Tyler H.
Yelp
The refreshed ambience at Greenleaf is delightful, with a library or book study theme. I like how the theme carries through to the menu descriptions as well. Our only complaint is that the table we sat at had a glaring light right between us that made it a little difficult to enjoy the meal. Looking around, it seems like it was the only table with this problem, so you should be otherwise fine at any other spot in the restaurant. During nicer weather days, dining on the Calle outside is another fantastic option.
The menus here have good variety. I've been to Greenleaf for both breakfast and dinner, and I always find multiple things that look enticing. On our latest visit, I was committed to dining as a vegetarian, and I still found multiple favorable options to pick from, which is a definite plus. It's always sad for a vegetarian when all you can order is a salad, but at Greenleaf you're given several options, which is excellent.
Rating the food is a little tricky. Wifey ordered the Tuna Salad Sandwich on Sourdough and I ordered the Pesto Veggie sandwich on a Croissant. In both cases, the presentation was good, and the sandwich fillings were excellent. Both of us were disappointed with the breads, however. The Sourdough seemed stale and could not stand up to the fillings. The Croissant was stiff and not flaky...it also seemed stale as well. I think they source their bread locally from the Apple Cellar Baker (aka Village Baker) located in Ashland, so it's probably not an issue with their supplier. Maybe the bread needs to be toasted a bit, or perhaps there is a storage or freshness issue? Not sure. We opted for their salmon chowder as a $2 upgrade to the entrees as a side, and it was definitely worth it. Very good.
Service was acceptable, at best. It seemed that our server was grumpy and we were inconveniencing him with our presence. Our waters were never refilled, and it wasn't ideal that the default tip was 18% on the Toast POS system. I still gave the 18%, but I always find it cheeky when restaurants assume that, especially when service doesn't seem a focal point. We're chalking this up as 'anyone can have an off day.'
Overall, we would rate Greenleaf as a 'solid' experience. I'm sure we'll dine there again, but perhaps breakfast is the better meal option to go with.