miami, whether consumed on the water or dry land. The slice shop is in Downtown, which is close to some major boat-launching points, but they also deliver. This could come in handy if you (hypothetically) left the cooler of beer in your hotel room and (hypothetically) have run out of time to pick up more supplies before your voyage. Order a couple of pepperoni and hot honey pies straight to the marina and (hypothetically) all will be forgiven. Don’t forget to share with your captain, too." - ryan pfeffer
