Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

I tried two scoops - Root Beer Float and Brambleberry Crisp - at Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams. Since I am allergic to eggs, I asked the staff about ingredients, and they were very clear about which flavors had eggs and which did not. They also had great sorbet options for vegans. I appreciated being able to sample flavors before choosing. The staff were friendly, patient, and helpful, even with a big crowd waiting. Both flavors were tasty, but I was especially impressed with the Root Beer Float - it really tasted like the drink! The shop is busy, but worth the wait. I would definitely come back.

Local ice cream place with a great many super interesting flavors. While you are likely to find a line, it is worth it. I had the burnt orange - so delicious! Also yummy was the brown butter almond brittle and the gooey butter cake. Heck, all the flavors we tried were DELICIOUS!! Go today! Go again! Yum!!!

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams in the Short North is a must-stop for anyone craving unique and delicious ice cream. What really stood out during my visit was the exceptional service. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful, making the sampling process a joy. They offered generous samples, answered questions with enthusiasm, and provided thoughtful recommendations. Their patience and genuine warmth created a welcoming atmosphere, making it easy to navigate all the flavors. While Jeni's is known for its ice cream, the positive and attentive service from the staff truly elevated the experience.

Staff were friendly and welcoming! I have been a long time Jeni’s fan and getting to go in person was fantastic. Loved all the specialty combos on the menu!

Unique flavors that somehow just work! We had had pints of Jeni’s from the grocery store but were thrilled for the opportunity to try ice cream from the scoop shop itself and we were not disappointed! We shared the ice cream flight which comes with 10 scoops of 10 different flavors and waffle cone pieces on the side. Each flavor was unique and offered something different. My favorite was the “everything bagel” which was a savory ice cream and very different from anything I’d had before. My wife’s favorite was the honey vanilla bean. All the ice creams were soft, creamy and not overly sweet. Some of the best ice cream we’ve had! Hope to see them open a shop in Kansas City someday!

One thing about me is if I’m in a state that has a Jeni’s, I will make it a point to stop by. It’s a must. I always get my almond brittle butter ice cream and it never disappoints. The flavor is rich and creamy, with that sweet and slightly nutty crunch that makes it unforgettable. And their waffle cone? Absolute perfection! It’s crisp, buttery, and the perfect match for their ice cream. I’ve loved Jeni’s for years, and every visit reminds me why. The quality is always consistent, the flavors are creative and bold, and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. Whether it’s a quick treat on a hot day or a little indulgence after dinner, Jeni’s always hits the spot. This is one of those places I’ll keep coming back to, no matter where I am.

First time in Columbus, OH and I was advised to stop by Jeni's for ice cream. This was the best suggestion. This place had great customer service and a variety of ice cream to pick from. Jeni's even lets you sample every ice cream they have with no pressure to buy any. If you're near a Jeni's ice cream,definitely stop by and grab some

So many choices for ice cream. Very nice delicious flavors. Staff seemed extremely knowledgeable about the descriptions of each flavor. I was disappointed that they only offered ice cream cones and bowls. No other type of desserts like shakes exedra. There is a bathroom there you can use. We were very pleased that they had free tap water available in the dining room. That was super helpful since we had been walking around outside in the heat for 3 hours downtown. As expected, the prices were extremely high.

Jeni's is my go to ice cream shop in Columbus. They have a ton of fun & unique flavors that are made with the best ingredients & you can taste the quality! It's fun trying all of their new limited time & seasonal flavors; there's bound to be a flavor for everyone any time you go! I love all of the fantastic locations they have as well; the walk up window in German Village, and the locations in the Short North & Grandview are my favorite; because they're perfect for grabbing a scoop or two & then enjoying a nice walk with your delicious ice cream! For those that normally have to skip out on ice cream due to dietary restrictions, Jeni's is still for you! They have a ton of dairy free ice creams that are seriously quality & taste great! My go to is Texas sheet cake, it's loaded on the chocolate flavors, but all the df options like Carmel Pecan Sticky Buns, Banana Cream Pudding & even the Frosé are all amazing! Most of these are vegan, & they have a ton of gluten free options as well! Regardless of the kind of ice cream you like, Jeni's is a spot you need to try!

