Fishmonger

Fishmonger is my favorite restaurant in Atlanta, everything is divine but I’m addicted to the caesar salad… I crave it all the time and find myself having to come back for it almost every week (shoutout to the server who told me I could get a MINI version, I’ll usually pair it with a crudo or ceviche 😋). This location is newer so there aren’t as many reviews and I thought I’d help give a boost — it genuinely deserves the praise. I love this location not only because of the food but the atmosphere, it’s much bigger and has a lot more seating compared to the original Ponce location. Totally worth the 31 minute walk from my apartment, even in the scorching summer sun.

I had a great experience at Fishmonger - Howell Mill. The food was great, although I didn’t favor either of the crudo dishes based on personal preference (no fault of the chef, just too citrusy & too much horseradish), the Oysters Casino & lobster roll was delicious! I didn’t try the 2 different fish sandwiches, but they were ordered at my table & looked good! Drinks were really tasty & different. I definitely want to go back when it warms up to check out the open air seating area they have. Vibes (music & decor) were so great here!

Delicious and fresh seafood. The grouper, caesar salad and potatoes are great. Service is quick and staff is super friendly. A lot of space to seat outside - it’s pet friendly too!

Came here for lunch with my friend. I ordered the hot fish sandwich. I will say that the fish tasted really good, fresh, and was prepared nicely. I paid a whopping $22 for my hot fish sandwich and my friend paid about $20 for her sandwich, it’s a bit pricey. My friend did not like the black and grouper sandwich, she thought that it was a too mushy, but she thought the sauce tasted ok. Try this restaurant out for yourself!

Really fantastic place we loved it so much. Went for the blackened grouper sandwich with was very excellent with the whole fish spread which makes it a double patty when you close it ❤️. Rest of the food was very good too: peal & eat shrimp, beet salad and clam chowder. Very tasty and price is not too bad we will be back!

Went here for dinner on a Thursday night. The staff were super friendly, they offered various drinks and wine recommendations, and the food was 10/10. I highly recommend the green curry mussels to start and the hot fish sandwich.

Love this West Midtown location!! I guess I'm going around visiting all the locations lol but since this one is closer to home, this may be it!! Love the space. Huge compare to the Poncey-Highlands one. The space has a huge bar. I actually ate at the bar. Service was great!. I had the oysters. They were so fresh and good. I also had the calamari salad which was amazingly delicious!!!! It is a must try. Parking available in the back of the restaurant. Pretty reasonable in terms of price. Again, great location with an outdoor patio!!

We found this place by accident and we’re not disappointed. The service was friendly, knowledgeable and relaxed, the atmosphere buzzy and fun and the food was exceptional. We had the Clams which were utterly delicious and had to try the oysters and Ceviche which were also great. We’ll definitely be back when we’re in Atlanta 🙌🏼

Fishmonger has quickly become known around the city for its fresh seafood, innovative takes on classics, and a beloved favourite of former President Barrack Obama. Even though my opinion doesn't carry as much clout as his, I can too attest to their fantastic grouper sandwich! I've had the pleasure of dining at their Pullman Yards & West Midtown locations numerous times. My husband and I would like to come here on Wednesday to take advantage of their happy hour (half-priced marks on a patio), followed by their weekly clam jam! Their clams in a Thai curry sauce, crudo, and swordfish tacos are excellent picks! The bartenders are always friendly and show off their chops. Recently, at Westside Stride, we learned they'll be moving to a fancy new interlock building, and their previous location will be turned into a park. What a great way to stroll and walk off the yummy seafood and hearty bread after a meal. I can't wait to see the new space in 2025.

