Al M.
Yelp
I paid for a "fresh, local, free-range" turkey, but I think I got a Butterball.
For 2 years in a row I ordered a 20-25 lb. turkey from JL Kennedy Meat Stand and both years the turkeys I got were frozen solid. When I inquired about it after the first year, the woman told me that they keep their refrigerators really cold so if I pick up the turkey later in the day it would probably be frozen. I had picked it up fairly early, but I gave them the benefit of the doubt.
This year I picked up the turkey at 6:30 AM. I felt the turkey at the stand and it felt soft, so I figured this time I got a fresh turkey. When I got it home and began prepping it, the inside was still frozen solid.
I called the farm and the man I spoke with told me that he keeps his truck cold and it may have frozen in there. I told him that it's not possible for it to freeze on the inside and remain thawed on the outside. It just doesn't work that way! He told me that I can return it, but that wasn't an option because I had to put it in brine and go to work. Also, the market is 1/2 hour each way from my house.
Also, both years the turkeys had the giblets inside white paper bags that were mechanically sealed (just like Butterball) and both had pop-up plastic indicators, just like Butterball.
Butterball sells fine turkeys, and if I wanted a Butterball I could have gotten one for 1/3 the price at any supermarket.
I'm on the look-out for a farm that sells REAL fresh, local, free-range turkeys for next year.