I have been coming to Jeni's since she first opened and High St was her only location. I love that she started in Columbus, so even when I lived out in TX- I supported her. I do think her flavors are getting a bit much. Her originals like the goat cheese and red berries & chocolate cayenne were just so different. She has very different flavors now, but the vast majority have been bad recently. The s'more advertised marshmallow, gave ashtray. All the traditional/ not seasonal flavors taste the same.

Ok, it's ice cream. So you know, it's yummy. But they have really cool flavors and these crazy house-made waffle cones too. We are chocolate fans, so we had to do the double dark chocolate. I also had the salted peanut butter something or other, all yummy. Great service, the line is long, but they seem to keep it moving and are plenty friendly. Prices are reasonable and you get 2-half scoops per order, so you can try two different flavors. They also include a little pie-shaped piece of the yummy waffle cones with each order in a cup. Good call!

Saw this ice cream shop everywhere. Fun flavors that hit the spot. They have seasonal flavors that are worth a try, but if you don't like things too sweet I'd stick to the classics. I sooo wish I could have tried their miso flavor ice cream. Instead I tried their gooey butter cake and cookie dough. Also v good and we were able to get a split scoop !

Now this ice cream was amazing. My first time ever trying it. They let you try as many flavors as you want! The guy working was really nice and patient. There a few seats right by this location it is fairly loud because I'd eh food hall.

Service was super friendly and welcoming. And the ambiance is your typical neighborhood ice cream shop, super inviting and nostalgic. I needed some caffeine and was in the mood for some ice cream after failing two exams back to back, so I found myself at jeni's ordering an affogato. The fine folks at jeni's usually recommend you get the affogato with the brown butter almond brittle, and who am I to say otherwise. They poured maybe 3-4 oz of dark, concentrated cold brew over two scoops of ice cream and off I went to my precariously parked car to scarf it down. Initially I thought that the ratio of ice cream to coffee was a little too much and I thought it would have been better with espresso as opposed to cold brew but I ate a spoonful and it all made sense. The smoothness and slight bitterness of the cold brew played perfectly with the ice cream and there were bits of almonds and brittle in every bite to add textural variation. At the end you're left with this nice little latte situation to top it off. Super fun and interesting experience, would definitely recommend!

Delicious ice cream and I love the "standard" which is 2 small scoops of 2 flavors for 6.50 that is not California prices and it keeps me coming back each day for more! The salted peanut butter and goey cake together was delightful. Service was fast and friendly and felt bubbly and fun just like the interior of this shop. Loved every minute and every bite

This is such a fun spot to go to. They have some of the most unique ice cream flavors I've seen with combinations that work really well together. The staff was super friendly and patient with me as I asked questions about the flavors and tasted multiple. My favorite I tried was the brambleberry crisp. I loved the textures and fruit flavor mixed into the ice cream. I sat on the patio and it felt like I was almost at the beach. I enjoyed the decor they had as well as the ample seating area outside. I will definitely be back here when I make another Mason trip.

We came on a Saturday afternoon and the line was pretty long but it went by quickly. The servers were super nice and offered samples even though there was a line. Flavors were amazing as always, especially the tropical bloom (spring flavor). There isn't any seating next to the stand but there is plenty of comfortable seating upstairs of Short North market.

Amazing selection of gourmet ice creams. They advertise their cookie dough as some of their best ice cream and I have to agree. Creamy and full of cookie dough - some of the best ice cream I've ever had. Lovely seating area in the back where we enjoyed our ice cream. Great service. Ask to taste flavors before you select your ice cream. They have small tasting spoons. 5/5. Will be back! Thanks for having me.

Ordered peanut butter flavored icecream and it was amazingly. Service was good. Ambiance was lovely and cute. Will definitely recommend it to my friends.

So many creative flavors so little time! I sampled at least 4-5 flavors before I decided to get a signature bowl that allows you to get 3. The shop was completely empty when I came in so service was quick. Pretty straight forward, nothing that stood out but no complaints.

Have had Jenis many times it it never fails. My usual favorites are the Brambleberry Crisp, Coffee with Cream and Sugar, and the Wildberry Lavendar. Today I got two scoops, which contains one of my favorites - Bramberry Crisp, and a new flavor - Bastani Sonnati. The new flavor is basically a balance of saffron, rose water, and pistachio. Not a super strong taste, but still refreshing! Service is always great as they ask you what flavors you would like to try.

Such a cute location. Walked around the SN and atopped in to try the new special with Bastani Sonnati, Brambleberry crisp, and brown butter almond brickle in a waffle cup. Chef's kiss of complimentary flavors! Staff was super friendly and helpful despite the long line. Everything was working smoothly and with kindness!