Fishmonger has been on my list and I decided to give it a try finally! I did not realize they replaced my beloved La Fonda's location but nonetheless I was excited! The decor and vibe is definitely edgy and fun off rip. I love the unique style of staff and how it all feels intentional + the neon colors for menus + lighting. Now on to the important stuff...the drinks & the food. I can't remember which drinks we ordered 100% but I believe we got the Daiquiri + 75 South. Both were delicious and the flavors were light and layered well. We also took part in a couple of glasses of their OE Le Chardonnay' 2022 which was pleasant and paired well with the meal. For food, I had the following with ratings included: * Chowder 7/10 (a little salty but I loved that it wasn't your standard level of creamy chowder. It was a lot looser of a base. * Gumbo 5/10: I love okra but this was mostly okra and minimal proteins. Was not nasty but definitely didn't give me those gumbo flavors I was looking for (spice, seafood etc) * Caesar 6/10: nothing special! I love a good Caesar dressing but this one was very very light. * Oyster Casino (Raw Bar): 9/10 no complaints at all! * Blackened Grouper Sandwich 8/10: fish was flakey and I loved the peppery crust. lacked a little salt here but with everything combined, not a big miss * Hot Fish Sandwich: 8/10: Very good, and nice hot flavor. Not that oily flavorless mess that "hot" dipped fish or chicken can be. Also a good size served! All in all, would recommend and come back for drinks + raw bar specifically.

It almost hurts how much I love this place. Seafood check, ambiance check, staff check! Their happy hours are great half off margs Thursdays and then $9 for half a dozen oysters I think it was. We came for lunch before sending off family as they wanted seafood and I knew just the spot. The shrimp roll was fantastic. It was great portion and tons of filling which sometimes is hard to find. The hot fish sandwich..... I can not stress enough how good it is. Juicy, spicy, fresh. All the things. It was messy and worth it. Never had something with this much flavor and cooked to perfection. The bartender is one of the kindest human beings always attentive and has the best personality. We come every week basically to see her and get the best prices seafood in town!

Fishmonger is consistent. Parking is a bit of a drag depending on the time of day, but I greatly appreciate the parking lot. The oysters are shucked beautifully and the bartenders are great and friendly. The blackened Caesar salad is AMAZING! If you're there during the summer you have to try the frozen painkiller.

I've been to two of the locations - Virginia Highland and the one near Candler Park. Not sure if there's a quality difference but at the Candler Park I ordered the tuna melt sandwich and a side of pasta salad based on a review recommendation. It was ok but probably overpriced at $16 for what it was and pasta salad was ok too but not something I would eat again. I recommend their raw bar more which I ate at the Virginia Highland location - I've had the ceviche and that was really good but unfortunately that location closes early.

Out and about with my peoples looking for a place to buy some fish. GPS suggested Fishmonger. We entered a quaint spot with a large table for 6-8 and window seating and a small display of fresh fish. We were disappointed that there was not much of a selection but it might be due to the fact that the sandwiches and other prepared items were dayum good. We had the grouper sandwich and the tuna melt. I initially felt some kinda way about sides not being included but we did not need them at all...the sandwiches were plenty. The owner was very detailed about the preparation of ordered items which translated into phenomenal fare. He even had time to train new staff while working on a new dish. Cannot wait to see if it is on the menu on my next visit.

I have been dying to try this place and this was amazing! My main reason for the love is because the happy hour is from 5-7!!! Talk about generous!! You get half off margs and oysters I mean that's the best deal I've ever heard. Either way let's start at the beginning they have a lot out back for parking. And like I said happy hour. So we obviously split (me and a friend) 6 oysters and we each had 2 margs. Margs were on point and the oysters were fresh and delicious. We also got the fish dip which to be honest was just fine!! It kind of gave like a chicken salad esque vibe so not my fave but worth a try! Would try other apps next time For our entrees we shared the group sandwich and the lobster roll. That group sandwich lives up to the fame with how large, juicy and stunning it is. The lobster roll also was one of the better ones I have had in the city. Overall, I loved this place and can't wait to come back.

I went to Fishmonger for the first time which is in the same building that La Fonda used to be in and figured I would try their signature Grouper sandwich and it did not disappoint. The filet was pretty big and cooked perfectly, at least to my linking. I also had the fingerling potatoes which were drenched in a butter sauce that paired with the sandwich very well. The beet salad was way better than I anticipated. I would recommend anyone in the area that's been curious to at least try their offerings at least once! UPDATE: I tried the Tuna melt with the pasta side and they have surpassed my love of the Grouper sandwich. Pics added.

