Wells L.
Yelp
TL:DR - Super super creative flavors that actually deliver. The ice cream itself is top notch, but no better than any other good ice cream spots. If you like cake chunks, you won't be disappointed with the blondie vs. brownie, it is delicious. But the mango sticky rice is unbelievably close to the real thing, smooth creamy and fruity. This place is going to be hard to beat.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
As I've said in many other reviews of ice cream spots, there is a real ceiling to how good the quality of your ice cream can get. And most really good spots can hit that pretty easily. Thinking Humphry Slocombe in the bay, Jeni's in the midwest, Clementines from STL. Fifty licks has that down pat. But what makes fifty licks stand out for me is their flavor combos, the imagination of some of these things, and their execution is top notch. Even looking at all of their flavors, I was o man that sounds amazing, and then trying them I was even more impressed by how well it was executed.
I tried a few, but the blondie vs. brownie was my favorite as I love a good vanilla ice cream and love the chewy texture of both the blondie and brownie and the chunks were super generous. I ended up trying a little of my friends mango sticky rice, and that works so unbelievably perfectly and legit my be my single favorite ice cream flavor ever. Unbelievably smooth and I love that it's almost like a mango swirl jam or jelly vs. chunks of real mango which can get really tart/sour sometimes.
But we came in about 10 min before close and while the staff was prepping to close and hesitated when we asked if they were still open, they still served us with a great attitude and we didn't linger too long.
All in all, this is easily one of my favorite ice cream spots anywhere. The flavors are creative, but still just give you want you want, vs. trying to be ridiculously overly fancy. I will 100 be back.