JD H.
Yelp
My family rented a three bedroom/three bath, that could accommodate six adults, via Marriott Homes & Villas. The unit was less expensive on Expedia, but with my Marriott points, the price was reduced significantly. Although I booked through the Marriott website, their "trusted partner" was Maui Rentals which was responsive to my questions prior to our visit. I reserved a pack n play and high chair at no additional cost. The unit touted its well appointed kitchen and because we had a toddler with us, I wanted to book a place that included a kitchen, since we planned to eat most of our meals there.
Before our arrival, I was told that we could use the bellmen to help with our bags and there would be five "bracelets" (to be used for towels) waiting for us. When we arrived, there were two bracelets and no one would call Maui Rentals, but gave us the phone number (?). I called and was told they would bring over the additional bracelets. They were not delivered so my husband had to walk to another location to pick them up. Strike One.
We had also been given the combination to our room for keyless entry, which we received via email. When I got to the room there was no combination display so again I had to call someone and experienced yet another delay. Finally someone called and said that our floor hadn't been set up yet for a combination entry so we should use the bracelets, which at that time not everyone had. Strike Two.
When we finally entered the unit with the bellman, everything seemed fine at first glance. Then we opened the glass door to the balcony and ran smack into the dining table and chairs which were in the way and very tattered (no doubt a result of the placement of the chairs and table). It impossible to avoid hitting the chairs, much less fully open the door. We had to physically move everything in order to do that.
The kitchen was visually impressive. Viking appliances, wine refrigerator and even a Vitamix blender. Unfortunately, it was NOT well stocked. There were plates, cups, cereal bowls, glasses, flatware and a few small pots and pans. No prep bowls, pitchers (other than a small one for water), platters (which I had planned to use for the communal BBQs) or covered storage containers. The toaster was half broken, as was the ice maker in the freezer. Needless to say, it was not what was represented to us. So began a number of calls and texts to Maui Rentals. They delivered two large bags of ice and offered to "shop" for whatever we needed. We were told that the unit was individually owned but clearly it was commercially "stocked." I was asked to give them a list of what I needed.
Initially, a few items were delivered. I then spoke to a rep at Maui Rentals who shamed me when she said, "Well, most people come for vacation not for cooking!" That's why you advertised such a wonderful kitchen complete with a wine refrigerator and Viking appliances? That was more than Strike Three, and we ended up spending a lot of money on food which we was not in our original plan. I was told that they would "go shopping" for things we needed, which they did, but after going back and forth, many kitchen items weren't available in Lahaina (i.e. platters to move food to the communal BBQs), so we gave up.
At least one of the community pools was blocked from use (and for two days there were two pools out) during our entire stay at Honua Kai except for the day we left. Two different pools had pipes break which looked like sewage (it wasn't), however they worked on the big one and it was cleaned up in a day or so. The other pool had problems during the entire week until our last day. As others have pointed out, there was a lot of construction going on, however we didn't see much in Konea, the building in which we rented.
Because of the kitchen misrepresentation, I wrote Marriott's CEO and the VP in charge of Homes & Villas requesting my points be returned since we spent a significant amount of money eating out but received 10% of what I used...a token offer which shocked and disappointed me. Ironically, once home I received a text from Maui Rentals' stating its goal was 100% satisfaction and asked if there was anything to address. I shared thoughts including their representative's comments to me. On the day after we returned home I received the text, "Mahalo for your stay with Maui Resort Rentals! One simple yes/no question. Would you recommend us to your ohana (family) or friends? We value your feedback!" I did not reply.
On the bright side, the facility is in a great location between Lahaina and Kapalua, and we enjoyed its beach. Our view from our unit was terrific (see attached photo). There is a Duke's restaurant on site, but expect a wait. If you decide to come, ASK about construction and, if important to you, how the kitchen is stocked. I don't believe we'll return, although the three bedrooms/three bath unit was exactly what we needed.