SO GOOD! I loved every bite of this icecream and cone! Definitely higher price tag but a perfect treat! Loved the coffee flavour.

Amazing vegan ice cream! I had the lemon bar ice cream and it was just like the dessert as it's named after. So creamy so lemony and just to write amount of sweetness. I would definitely return to this place when I get back here.

Came in here today with my wife and mother-in-law to get some ice cream and had an amazing time! If you're like me and the other 99% of Americans who love ice cream, you NEED to try Jeni's ice cream. I've had plenty of ice cream in the past and this is definitely the best I've ever had. The staff was super friendly and environment was so welcoming. The only downside was that there was nowhere to park and my father-in-law had to stay in the car while we ran in. Definitely come to this location when you're in the area next!

Walked in on a random Wednesday in February with a group of 10. They were so nice to us, didn't rush, and let us sample any kids we wanted. Great selection and service. I really liked that they would do 1/2 scoops.

GF, Dairy Free, and Vegan options. Quality and simple ingredients. Nice portions for price!

I always make a trip to Jeni's whenever I'm back in Ohio because it's my absolute favorite ice cream. We had a chance to try two of their limited flavors boozy eggnog and white chocolate peppermint in a waffle cone bowl. The bowl became a little hard to eat at the end so I would recommend just getting a waffle cone wedge. All of their flavors are great and you truly can't go wrong with any of them. Some of my favorites being gooey butter cake and brambleberry crisp They have some other locations through out the Midwest as well and would highly recommend making a trip if you're near a location.

Overall the ice cream was amazing. So many different options. Upon arrival I was very overwhelmed since never going before and the line was decent size but moving quickly. The staff rushed me (understandably just trying to get through the line) but I felt like I didn't really get to fully appreciate the experience or flavors. Overall a nice location but not worth eating there. Just take it to go.

Can't say enough about the overall quality and selection of flavors. Do yourself a flavor, and if in the area stop. You will not be disappointed!

Overall a good place to get ice cream. I like that they use local partners for their coffee. The flavors are quite unconventional and portions are small but I like the decor and atmosphere. Service was good, it was refreshing in this day and age to be greeted by someone that enjoys their job. The waffle bowl was a nice addition but tasted again a little unconventional, like salted caramel, which personally isn't my preference but was still good.

Charlie in short north jenis is awesome!!! I went in with friends not going to get anything and he made all the flavors sound so good I left with two pints

So happy Jeni's has fun dairy-free ice cream. The Texas sheet cake is rich and you can't even tell it is dairy-free. Friendly service and clean establishment.

Jeni's is easily the best ice cream spot in Columbus! The aroma alone makes it nearly impossible to not stop in when walking down the street. It's always fun sampling the unique flavors, and nearly impossible to pick when it comes time to order. Today I went with Gooey Butter Cake and Brambleberry Crisp which were both decadent, creamy, and delicious. I love how the cups come with a waffle cone piece, too.

Jeni's has to be my favorite ice cream place around. They have a wide variety of flavors that are exchanged and switched around by season. I like this factor, I can always try something new. They allow you to sample flavors and the prices are decent. Staff is so helpful and always friendly!

Get the flight. Get the sodi pop. Don't question the dinosaurs you may see snacking on ice cream the day before Halloween.

I was in Columbus for three days for a conference and I came to Jeni's at least once a day. I tried several of their flavors and each one was divine. Jeni's has the waffle bowl which I have never seen before. Game changer. Ice cream will never be the same again.

Jeni's is premium ice cream, rich with flavor. They are now allowing you to come inside to order (previously, you had to order by the window due to the pandemic) but still currently no seating. This may change shortly as they do have seating in the back, and restrictions are loosening up. I've tried most all flavors and will say that many are very RICH. The Texas sheet cake ice cream is potently chocolate. My favorites are the gooey butter cake, brown butter almond brittle, and salted peanut butter with chocolate flecks. The first two are very sweet, and the peanut butter is more mild. I typically get a waffle cone when I come in. Note that they are made in store and have a strong butter flavor to them. They're unlike most any waffle cones I have had. They also offer birthday cones. So, go and enjoy a scoop on your special day if you're nearby!

