Mike L.
Yelp
With essentially all of Monterey's food scene to be explored, figuring out which restaurant to try first felt a lot like one of those "Choose Your Own Adventure" books. Do we hit up one of the popular touristy spots? Something on my list of Yelp bookmarks? Or maybe wherever the wind happened to take us? Funny enough - after walking around the area to assess our options, coming to Hula Island Grill ended up answering "yes" to all three questions!
While a few others places we saw also piqued our interest, the promise of good Hawaiian food and the lively atmosphere here was too much to resist. Inside, we were surprised by how packed it was on a random weeknight and how well the decor leans into the tiki theme without being cliche. As for the menu, given how it's Monterey, most of their dishes, whether it be their pupus/apps, bowls, burgers, sandwiches, entrees, tacos, salads, or house specialties, feature seafood prepared in various ways, but there are plenty of non-seafood options, too, including short ribs, ribeye steaks, and Jamaican jerk chicken, just to name a few. What's more, the cocktail menu is even more interesting than the food!
-- HULA'S MAI TAI - Gold Rum, Orange Curacao, Pineapple and Lime Juice, Orgeat, Dark Rum Float...$12
This may not have been the best mai tai I've had, but it was pretty solid. The orange curacao, pineapple, and lime juice, combined with both types of rum, created a fruity and floral mixture that still had a nice hit of alcohol.
-- DR. FUNK - Coconut Rum, Vodka, Creme de Banana, Pineapple, OJ...$11
Just as we sat down, I overheard a nearby table get three of these and I could easily see why. The taste of this was like banana mixed into a pina colada (in a good way), but sweeter and also thinner in consistency. The rum rounded out the flavors quite nicely, though it was pretty subtle.
-- CRISPY COCONUT SHRIMP ROLLS with Pineapple and Horseradish Dipping Sauce...$14
Not as amazing as I had hoped for, but not bad either. I liked that the skins weren't super thick and that chunks of shrimp were quite big. However, the filling was also really wet, which might also be why the outside of the rolls weren't very crispy.
-- AHI KATSU TACOS - Seared Panko-Encrusted Ahi Steak, Sriracha, Taco Slaw, Sundried Tomato Pesto Aioli...$23
Meh...this was okay. The tuna itself wasn't bad, and the portion was generous, but this was more "katsu" than katsu. Parts of the fish also tasted burnt/dry, but at least the slaw and aioli helped on that front. Funny enough, we both thought this might have worked better just seared without the panko.
-- BLACKENED WASABI BARRAMUNDI with Mashed Potatoes, Wasabi Cream Sauce, and Arugula Salad...$27
The tacos may not have impressed, but this one certainly did! The barramundi was cooked perfectly (really moist on the inside) and, between the seasoning and wasabi cream sauce, the flavors were great. As for the sides, both were terrific, especially the arugula.
As far as service goes, we didn't have much to complain about for the most part. The hostess who greeted us was friendly and her comment to "not worry about the wait" was spot on (we waited no more than 5-10 mins). Once we were seated, it did feel a little like we had been forgotten about, as it took a bit before our server came by, but it seemed like may have been tied up with a large party, as we saw him fairly regularly after that. We also appreciated how engaging and energetic he was, though a couple of the jokes he made were more awkward than funny.
Considering how so many people like Hula's Island Grill, including what seemed like a number of locals/regulars, part of me can't help but wonder if what we ordered had something to do with it. Although the rolls and ahi katsu tacos are two of their more popular dishes, perhaps their ceviche, chicken wings, kalbi ribs, or shrimp tacos would've been better choices. In that vein, I wouldn't be opposed to coming back one day to find out, but if it's about the same as what we had, I'd rather just stick to the cocktail menu.