The hot fried catfish sandwich that i keep seeing everywhere really is that good. They use a few different herbs and pickles to garnish the sandwich and it's so good. Tried it a month ago and I've still been thinking about it.

The food here is amazing as are the drinks. Came late on a Thursday night and had the fish sandwich, ceviche, and mussels. The interior of the restaurant is really cute with plants everywhere - really adds to the Caribbean vibe. Everything was incredible and has a hint of spice (which I liked). I forgot to take pics of the food but the portion sizes are generous. Even my espresso martini had spice which was fine with me. I also tried the rum drink which was great too. Great drinks and excellent staff. I will be back!

Fishmonger is consistently good! Both the service and the food. This is one of my new regular spots for oyster happy hour. On Wednesdays I come for the Clam Jam and the $5 shot and beer. The music is always bomb too! As an avid oyster lover the only thing I WISH they did was list what oyster varieties they have somewhere either on the board at the front or on the menu. Real oyster lovers like to know what they ate eating. When I asked the waiters they try their best, naming the state they came from but nothing of the city, company name or body of water.

I had clammy deliciousness at Fishmonger. The steamed clams in the delicious clammy both was just everything. I could eat them every day. My daiquiri drink was tasty as well. I can't wait to return, to try the grouper sandwich.

Was a bit surprised when I first saw that one of my favorites had been converted to a fishmonger location. Looked it up on Yale and was impressed with the reviews shared, and finally had the opportunity to visit last week. Parking was a bit of a hassle as the back lots are now lots. There was ample signage stating that validation was available inside the restaurant, and the server who seated us provided all necessary information. Seating was open, and we chose to sit inside due to the warm weather. A second server assisted us once our order arrived, as the initial server went to the patio area to assist with the growing number of patrons seated outside. Service in general was good. We were able to get the happy hour specials, which included drinks and oysters on the half shell. My companion ordered the Caesar salad, which was large enough to share. Everything was delicious! The oysters were so good that I don't recall having time to take a photo! The mionette sauce that accompanied the oysters have always been one of my favorites, and complemented the horseradish requested in addition to cocktail sauce. Our margaritas were equally good, mine traditional with salt rim and companion's passion fruit with sugar rim. Ambiance and decor were really nice. I would like to visit the other two Fishmonger locations, and will definitely return to the Howell Mill one again.

Genuinely excellent and objectively Fun. How it wasn't packed at 7pm on a Friday night, I have no idea. Initially scoffed at cocktail prices, but they are more innovative than the menu suggests + true works of craftsmanship. The Abuelita was one of the best drinks I've ever had -- perfect balance of spice + savory, in an espresso martini format. Gulf Shrimp Roll was also a top 5 sandwich. Could eat this every week. Brown butter potatoes were absolutely gluttonous in the best way possible -- smash the potatoes to absorb all of the liquid gold. A little flaky salt would have taken these over the top + that's my only critique. Scallop crudo was also very good. When every other restaurant on Howell Mill is a nightmare, stop in Fishmonger and take a seat at the bar. You won't regret it!

They don't have vegetarian or vegan options. I went there with five friends, and we all had to leave because they didn't have options for us.

The food was soooo good. We stumbled upon this place by being in the area and wasn't disappointed. The peel and eat shrimp were huge, well seasoned and worth the price. The gumbo had a little kick to it and had so many seafood options. And last but not least the hot catfish sandwich.... Wow it was huge but had amazing layers of flavor!!

Salmon BLT was to die for. Great presentation. We stopped in for Sunday lunch on the way home from the airport.

West Midtown - Love this location!! I guess I'm going around visiting all the locations lol but since this one is closer to home, this may be it!! Love the space. Huge compare to the Poncey-Highlands one. The space has a huge bar. I actually ate at the bar. Service was great!. I had the oysters. They were so fresh and good. I also had the calamari salad which was amazingly delicious!!!! It is a must try. Parking available in the back of the restaurant. Pretty reasonable in terms of price. Again, great location with an outdoor patio!!

