Karen S.
Yelp
A fab, low-key place to celebrate a special occasion! I had mentioned it was an anniversary when we made the reservation online, and I appreciated that they remembered both when we walked in with a simple "Happy anniversary!" greeting, as well as at the end of the meal with a free dessert and a lit candle. That's all I ever want! No big fuss or anything crazy -- it's just nice if they ask about a special occasion in the reservation that they acknowledge it.
We got the $45 per person tasting meal, which actually wasn't too much food. I'd venture to say that if you don't get that, you're probably paying too much. The portions are really small, and I don't eat that much! You do get a nice warm roll with butter and olive oil to start, which helps.
The salads to start the meal were good but nothing special. I tried the veal tongue, which was a little overpowered by this creamy dressing, but not bad (I'm used to thicker, slightly chewier cuts of pig tongue in Taiwanese cooking). The pastas were fantastic! The taleggio ravioli was super delicate (and not too stinky -- sometimes taleggio can be overpowering) and tasted like spring. The bucatini amatriciana was a little less spicy than I've had in other places, with the guanciale incorporated in thin strips like prosciutto instead of in little chunks like bacon, but the dish as a whole was super comforting and something I could eat a giant bowl of. We got lamb saddle and atlantic dorade as our main courses. Both were perfectly cooked: the dorade was flaky, with crisp skin, and the lamb was tender and not overly lamb-y tasting. I thought the dorade plate was a tad oily but enjoyed the combo of fennel, super crispy potatoes and clams. The salsa verde and green garlic really brightened the lamb dish, which had the potential to be heavy.
The desserts probably tied the pastas for our favorite part of the meal. We ordered the affogato (higher espresso to ice cream ratio than I've had in the past), the olive oil cake with lemon curd, grapefruit supremes and meringue, and they gifted us with really yummy cherry ice cream. Between the three we got bitter, sweet and sour, which is nice to have at the end of a meal.
The tables are indeed really close together, as other diners have mentioned. When I got up to go to the bathroom, which is through the connected restaurant, I noticed it was at least half empty and wondered why they didn't expand Fat Hen into that space a little more. It also got really dark inside as the sun set, leaving me to wonder how people were going to see the menu as the night went on (we got there around 6).