Michael S.
Yelp
Garnett's is a great little place to go if you have ample time during the week or time to spare on the weekends. It is laid back to point of leisurely service and pacing -- until they need the table turned over. Then, suddenly, you feel juuuust a little less wanted than you were 5 minutes earlier, no matter how much food you still have left on the plate. With (I think, this is from memory) 6 bar stools, maybe 5 two tops, and 2 four tops, this place is not big. So I understand the need to drive turns. But being just a little less obvious with the drive-by dropped check and dropped take out boxes might not leave this as the patron's final impression of the joint.
I need to say first and foremost that I am just super impressed with what they can turn out of such a small kitchen area. I had more space for food prep in my college dorm. But this does not deter the staff, they get the food out, and it is all tasty good heart warming stuff. I had the Manny, which is turkey and pepperoni, swiss, onion, and spreads on a toasted roll. It was very good, although I would recommend asking them to perhaps throw the onions onto whatever cooking surface they have -- crunchy raw onions were a bit jarring. The red bean chili was a great soup. I would go in just for this, by the bowl!
My picky dining partner had the croque monsieur, and found the mornay sauce to be excellent. It truly carried the rest of the sandwich.
The coffee was good, fresh, strong, and welcome. A refill came without asking, which is nice. I wish I could have gotten a third cup toward the end, but what can you do.
Although we didn't have them, we looked at the cakes in the display cake stands. All were clearly left from the day before (we were there on a Saturday at about 11:20 AM and most were well sliced out.) All looked left over and worse for wear but not bad. I would go back to try, perhaps.
We were intrigued by the Date Night special, $33 for any two menu items plus a bottle of wine or a pitcher of beer. This is available any night after 6 PM. Not a bad price compared to the menu prices for single items.
We will continue to return to Garnett's from time to time. It is good but not fantastic and deserves its place on the dining rotation.