First and South Restaurant & Bar

Restaurant · Greenport

First and South Restaurant & Bar

Restaurant · Greenport

100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944

Highlights

Nestled in a charming mint green Victorian, this cozy bistro offers delicious seasonal New American dishes and a welcoming vibe, perfect for family dining.

100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944 Get directions

firstandsouth.com

@firstandsouth

$30–50 · Menu

Reserve

@infatuation

"This minty green Victorian-era house has a couple of patios, a covered porch space, and plenty of indoor seating, so it’s as flexible as you need it to be and easy enough to visit with kids or a stroller. This is the spot if someone has a hankering for a creamy chowder, big burgers, and skin-on, hand-cut fries, with a friendly staff that keeps things moving, even when the place packs out. They do a great brunch on Sundays that’s worth it for the homemade pop-tart alone." - sal vaglica

The 21 Best Restaurants In The North Fork 2024

View Postcard for First and South Restaurant & Bar

@infatuation

First and South - Review - Greenport - Long Island - The Infatuation

View Postcard for First and South Restaurant & Bar

Jay M.

Google

Everything about this place is so amazing. I can’t wait to go back. What we got: Burrata with confit tomato’s, (nut free) basil pesto with a side of crostini - 10/10. The burrata was creamy and delicious. The pesto was vibrant. The confit was sweet but savory adding a lovely touch. A Really Good Burger - it really was a really good burger. The patty was hearty and cooked to perfections. I added cheese and bacon. The bacon was THICK and delicious, definitely worth the extra money. First Fries - incredible skin on 3 times blanched fries. You’re able to add on sauces for dipping which is such a nice touch. We got the garlic aioli which was really acidic forward, truffle aioli which was divine with the right about of truffle, and the scallion remoulade which quickly became my fave dip after dip. Lemonade - it has the perfect balance of sweet but tartness. I could imagine having it on a hot day as a refreshing beverage. Overall, I highly recommend!!

C Sorrell

Google

My sister and I’s waiter Clint was the best. Kind, cool and funny. We had the best conversations about recommendations for food on the menu and places to go visit around town while visiting, even after the restaurant was closing down for the night. The food and drinks were delicious. I would highly suggest visiting.

Jason Fidler

Google

My wife and I came here for lunch and had an outstanding experience. I ordered the New England clam chowder, and it was easily one of the best I’ve had—loaded with clams and perfectly balanced without being overly creamy. My wife had the shrimp and lobster sliders, which were fresh, flavorful, and paired perfectly with her Bloody Mary. But the real standout? The hand-cut fries—crispy, golden, and absolutely delicious! Despite the place being busy, the service was attentive and friendly, making the whole experience even better. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town. Highly recommend!

Matthew “Matt from the North Fork” Chizever

Google

What an incredible experience we had today at First and South! It was our first visit, and certainly won’t be the last, thanks to some amazing service by Patrick, great drinks and delicious food! Highly recommend the miso salmon, as well as the poke bowl! What initially brought us there was the fact that they’re dog friendly outside and in the bar area (I think I have that correct…) but aside from that, it’s a really cute spot with killer drinks and phenomenal food. Nuff said, don’t take my word for it. We made a reservation on Resy and got right in. Do the right thing and plan ahead, especially on busy weekends (we went on Memorial Day and still no wait to sit with our reservation). This is literally all we need when we go out to Greenport with our dog and we’ll definitely be a frequent stop!

Rose Khan

Google

We found First & South to be just okay— the atmosphere was nice and we were seated right away, but after reading so many positive reviews, we were a bit disappointed by our dishes. We ordered the first fries as an appetizer, and the roast chicken, burger, lemon pepper shrimp, and gluten free mac and cheese as entrees. As a table, we agreed we enjoyed our meals, but they felt a bit overpriced. The lemon pepper shrimp was mainly pasta and lacked very much shrimp, which was misleading the menu description. Not a bad experience, but could be better overall!

Kevin Su

Google

Went there with a friend, and it was by far the best dining experience I had. Super cozy porch dining with great ambiance. Drinks were amazing, and the staff was super friendly. It's definitely my top Greenport pick!

Riley Spieler

Google

Went for a Monday lunch and enjoyed the Monday Mussels Special. Great value and quality! Good vibes and service as well.

Fkie G

Google

First thing that won our hearts was the service they provided to our toddler. The waiter heard our child say she was hungry, took the child’s order first and ensured our baby was eating a little after our drinks came out. Kids menu was banging! Fried chicken was citrusy and well seasoned. The fried shrimp was crispy and flavorful. Parmesan chicken wings were a little powdery, but perfectly crispy and paired well with the ranch dressing. Lemon Pepper Shrimp- at first I thought I was only getting two shrimp with my order! Glad to find the rest of those guys swimming at the bottom of that delicious broth. Tuna Burger- pretty good. Needed more of that sauce though!