If you like seafood, this is the spot. If you like knowledgeable staff, this is your spot. If you like casual outing, again, this is your spot. Had a wonderful meal here in Atlanta at this spot. We started off with raw oysters that was shucked and explained to us by Luisa. Gave us perfect descriptions and also gave us recommendations about other food they have on the menu when dropping them off. I'm sure they had more work to do since not our server but took the time to go down the menu anyways and gave us the details and make spot on recommendations. Luisa was Great help. Other dishes had were the Caesar salad, very tasty for a salad and they don't put big bread crumbs but what appeared to be crumbles which meant every bite had a crunch. We also had the chowder as a starter. So flavorful and all around good. For main dishes we had a couple of specials, a pasta dish with clams, could feed two, was so good with the sauce adding a depth of flavor, but the star was the blackened grouper sandwich. Perfect seasoning and fish was not dry at all. Loved this place and the staff that made it even better. Would definitely recommend.

I like Fishmonger, but I really wanted to love it. The beer selection is nice, but the cocktails and sandwiches are severely overpriced, especially not including sides. I ordered the hot fish sandwich and really liked it for the most part, but some parts of the fish didn't seem like they were seasoned evenly. The seasoned portions were excellent. The potatoes I ordered separately were 100% bland. A few specs of salt every few bites, but absolutely nothing in other bites. That's unacceptable for a potato. The service was solid. The server was friendly, but I couldn't help but think she could use another person to help. The ambiance is dope. It's a place you would want to hang out in. Despite my complaints, I'll be back to try another sandwich.

Love the ambiance of the place - it's got some moody lighting. Service was pretty quick and server was helpful in making suggestions. I was deciding between the blackened grouper sandwich and the Cesar salad + sandwich. I'm glad I went with the Cesar + sandwich because it was a true Cesar anchovy dressing. Quite salty ofc but really good/fresh-tasting. Blackened grouper was great quality as well - it was very clean, not greasy. The whole meal felt fresh and and not-gross to eat. Great place for quality seafood!

Seriously the best fish sandwich in Atlanta! My guy and I checked out the newest location of the Fishmonger Atlanta chain and I must say it did not disappoint! Came here for our 2nd dinner spot since these colder winter months has us a bit more ravenous! Ordered espresso martini and one of their signature frozen cocktails made with Brandy and all natural simple ingredients. Not overly sweet. It was divine. This place serves up the best fish sandwich in Atlanta! The Hot Fish sandwich made with Mississippi catfish is simply amazing! Perfectly hot seasoned fish with complimenting pickled veggies. Their oysters are extremely fresh and indeed mouthwatering. Service here is great! I really enjoyed interacting with the staff here and they play the best music with perfect lighting. Definitely a cool chill vibe and a sure bet for seafood in landlocked Atlanta!

It is an amazing place, they had such fresh variety of fish options. Loved all the food.

Great affordable seafood near home. Upon walking in, I was greeted and informed bar was full service and tables were order at the counter, seat yourself, and they'll bring everything out to you. There are indoor and outdoor seating areas to choose from. Cool vibe, nice people, fresh delicious seafood, and great cocktails. I will be a regular here. Parking is paid in the back lot.

Surprising that this restaurant has Michelin recognition. The seafood I got tasted freezer burned and was not at all representative of the high price. Will not go again.

Just ate here with a friend for lunch. I can attest to the quality of this establishment. The fish is quite fresh and delicious. I had the ceasar with blackened grouper on top. This might have been the best ceasar I've had in Atlanta. The grouper first of all was delicate and immaculately spiced. Can't really say much more, A+ job there on cooking that fish. What really caught me off guard though was the quality and thought that went into the ceasar. Yes, it's just a salad but their take on the standard dish was a breath of fresh air. It is clearly home made anchovy-based dressing (like all ceasar's should be) but the addition of fish roe and Calabrian chili's really spiced up on the traditional dish. My friend got the hot fish sandwich. He finished his entire plate. Not much else I can say about that because I am not in. The plate looked tasty. I will definitely come back again. Only knock I have is prices seem bit a high but we live in a landlocked city and that's what it costs for fresh, good fish.

