Jonathan R.
Yelp
This place is so small you could drive by it for years and never really notice it was there. That, in fact, is what I did until recently when I visited for the first time. It was nicely decorated with a variety of house-made products on display, and there was a rustic charm to the interior. They sold much of what you'd expect at a cider mill: donuts, pies, caramel apples and, of course, cider.
We ordered a variety of donuts, a slice of pistachio loaf and two hot mulled ciders. I also bought a half-gallon of cider to take home. The man who was working there was friendly and very knowledgeable of the history of the mill. He informed us that Goodison, unlike the nearby Paint Creek Mill, still makes their own cider. The food and cider was tasty, and there were benches and picnic tables outside where we could sit and enjoy our drinks. It doesn't have the scale or production value of a place like Yates in Rochester, but it has a nice location on Orion road and its product is just as good.
I think Goodison is often overshadowed by the larger Paint Creek Cider Mill just up the street, but I would highly recommend dropping in at Goodison to give it a try.