Daniel C.
Yelp
There doesn't seem to be a separate entry for the Emerald Island Casino and their restaurant, the Emerald Island Grille. Since everyone else is combining their reviews I guess I will to.
First the Casino. The three casinos in the downtown Henderson, Water Street area (the other two being El Dorado and Club Rainbow), are three of the loosest casinos in the Vegas area in terms of pay tables, and Emerald Island is no exception. They advertise themselves as the only "all penny" casino in the Vegas area, meaning that every machine has a penny denomination option. Don't let this worry you too much if you like to play bigger stakes, as you can usually play well over a 100 pennies at a time, and many machines offer the option to change to higher denominations.
They definitely cater more towards the "low roller" gambler with a more frugal gambling budget, even if you can play higher stakes. They comp drinks at a very low 20 cent average and you qualify for most of their promotions with an average bet of the same. One weird thing about the Emerald Island is that it is the Casino where I have seen payouts go down on some of the higher denominations, which is unheard of and usually the opposite is true. On the machines at the bar the payouts on one cent and two cent are pretty high, but switch to five cent and they drop. Casino owners usually want to encourage higher denomination play as they turn a bigger profit on it, so this makes no sense. Stick to the lower denominations and up your bets there if you want to make bigger bets.
They have no table games (none of the Water Street Casinos do) and one long bar inside. One downside to this place is that there are a lot of smokers, espicially at the bar, which is where I prefer to play. On the upside the bar does have some drafts from Lovelady Brewing down the street, which they comp, and that is a huge plus to playing here in my book. They also periodically walk through the Casino with snacks, like a tray of cookies, for players, though this doesn't seem to happen too often.
The players club doesn't offer free play, which is a downer, but they do have more point earning promotions and "spin the wheel" style promotions than any place I have ever seen. They advertise themselves as having a promotion everyday, so make sure you check with the players club before you start gambling to see what's going on. On many days you might get to spin a wheel for extra cash if you hit a certain keno hit, slot amount or video poker hand. They also have some crazy point multipliers that range from 25 times to 100 times your normal earnings. We played for an hour during a 75 times multiplier and earned almost fifty dollars in comp between us for the Cafe, which is by far the fastest I have ever seen comp dollars accumulate. If you want to eat for free, this is the Casino for you.
On the the restaurant. The Emerald Island Grille is the only Casino on Water Street that has a 24/7 dining option. Their graveyard specials are pretty low priced and they have several options every night, including breakfast and burgers. Almost every night has a theme to it, and we've been here for BBQ night and Italian night. We were shocked by the quality on both nights considering this is a casino cafe. The Italian sausage pasta and linguine and clams were both amazing. The BBQ sampler was worthy of a real BBQ restaurant and had five meats for 16.99, including the best hot link I have ever had for BBQ. My wife got the brisket sandwich and it was also fantastic. They even had Pecan Pie as a special desert for the BBQ night.
Their theme night food is worthy of five stars, but funny enough their normal dining menu hasn't impressed us that much. I got the ribeye here once and it wasn't even a ribeye... I got the double cheeseburger special one time, and it was OK, but nothing special. They have decent breakfast to.
Their prices are typical for a diner, and are a little bit higher than the other Casino Restaurants nearby that offer dirt cheap prices for everything. This is probably due to the crazy rate gamblers can earn food comp here if they gambler during the multiplier times. The service here has always been great and very friendly.
In conclusion, the Emerald Isle is better than your average locals casino, especially if you are a low stakes gambler. Their biggest downsides are that they can be smokey and you don't earn free play, but they have very good craft beer and a good restaurant you can earn comps quickly for. I wouldn't drive across town to come here, but if you live nearby I would check it out.