Sunil A.
Yelp
There are times you read about some of the attention seeking behavior that restaurants go through to get people in and then you take a bite of their food and you know that it is all fluff and no substance. The food comes out flavorless, there is no attention to detail, the service mediocre at best and when you get the bill you wonder what the hell you just spent $300 on.
I am happy to say this is not one of those situations. I'm not going to lie, when I first heard you have to text a phone number to make a reservation and then on the day of your meal they will send you a secret code word and then you go to a secret door, my eyes rolled so hard and so fast it looked like I was doing a Marty Feldman impression. There is no way anything can be worth all this hassle, right???? WRONG!!! It was worth every bit of it and in fact only added to the experience further. I think I'm going to write this review in sequential order to capture a moment by moment experience.
I'm not going to give away the location of the door because I think enjoying the full process of discovering it is part of the fun. Once you give the secret word (for you Always Sunny fans, it's not, I repeat it's not OOOOOORRRRRGGGGGYYYY) you going down stairs, through the basement kitchen/storage area and through a disguised entrance that leads into the restaurant. Once again I'm not going to give away too many details on the entry process to keep the mystique alive even if it is temporary.
Upon entering the restaurant, you're immediately greeted by (a photo) of Miles Davis and it's the perfect first impression for the secret, jazzy feel to the place. A combination of edison bulbs and candles keep the the rooms softly lit but still dark, guests at distant tables were nothing more than moving shadows, at closer tables ghostly visages laughing and drinking and eating. Aesthetically, it is an absolute feast for the eyes. Dark woods, classic furniture, stone walls left exposed add to the mysterious feel.
We decided to sit at the high top so we could have better view of the restaurant and the bar area. The drinks we ordered were nothing short of spectacular. They looked beautiful, tasted amazing, and actually had enough alcohol in it so you could feel it. Watching the bartender make our drinks was a great show. We decided to order a bunch of dishes and share them among us, like a family style dinner.
We started with the Lump Crab Napolean. I find working with seafood is always a tricky experience, especially lobster, crab, scallops etc. I like a little char to it because texture is big thing in my world in dealing with food. Although the lobster was charred by any means, the combination of the avocado, lobster, and the vinaigrette gave the dish a great texture and flavor.
Next on the list was the Lobster Mac and coming from a person who does not especially like mac of any kind, this was delicious. It was creamy, and the bisque sauce took the flavors to all different levels. It was so well balanced between creamy and dense that it perfectly satisfying on many levels.
I couldn't imagine that being topped and then the peanut encrusted lamb chops with miso sake souffle just came in yelled "G5!" and the Lobster Mac responded with a sad, "you sunk my battleship." This was my favorite dish of the night without question. Perfectly cooked and the peanut crust was a combination I would never have thought would be good together but damn, brilliant! The real joy though was the souffle. I'm not sure what miso sake is, I don't know if I will ever run into it again, but wow. Just wow. So light, fluffy and yummy! It was like a little dessert to cleanse the palate before the next dish.
The encrusted beef medallion was next and I honestly wish we had ordered this before the lamb. I know this was delicious but following the lamb, this had no chance and this is an absolutely a travesty because it is such a good dish. I'm telling you, you won't be disappointed if you order this.
Finally for dessert, we had the blueberry creme brulee. Now I'm going to be frank with you, I might not be a connoisseur of many things in life, but creme brulee's is something I could probably get a doctorate in. This one was so well made and the blueberries was such a nice touch. From the minute my spoon cracked that perfectly caramelized shell to every heavenly bite, I was actually angry I was forced to share this with someone else. I will have to sneak back here and have it again all to myself... bwhaahahahhahahahahhaa (evil laughter and twirling of mustache ensues at this point of the story).
I can't recommend this experience enough and I can only hope they change their menu regularly so I can have an entirely new experience.