George Keeley
American restaurant · Upper West Side ·
Vast craft beer selection, pub grub, TVs, darts, and free popcorn
Vast craft beer selection, pub grub, TVs, darts, and free popcorn
"A good neighborhood tavern with fine brews, good wings, free popcorn, and 10 TVs: Look for a menu of burgers, reubens, Texas toast, wings, giant pretzels, chili, and fish-and-chips." - Eater Staff
"George Keeley shares a lot of DNA with your average neighborhood bar. It’s a dark space, for example, with TVs, a dartboard, and lots of fried food. But there is one key difference between this place and the usual spot where you lean against a sticky bar and watch some sports: George Keeley takes its beer seriously. They have a TV above the bar showing everything they have on tap, and it even says how much of each keg is left. You can also check these logistics on the website if you’re looking for something specific." - hannah albertine, bryan kim, matt tervooren
"You’re on the Upper West Side, and you want to drink beer. But not a beer that all your friends have heard of. You want something obscure, because your horoscope recently told you to try new things. Go to George Keeley. From the outside, this place looks like a very normal pub - and on the inside it looks pretty normal, too. What sets it apart is the fact that there are so many hard-to-find beers on tap. Big flat-screen TVs behind the bar show lists of what they’re currently pouring - and there are also a few other TVs for watching sports." - will hartman, bryan kim, neha talreja, matt tervooren
"On the Upper West Side, George Keeley’s had its liquor license suspended over the weekend after the State Liquor Authority reported that twelve patrons were sharing a single basket of popcorn, which the SLA said does not meet the agency’s definition of a 'substantial' amount of food." - Luke Fortney
"When seeking a more expansive craft beer selection on the UWS this Sunday, George Keeley is the way to go. It’s got 25 beers on tap, eschewing sports bar standards in favor of unique IPAs, pale ales, and even some wines and ciders. The long food menu includes lots of dressed-up burgers, wings from classic hot to honey garlic, and several salads." - Alexandra Ilyashov