Heritage Tavern

I went here for the first time for a birthday dinner and was honestly stunned at how great the food was. The menu leaves your tastebuds watering with their perfect descriptions of their options. Our table ordered the deviled eggs as an appetizer and it was a hit! I have never had such fancy deviled eggs before. Visually impeccable 👌 The entrees were also amazing. The special that evening was Red Snapper (meant for two) and was also a hit! Service was fast and friendly. Such a unique cozy atmosphere. Hands down would recommend if you are looking for a special night out!

This was my first time here, and the atmosphere was nice. Great staff! I loved the drink that I had, but the food was not for me. I don't eat pork, and they had a lot of dishes with pork in them—a little on the pricy side.

Something wonderfully warm and welcoming about this place. The space itself is a nice step back in time and the wood (mahogany I guess?) gives it a nice feeling to gobble anything there. Their Nitro Willy will make you come alive, it's like a tequila based espresso martini. The cinnamon roll with ham is amazing. That, with coffee now would be breakfast, but no. We also ordered shrimp with grits and lamb French toast and Suri served us right and also fixed our wobbly table, which by the way would not have gotten in the way of eating all the deliciousness. Great vibes too! Please go! Enjoy.

What an wonderful evening. We were able to enjoy their summer restaurant week menu. The staff are incredible with their knowledge of the menu, attentiveness and friendly service. The food was cooked perfectly and absolutely delicious! We enjoyed a few specialty drinks…the complexity and depth of flavors were off the charts…everything from drinks through dessert was wonderful

Great surprise in downtown Madison. We ordered many great dishes, including the peppercorn steak and short rib (fantastic combination) as well as a special of the day that consisted of a duck and lamb dish. The depth and complexity of flavors were unmatched in our adventures around Madison. Heirloom carrots, wine sauces, wild mushrooms, potatoes, pinto beans and many other fresh and deliciously cooked ingredients that created beautiful and full flavors in your mouth. We will definitely be returning and have found a new favorite next to the Capitol.

I wasn’t impressed with the food. I was excited to try the deviled eggs, but they were just salty and lacked flavor, which was disappointing, especially at over $3 per HALF egg. The pork schnitzel had a strong, distinct scent and flavor that didn’t work for me either. The dishes also took 45 minutes to arrive.

I really enjoyed the service that I did here. They were very attentive and accommodating to my questions. I thought that the food was great, and I look forward to visiting again.

I really enjoied my experience at Heritage Tavern. The menu had so many delicious items, we couldn't stop adding to our order. Each dish was full of fresh flavors and bright colors that really showcased the quality of not only the food it's self, but the staff who prepared it. The grilled peach and beet salad popped with fresh flavors as was the heirloom tomato dish with stuffed squash blossom and smooth tomato sorbet. Definitely a culinary gem in Madison, WI.