I've tried Fishmonger's other location in Pullman Yards and LOVED it, so not surprised this location on Howell Mill did not disappoint either!! My friend and I came to check out this location for a Friday happy hour. There's parking in a lot right behind it which I appreciated (I can't remember now if it's paid or validated). We were seated quickly on the patio which was so nice and had great vibes. They have a deal on margaritas during happy hour so we got a couple before the happy hour was over!! We also decided to split the blackened grouper sandwich, fish dip, lobster roll, and oysters (which was another happy hour deal!). OH MY GOSH. Fishmonger might have been even better the second time around!! The oysters are always so fresh and I love their mignonette. The grouper is a classic and it's always so tender and flaky. The lobster roll also was so buttery and summery. The fish dip was a new try for me this time, and WOW. I loved the fresh dill and how refreshing it was. All the accompaniments too were great. Overall, really good time (as always) at Fishmonger, and I plan to keep coming back!!

In our two visits, we had the same experience. The food is very good, but the service is lacking. We definitely enjoyed the blackened grouper sandwich, crab & avocado sandwich, gulf shrimp roll, and rock shrimp ceviche. Both of our visits have been during off peak hours (about 3 to 4 PM). Every time, the service has been painfully slow, and everyone in the restaurant acts like we are disturbing their "break time."

This place is amazing! 100/10With our belly's full of flavorful food and our eyes dilated from such an amazing establishment! Our server was the kindest lady who connected with us and shared her favorite sandwiches and items on the menu. Vibes in the restaurant are Boho chic/ fish market /abstract decor. Highly recommended YOU go try this place.

The service here was a little weird. I sat down in front of the bartender and was not greeted even tho he was right in front of me. 2 minutes passed and I decided let me ask for a menu. After i got the menu ordered a couple different things and really nothing was very good besides the lobster roll. (Beetlecat is better and so is the service so would just got there moving forward)

The establishment and service are pretty cool, but the menu isn't spectacular, especially for the prices. But it's not bad.

Me and my boyfriend absolutely love this place, made me feel like I was back home in Florida. Every dish we had was so delicious!! Our drink were perfect, such an awesome vibe! The manager was so sweet and helpful when it came to choosing what we should get! She also reminded me of Rosalia, random but I just needed to point that out. Lol

We got the grouper and the hot (cat fish) sandwich. The fish quality seemed okay/pretty good but the flavoring was really bizarre. The grouper had a slightly bitter after note that coated the mouth. And the hot sandwich got really spicy halfway through (and I like spice usually more than the regular person). It had a curry flavor but also SO much mint which really did not go together. Service was okay but, as everyone says, an obligatory 18% service fee is weird and really counterproductive because it just makes me want to tip way less if nothing at all, especially since everything here is a la carte and way expensive. There's parking in the front, about 7 spots and then parking in the back. I think both are free but forsure in the front is free. The space is nice and different, there's an outside and inside. The lighting is more of a bar lighting though with pink lights. It's cute but the food is just not good.

Very good and enjoyable and with amazing customer service truly felt happy and a peace here

I went their on Wednesday and they had a pretty good HH. The Hot fish sandwich I had was really good except for celery salad. (Pickled fennel)

Fresh food. Amazing fish. Great service. Pay to park - but lots of spaces. Indoor and outdoor seating. Great vibes and music. A little pricey but worth it! 10/10.

I would have loved to share more of my experience after walking in at 9:33 pm from taking pics and waiting at the door just to be avoided by staff to find myself at the bar to ask the bartender do I seat myself or order at the bar just to be told the kitchen closed at 9:30. At this point it was 9:38pm. I even asked if I could order something simple... he didn't even bother to ask mgmt or the kitchen but told me it wasn't up to him and offered an alcoholic drink. And insisted if I'm close in the area to come back another time. Note: Despite the hours of operation kitchen may close 30 minutes before just depends how the staff feels. Call ahead to check, even if you're a next door neighbor stopping by to get a quick bite or even arriving in ample time before closing.

