Charlotte M.
Yelp
I must respond to the ridiculous review calling this bagel inauthentic! Ashley, clearly, you don't have my experience.
I am a fourth-generation NYC native. I know what a NYC bagel is about. Ashley, bagels started to get bigger and the holes became smaller, in NYC, sometime in the 1980s-1990s when bagel sandwiches became a craze. The timing also correlates to when fast-food restaurants were supersizing their products. 7/11 even introduced their Big-Gulp fountain drinks, as well. It is when all the good stuff I knew as a kid growing up in the 1970s became unhealthy. It is the era that brought us an obesity epidemic, too!
I grew up on NYC bagels, as did my family. My dad would bring back bags of the most delicious bagels, bialys and pleztels from his old Brooklyn neighborhood at least once a month, after we moved to the other side of the Hudson, settling in NJ. Northern NJ, because of its proximity to NYC, also has great bagels.
When I moved to SF, over twenty years ago, I would drive 15-20 minutes to House of Bagels because I longed for an authentic NYC bagel. Now, I live much closer to this shop.
Quite frankly, Boichik Bagels was incredibly promising when they had only one shop in Berkely. Then, they automated their kitchen. They have the top NYC old-fashioned bagel recipe, but robots mess them up. I ate a few Boichik bagels when they were still hand-rolling them, and they were incredible. Today, I prefer House of Bagels.
I call House of Bagels an ordinary NYC bagel place but for the San Francisco Bay Area, it is extraordinary!
I miss authentic Bialys. Wise Sons, for a short window of time, actually were producing perfect NYC bialys but they settled on a product that is a bit inauthentic.
Pleztels are nowhere to be found, even in NYC, when I go back. If only I could find a good knish here. Alas, I wait until I am back in NYC and head to Yonah Schimmels, on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, where my family has been eating for over 100 years! That place has never changed!
I go back east at least once a year. As someone who remembers the city from way back when and who grew up hearing what NYC was even before, I promise you that NYC is barely holding on to its past! The accent is even disappearing!