Hog Island Hoagie - inside Petoskey's Sports Bar in Fremont

Sandwich shop · Fremont

Hog Island Hoagie - inside Petoskey's Sports Bar in Fremont

Sandwich shop · Fremont

125 N 36th St, Seattle, WA 98103

Highlights

Philadelphia-style hoagies, Italian subs, cheesesteaks, beer, wine

125 N 36th St, Seattle, WA 98103 Get directions

hogislandhoagie.com

@hogislandhoagie

$10–20 · Menu

@infatuation

The Seattle Boat Sandwich Guide

"For Philadelphia-inspired hoagies involving a combination of meats and lots of spicy pickled stuff, Hog Island (located inside Petoskey's) is our #1. It’s impossible to go wrong with anything here, whether you’re in the mood for a hero with ham and white american cheese or a vegetable hoagie with olive tapenade and roasted tomato, but our favorite is the namesake Hog Islander. It comes stacked with ham, salami, coppa, mortadella, provolone, and spicy peppers—and to really get into that east coast spirit, tack on a bag of Herr’s chips." - aimee rizzo, kayla sager riley

https://www.theinfatuation.com/seattle/guides/best-sandwiches-seattle-summer

View Postcard for Hog Island Hoagie - inside Petoskey's Sports Bar in Fremont

@infatuation

Hog Island Hoagie - Review - Fremont - Seattle - The Infatuation

"For Philadelphia-inspired hoagies involving a combination of meats and lots of spicy pickled stuff ranging from giardiniera to Mama Lil’s, Hog Island (located inside Petoskey's) is our #1. It’s impossible to go wrong with anything here, whether you’re in the mood for a hero with ham and white american cheese or a vegetable hoagie with olive tapenade and roasted tomato, but our favorite is the namesake Hog Islander. It comes stacked with ham, salami, coppa, mortadella, provolone, and spicy peppers—and to really get into that east coast spirit, tack on a bag of Herr’s chips." - Aimee Rizzo

https://www.theinfatuation.com/seattle/reviews/hog-island-hoagie

View Postcard for Hog Island Hoagie - inside Petoskey's Sports Bar in Fremont

Tim Kviz

Google

I’m downgrading what I would normally rate this place for one specific ingredient - they no longer offer the soft French roll and The Sea Wolf hoagie is really not a great match to these sandwiches. I can’t imagine getting a cheesesteak on it, it’s too tough and not what I came to love about the sandwiches here. The sandwiches are rad but I’ll refrain from ordering until the soft roll comes back to the menu because it’s too much $$$ for a sandwich if you don’t like the bread…

Samantha Howard

Google

My official plea to bring back the old roll! We moved here from Philadelphia and these sandwiches have always been a taste of home but I gotta tell ya this new bread isn’t it…it’s too dense and the outside is too hard and overall has too much chew to it…

charles morgan

Google

I was looking for the deli but they’re working out of petrovskis bar and I was pleasantly surprised. The bartender is super friendly and attentive and the food was very good. I have been craving a hoagie since I moved here from Philadelphia. The sandwiches here are the real deal.

Nikki Cruz

Google

Dude I really love this place's sandwiches Reminds us of the east Coast. BUT if they put mayo on.my sandwich one more time...... After specifically asking for none..... $18 in.the garbage. Ugh. I'm going to stop ordering if it happens to us again.

Alexandria Bodas

Google

Solid sandwich experience at Hog Island Hoagie today. When we arrived we weren't 100% sure we were in the right place-- it's inside Petoskey's Pizza and didn't see much Hog Island-related signage. We arrived during typical lunch hours and there was only one employee working, so it took maybe 15 minutes for two sandwiches, but not a big deal for us. The Hog Islander (Italian sub) was delicious and the American Hero was pretty good too. We'll be back!

Sierra Gonzales

Google

This kitchen is inside Petoskey's in Fremont and they have the best Italian sandwich (aside from JM) and one of the best cheese steaks in town! I've been a loyal customer for years now and always order the same thing. It's the perfect hangover cure, if you don't skip the Chicago pickle. Yum!

Mackenzie Brisben

Google

Such a great sandwich! I had the Steamboat NOLA and the Starboard with a pickle. Loved it. Very nice ambiance and fun to watch games.

Shawn Wright

Google

Nice hoagie for Seattle. Bread was good, but I do wish that they would have scooped some out. Ordered the Italian and held the mayo.