Garden Grill

American restaurant · Smithtown

Garden Grill

American restaurant · Smithtown

1

64 N Country Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787

Photos

Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null
Garden Grill by null

Highlights

19th-century Victorian with a serene, living-room vibe features American fare & fixed-price meals.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

64 N Country Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787 Get directions

thegardengrill.com

$$ · Menu

Reserve

Information

Static Map

64 N Country Rd, Smithtown, NY 11787 Get directions

+1 631 265 8771
thegardengrill.com

$$ · Menu

Reserve

Features

dine in
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Mar 4, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

Shalimar Diner in Queens Has Closed After 45 Years - Eater NY

"And other classic diners around the city have been unable to survive the current restaurant climate either — recent months have seen the closures of Silver Spurs, Garden Grill, and Georgia Diner." - Stefanie Tuder

https://ny.eater.com/2018/11/26/18112975/shalimar-diner-closed-rego-park-queens-nyc
View Postcard for Garden Grill

Marisa Crowley

Google
I came here with a group of friends a long while back in July, for my birthday celebration and made reservations! We had an outdoor seating, and it was absolutely beautiful and nicely organized! The staff was super friendly, and had a very good attitude whilst they gave out our appetizers and meals! The baked clams, and the burrata was very tasty and super fresh!!! Moving onto the entree, I ordered Penne Alla Vodka and it was the best thing I ever had! It had such a savory taste, and it was a very good size portion since I took some of it home with me. Lastly, the staff surprised me with some birthday dessert and all came out together to sing along, which was really sweet and wholesome! The dessert was really good, I assume it was the chocolate moosse cake? But whatever it was was very moist and had amazing taste! Overall, I recommend on coming here for birthdays, a nice date, for celebratory dinner, or family dinner as it’s a really nice place and I love the outdoors atmosphere!!!

Barbeque Chef

Google
One of the best burgers I have had in a while.. Came out perfect, for me, medium rare. The meat blend Chuck, Brisket, and Short Rib... That's a premium blend that warrants the $19 price tag The fries were served extra crispy, as I like them Friendly, beautiful place...Busy for lunch , with many tables filled Ill definitely be back, and would not hesitate to recommend the burger, or the restaurant.. Certainly in my top 10, might even squeeze into my top 5 Enjoy

Jack Levy

Google
The food and service were top-notch. We booked a party room and had a selected menu for my Nanas 90th birthday. They were very accomdating, friendly and food was excellent.

Marianne Weinfurt

Google
Because the atmosphere and service were superior, we only wish the food was better. Chicken was over grilled and steak sandwiches were very greasy. All 6 of us were disappointed in our meals, which were over- priced. Our waitress was friendly and fun, making us want to give it one more chance. Renovations were a welcome change from previous years.

Tommy Wu

Google
A great place for a nice meal! We made reservations for their Christmas Eve dinner. It wasn't too crowded and the workers were really friendly. The crab cakes were a great start to the meal. It had a nice flavor and a light crisp. The mango salad on top was a nice addition. The soup was also really good. The main dishes were great but the risotto was a little on the mushy side and the flavor didn't really stick out to me. Overall, this is a great place for some classic dishes!

Laureen Sanchez

Google
I went to my friends birthday party, the food was delicious and fresh, we were in a large room with large windows and it was very nice.

Craig Fish

Google
The Garden Grill was a pre-covid favorite of ours. First time back in quite awhile. We weren't sure what the new outside dining was like so we opted for the AC and intimacy of a lower level back room. Overall decor is Victorian and comfortable. The band had some talent and was easy to listen to. The service sufficed, even thought it was our waitresses last night. A bottle of red wine was shared and entrees consisted of jambalaya and the mixed seafood platter (photos attached). Ample sized portions. A 5 star rating could have been possible but the lobster tail was a soft, tortured mess. We ate late, so sending it back was a weak option. The rest of the meal was fine. We will go back, try it again and listen to some music in the Beer Garden, perhaps.

Scotty Blaze

Google
Was skeptical after reading so many negative reviews. But we decided let’s give it a shot and judge for ourselves. Food & Drinks were good, and Live music was great! Service was good too. Was a fun night out.