Gem Wine
Permanently Closed
Seasonal small plates, natural wine, and a cozy library-like atmosphere
Seasonal small plates, natural wine, and a cozy library-like atmosphere
"A bar and restaurant located in the Lower East Side, operated by Chef Flynn McGarry. Known for its wine bar and collaborative events with guest chefs and wine purveyors." - Nadia Chaudhury
"At some point in your life, you'll probably be sick of going to weddings every other weekend. If you're still a few years away from that, we bet that when the moment arrives, you'll hear at least a couple wedding speeches that reference a first date at Gem Wine on the Lower East Side. This spot is a Goldilocks zone wine bar—just right for many things. But most of all, it's perfect for actually meeting up with your matches. That's because Gem Wine successfully walks a middle path in everything it does. With battered wood floors and lamps decorated with Goldfish cracker-shaped fish, it's easygoing and welcoming, while the chunky candles and woven seats make it feel grown-up. The lighting is turned down to a sexy wattage, but it's not so dark that you’ll struggle to decipher the 20-page wine list without a pair of readers. photo credit: Alex Staniloff And while you could get just a glass of wine and some sourdough bread and butter, the seasonal dishes here are worth dipping into too. Or, if the date is going really well, you can order their approachable six- to eight-course tasting menu—which is a great deal at $80 per person. The wine bar used to be Gem, a seasonal tasting menu spot started by a chef who was, at the time, too young to legally drink wine. The food here still feels well thought-out, without being too intimidating. Yes, that cured fluke is served inside an orange peel (cute!), the plates are precise and relatively small, and the tasting is called The Experience, but nothing feels more fussy than delicious. This also extends to the drinks—the servers are happy to put on their wine nerd hats if you ask, but most likely they'll just start off describing the day’s by-glass options as white, orange, and red. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Gem Wine takes reservations, but they do save plenty of space for walk-ins, so you shouldn’t have trouble getting seated for more spur-of-the-moment meet-ups, especially if you come in early. Just remember that most of the tables are communal four- and six-tops—so there’s a solid chance you’ll end up on an impromptu double-date. But who knows? A few years down the line, you might be planning a couples’ vacation. Food Rundown The Experience Calling a tasting menu “The Experience” feels a little contrived. But if you’re planning to eat a full meal here and don’t order this, you’re being financially irresponsible. For $80 per person, you’ll get six to eight sharing plates of seasonal dishes, starting with bread and marmite butter, and ending with one of the larger plates, like the lion’s mane schnitzel. On one trip, we had roasted banana squash with enough chanterelles to put Alice in Wonderland. Another time, there was a citrusy fluke crudo with braised seaweed, and a hearty chestnut soup topped with sage crème fraîche. It’s filling, and three a la carte plates per person would take you over the cost of this menu, so it’s a pretty good value. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Sourdough and Marmite Butter You know it, you love it: two thick slabs of sourdough are served with soft, savory butter. The butter is served in a slip of parchment paper with an old, tarnished butter knife for spreading. It’ll kick off the tasting menu, but you should get some even if you’re just here for a glass of wine. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Lion's Mane Schnitzel You can order this a la carte, but given that it costs about half of the price of the tasting menu, you should probably just order the tasting menu. The schnitzel are crispy, and they’re topped with either bitter endives, anchovies, sauce ravigote, and jam. Squeeze some lemon over top, and it’s a satisfying end to your meal. This is a tasty dish, but not transcendent enough to order on its own. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Satsuma and Fluke Crudo This crudo is bright and briny, and served, adorably, in a satsuma peel (or another seasonal citrus). It’s a refreshing early entry in “The Experience,” but we'd recommend getting this even if you’re ordering a la carte. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Salted Cod Beignet with Kosho Aïoli If no one told us there was salted cod in this, we wouldn’t have guessed. This beignet works well enough, especially when served warm alongside the chilled fluke crudo, but it’s not an essential order. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Chestnut Soup with Sage Crème Fraîche and Sourdough Crouton This soup tastes like walking past a roasted chestnut cart around the holidays. Ask if this is on the menu, and save a corner of your bread to wipe out the bowl. photo credit: Alex Staniloff Ginger Cake, Coffee Cream Ice Cream, Poached Pear While everything on this dessert was fine, we’d have been just as happy if dessert was simply a bowl of the ice cream. It was rich, subtle, and velvety." - Will Hartman
"This sibling to Gem that’s around the corner from the restaurant from Flynn McGarry, the guy who opened a tasting menu spot in 2018, when he was 19, specializes in low-intervention winemakers and small dishes like gouda with pears and lamb tartare with greens. You can go even more minimalist with an order of bread and butter or a larger plate of mackerel with rhubarb ponzu. The wine menu has glasses and bottles that rotate regularly. No reservations." - Eater Staff, Melissa McCart
"Gem Wine, a quirky wine bar that looks like a library reading room at the world's coolest college, is perfect for a casual date with someone who appreciates cured fluke and cab franc. The menu changes frequently and is geared toward snacking, with options like mushroom schnitzel and salt cod beignets. If you want to eat more than just a few bites, we highly recommend the family-style meal, which costs $75 per person. It may sound pricey, but it can work out to be more cost-effective than ordering a la carte, and you’ll get to try a bunch of interesting things." - bryan kim, neha talreja, kenny yang, willa moore, will hartman
"This sibling to Gem that’s around the corner from the restaurant from Flynn McGarry (the guy who opened a tasting menu spot in 2018, when he was 19) specializes in low-intervention winemakers and small dishes like gouda with pears or lamb tartare with greens. But yes, you can go even more minimalist with an order of bread and butter or a larger plate such as mackerel with rhubarb ponzu. The wine menu is a rotating selection of by-the-glass and bottles, and like a neighborhood bar, is walk-in only." - Eater Staff