Ice cream is my comfort food, the one item in my fridge I always grab for. Whether I'm happy, or stressed, or trying to survive a pandemic... it's always there. Better yet, this location of Jeni's Ice Cream has always BEEN THERE! Between the pint of peanut butter and chocolate flecks that was delivered to help me get through a crazy presidential debate, to the wildberry lavender scoops I randomly grab while on long walks down High St., I know I can count on Jeni's when I need it the most. Especially in this somewhat alternate universe, that is 2020! While I'm always eager to spread the word on Jeni's, I'm here updating this review to share with you all the updates they've made to help keep you safe and healthy. For starters, the experience is one hundred percent contactless. You actually never step foot in the scoop shop. They have a plastic barrier set up at the door and this is where you will order and pay for your treat. As always, the personality of the staff is hard to miss. Their positivity, lively spirit, and love for ice cream is still clearly evident. They are happy to serve ice cream and spread smiles. You pick your ice cream order up around the corner at the entrance on Lincoln St. It's actually the cutest thing ever. They made a little window-like structure to keep things safe. From that point, enjoy! While samples are a no-go and the shop is off limits for now, the experience is still splendid. The ice cream is also as good as ever and you can't go wrong with any flavor. For me, if I could give Jeni's a sixth star, I would. Anytime a company's values align with my own AND they have insanely high quality products that taste this good, I'll gladly give them my money.

Let's see three visits in two days. I am a fan. I was stoked that this shop was a short walk from my hotel. I've been a fan from as far as Boston when my friend found Jeni's Brambleberry Crisp in a specialty food store.

Jeni's is high quaintly ice cream with amazing flavor options! Highly recommend visiting Jeni's when you can

Jeni's is my favorite ice cream shop. This location has a great selection to have scooped there or to take pints home. There are plenty of places to stop for food or shopping in Short North, and there's a good amount of parking too. Brambleberry crisp and Brown butter almond brittle are my classic order, they never disappoint!

Great late night snack and stopped by because who says no to ice cream? Nice location situated in Short North, friendly team members, light and refreshing flavors, and all the samples you want... Don't go too crazy! Went with a single order, or up to 2 flavors, of Honey Vanilla Bean and limited edition Wedding Cake. It was a masterful combination with both flavors and even included 2 free pieces of waffle cone. Visiting a physical Jeni's location is a must when in Columbus, and you get to learn about its ice cream while snacking on it.

Yallllll this ice cream is bussssin'!!!! They ain't playing no games here! Do you need to go after pay day because it's so expensive? Yes Should you care? No. This is the definition of treat yo' self! They have fun unique flavors and I promise you if you try their ooey gooey butter cake flavor on their homemade Waffle cone you will have an out of body experience.

Some work colleagues gifted me a 3-month subscription to the Pint Club and my quick reaction is... wow! I hadn't heard of Jeni's before which was likely one of the reasons they chose it. I love ice cream and I've tried premium ice cream all of the US. Jeni's ranks. Jeni's packages the ice cream so well that it arrived still frozen even though FedEx delayed it for three days. And I live in CA so it's not like they could rely on cold weather. Oh, and they shipped real spoons to eat it with. Major props. Of course, you're here to read about the ice cream... Brandied Banana Brûlée: Jeni's calls it as banana foster mixed with creme brûlée and that's a perfect description. Clearly made with real bananas and not the flavoring that most places do. To top it off, there's apple brandy added. Phenomenal. 94 points. Buttercream Birthday Cake: Buttercream ice cream with sponge cake pieces and blue + pink funfetti sprinkles. It really does taste like birthday cake. I'm not a buttercream fan so this was my least fav BUT... my wife loved this and it was her favorite. 80 points (without the spousal override). Brown Butter Almond Brittle: Buttercream ice cream with pockets of almond brittle. It's sweet, salty, and crunchy all at the same time. Remember how I said I didn't like buttercream? Umm, this changes my mind. 86 points. Blackout Chocolate Cake: The inner lining says OMFG. 'Nuff said? Chocolate cake pieces with fudge AND chocolate chips in dark chocolate ice cream. Dense and rich but not too sweet. As chocolate should be. 93 points. Coffee With Cream & Sugar: One of the few coffee ice creams I've ever had which smelled & tasted like good coffee. That's because they steep coffee grounds directly into the cream, instead of just adding coffee concentrate or flavoring. 92 points. Goat Cheese With Red Cherry: Likely the most surprising of the 12 flavors I tried. This is like a cherry cheesecake -- a really good cheesecake but the cherries are off. There's not enough of them and they don't have enough tartness. I would really like to the goat cheese base with some other fruit. 86 points. I had 6 more flavors which varied from amazing to just ok. Jeni's ice cream is pricy but, except for the occasional miss, top notch.

