Vanessa H.
Yelp
Great pizza joint! I was visiting the Brooklyn Bridge with family at around 7 ish pm on the eve of New Year's Eve, so I was expecting a crowd, but not a ginormous one. The line was outside which seemed long, but the turnaround time for these tables is genuinely so fast that we got inside in around 20 minutes. The restaurant is small, tightly packed, and dimly lit, and the large pizza oven where the prepare the pizzas are at the back of the establishment, on full display. One thing that was kinda weird though was that if you had to use the restaurant, you had to walk through the pizza-making area and squeeze right past the chefs who are rolling out your pizza dough. Maybe a little unsanitary I suppose? But I guess it's efficient use of the space.
We ordered the arugula salad, the margarita pizza with added pepperoni, and the specialty No. 4. The salad came out so fast, like literal lightning speed, and so did the pizzas shortly after. We got both larges for each pizza, which looked daunting at first, but it was so light and thin that the 4 of us chowed down most of it.
The salad was fresh and had a nice lemony dressing. Pretty good salad. The margarita pizza was so good. The dough was thin and crunchy with those little burnt black spots at the bottom - true coal-fired pizza. The mozzarella cheese was SO flavorful, definitely my favorite part of the pizza. However, I didn't really enjoy the sauce: I thought the sauce was quite sour and I feel like there was too little of it. There were some parts of the pizza that were completely void of sauce. The pepperonis were fine, a bit thicker and chewier than what I prefer. The No.4 had tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, prosciutto, and arugula on top. It was also pretty good, however the arugula's bitterness overpowers all of the other lighter flavors on the pizza. Maybe if there was less arugula or some kind of balsamic glaze, it would be better? Still tasty though.
Another downside is that the AC fans blow directly onto the middle tables (where we were sitting) which makes the pizza get cold so fast. After I ate one pizza slice, my second slice was already cold (and I'm a fast eater.) Maybe this is their strategy to get people to leave faster... who knows! Anyways, this was a great meal and you should stop by if you're around the area!