David E.
Yelp
About 17 years ago while dating my now wife we flew into O'Hare and we power walked to the Eli's location in the airport to grab cheesecake prior to getting on our connecting flight. The foodie wife swore by it and was dead-on accurate by saying it would be worth the sweaty power walk.
We finally got around to flying into Chicago to actually enjoy the city. Our new favorite city btw after spending 3 days here enjoying the sights, architecture, vibe, chow and beverages. Fortunately this time we were right near the Eli's cheesecake shop which was in between our incoming gate and outgoing gate.
We grabbed a variety of slices for our flight home. For the record, my favorite type of cheesecake is ricotta cheesecake but if well made I'm still a very big fan of cream cheese cheesecake. The slices are small so we should have purchase more. That was our only mistake. But the price is fair for airport pricing and quality cheesecake.
NOTE: they close pretty early but we were lucky and made it by 15-20 minutes before closing
CHERRY CHEESECAKE -- layered cherry is blended in from the front tip to the back end; shortbread cookie crust; dense, smooth, creamy texture; medium sweet or more; continual tasty cherry flavor throughout each bite; great with coffee; tastes of cream cheese given texture and flavor
RATING = A
CARAMEL CHEESECAKE -- tastes and looks like chopped walnuts embedded into the the caramel layer on top; tasty firm caramel; smooth, dense, firm cheesecake; very creamy; not crazy sweet for caramel cheesecake which is surprising as most are very sweet
RATING = A
PLAIN CHEESECAKE -- Madagascar vanilla bourbon used inside per their site; tastes of cream cheese given texture and flavor; smooth, firm, dense and delicious; clear light sweetness or a bit more lean towards medium sweet (not too sweet though); vanilla taste prevalent; I drizzled some 365 brand dark Canadian maple syrup on part of it to add some delicious maple flavor (still not too sweet considering maple syrup added); sometimes "plain Jane" is the best and this is my favorite especially since I can add a little of my favorite dark maple syrup to add extra excitement to the palate; very creamy texture; shortbread cookie crust; this was the wife's favorite as well
RATING = A+