First time at Jeni's and it was spectacular! Love the vanilla honey and the staff was outstanding with recommendations and allowing us to sample! Enjoyed our ice cream to go back in our hotel.

Amazing as always! This was our first time trying this location and they could not have been more friendly. It is small but has some seating options. We tried the flight. (See pics). It was 10 different flavors of ice cream for $20, which hubby and I split. They were out of two flavors, which we swapped out for strawberry and some other (nutty flavored ice cream). My personal favorites were the dark chocolate and berry lavender. I love rich, in-your-face flavors and both of these are like that. They have some lighter flavored ice creams too like their honey vanilla. My hubby really liked the rainbow flavored ice cream, which was really fruity. The PB with chocolate flakes was also REALLY good. We really liked ALL the flavors and we love that Jeni's always has unique flavors and a wide variety. We love Jeni's Ice Cream and will definitely be back!

I can't help to try this limited time release flavor - everything bagel. It definitely tasted like the everything bagel. Very interesting and unique. I also got the gooey butter cake one, and I think I still prefer sweet ice cream more haha. But they were all very tasty!

A must stop! Ice cream is relevant any time of the year, especially at Jeni's. Unique ice cream flavors that are smooth and refreshing. I went with one kiddy scoop of brambleberry crisp and one kiddy scoop of gooey butter cake. I got a cup and was pleasantly surprised to see you also get a complimentary corner of a cone. Perfect addition with the ice cream. The ice cream was creamy and fresh. You could taste all the flavors and all the textures in the ice cream. Price was about $5 plus tax - so a little pricey but the quality is great. Staff were friendly and efficient. I asked for about 3 different samples - the worker did not seemed annoyed and gladly gave me samples to try. I also love the metal sample spoons - much more eco friendly! There is a seating area in the back of the store to enjoy your ice cream. A long community style table, bench, and bar top seating. I also love the provided water cooler - always need water to wash down ice cream. Tips - 1) Get two kiddy scoops to equal a single scoop. I was able to get two different flavors at a smaller portion size. 2) try as many samples as you like - no shame!

Great service and even better ice cream! Loved getting three small scoops was definitely a great treat

Very good, love the ice cream and the options for people that like the fruitier ice cream flavors. Good environment and nice people. I'd say with no competition around they should maybe bring a couple more sherbet flavors but thats coming from someone that's not as crazy about the typical flavors of ice cream. My wife loved hers and I thought hers was great too. Hard to create boundaries for customers but they also act a little strange here, just seems like they don't think they'll have time to look while ordering or something lol.

The flavors look obscene & our scoops were so delicious. There was a line outside & a line to get a seat. It was is difficult everything looked so good; unfortunate we couldn't sample anything today. The shop was beautifully decorated and they even had gift cookbooks and syrups for sale. This is the original and now it's a chain.

Really cute layout, clean and simple. Service was good took a little bit because they have such unique flavors that you have to try them. They are all good and they are very generous to allow you to try whatever you ask.

On a chilly night there is nothing better than some delicious ice cream! Not only was the ice cream creamy and delicious the flavors were immaculate! A lot if the time pumpkin flavor ice cream can taste artificial but this was just like taking a bite of pumpkin cake. The brown butter almond brittle change my life outlook on brittle. Usually I'm not a fan because it gets stuck in your teeth but after the taster I had to have more. The brown butter based compliments the nutty flavor of the almond brittle and omg it is happiness in your mouth. Highly recommend making a stop here for a sweet treat!

Delicious Not too sweet I ordered chocolate and wildberry lavender Everything have their own favor Love it

One of my fav ice cream spots in Columbus!! A lot of people complain about it being too expensive and small portions but I think the portions are perfect! You get what you want without leaving grossly full. The flavors always hit!! Gooey butter cake is my personal fav

Jeni's is the best I've cream I've had in the Columbus area. While you can sometimes find their pints of Wildberry Crisp and other flavors and local groceries, this Short North location is not to be missed for their delightful waffle cones that you can smell all the way down high street! I recommend their more experimental flavors - cherry and cheese was incredible - as well as their vegan options which were wonderfully inclusive for my food allergic friends.