I would like a side with my meal. That's is how I'll start off this review. We paid for 2 cocktails, 2 sandwiches and 18% gratuity....$78. Each drink had fresh juices and every item had quality ingredients. Good taste, the tuna melt wasn't the meaty, cheesy salty, goodness I'm use to. It was fresher with sprouts, crisp tomatoes and onions. The hot fish sandwich is as spicy as red hot sauce and cooked to perfection. The sides change so they have them up on a board along with a few location specials. But they do not come with the entree. You would have to pay 5 or 8 dollars to complete your meal. Parking during a peak time may be more difficult but it was easy this time around. Will I be back, probably not. I didn't find enough value.

DELICIOUS! I came for lunch and it is WAY nicer than I expected it to be inside. A super trendy and modern vibe. Service was fantastic - super knowledgeable, attentive and gave great suggestions. The drink menu also looked incredible- it was a work day so I didn't try anything, but I'll be coming back. My husband and I started with the Scallop Crudo. It was a very refreshing start to the meal. I got the lobster roll for lunch with coleslaw. It comes with a great amount of lobster and it was super buttery. The coleslaw was also delicious. It was a little pricey at $30, but it's ATL so not unexpected. The blackened fish sandwich was actually my favorite. It is a little spicy, but a balanced and tasty combination- perfectly crafted. Like I said, a bit pricey for lunch but was worth it for the value and flavor. They also do happy hours with 1/2 priced oysters and margaritas. I will be back for more!

The blacked fish sandwich is my go to fish dish in west midtown. Honorable mentions to the hot fish sandwich aswell.

6 stars? This place is pretty darn awesome. The ambiance is cool and super bright and inviting. Our waitress, Taj, was very attentive. The menu has some really great choices and it was hard to decide. I had the shrimp roll and it did not fail to impress. I'm a lobster roll girl, but Taj says the shrimp roll is a tad bigger so I opted to give it a try. Hands down this is delicious. Fresh shrimp seasoned perfectly with a kick and freshness from the dill. They definitely do not scrimp out on the volume either. My husband and kids all had the grouper sandwich. All absolutely loved it. The fish was cooked perfectly with a nice blackened crust. The key lime pie was phenomenal. Take this from a Florida girl! All in all this place is a must

Great location near home. I love their outdoor seating but it will definitely limit the amount of people during rain/cold weather. I got the grouper sandwich. The flavor was great but it was a super messy sandwich to eat because of the sauce, tomatoes, and fish flaking easily. Also got oysters which my 5 year old loved. Ended up getting 2 orders of those. Will go back to try other menu items and the cocktails.

Convenient parking. Good vibe, attentive wait staff. Menu is small but diverse. Drinks were tasty. Food was fresh. Seating was not the most comfortable. I felt it was a novelty. I've been now and don't feel a need to go back.

Fishmonger is legit amazing. Their fish sandwich is one of the best in the world. Yea I said world. Their oysters of the day are awesome and I am a huge fan of the whole experience. Really good food and ocean quality seafood in Atlanta! Definitely visit and I know you will return

I had a great experience at Fishmonger - Howell Mill. The food was great, although I didn't favor either of the crudo dishes based on personal preference (no fault of the chef, just too citrusy & too much horseradish), the Oysters Casino & lobster roll was delicious! I didn't try the 2 different fish sandwiches, but they were ordered at my table & looked good! Drinks were really tasty & different. Good service. I definitely want to go back when it warms up to check out the open air seating area they have. Vibes (music & decor) were so great here!

Tried this place out and was pleasantly surprised!! Started with the shrimp ceviche otw as fresh with a nice kick. Also tried the chowder which was creamy and full of all types of seafood- I see myself stopping in for lunch just to have a taste of this. One of the servers was a bit rude and unhelpful but we then were helped by Margaret and she was really nice! She offered great suggestions and was able to offer separate checks. For my entree I had the shrimp roll which was outstanding as well. Looking forward to coming back!

The blackened grouper sandwich is hands down the best fish sandwich in Atlanta. This is not debatable.

Excellent and friendly service and amazingly tasty seafood! Tried smoked fish dip, chowder, and clams. Each dish was amazing! Will love to come back.

Another delicious visit to Fishmonger! Great food, warm waitstaff and easy vibes and yes! We will be back again!