Victoria S.
Yelp
I don't remember how I happened upon this place; whether it was scrolling on Instagram, or by perusing through recommendations on TableCheck/Omakase? All I know is, members of our party had wanted to try an omakase experience, and we had agreed to do one fancy one and one cheaper one (don't knock Mantensushi; they were awesome for the price).
I don't know why Kagurazaka Sushi Rin doesn't have a Michelin Star, because it absolutely should.
The restaurant is nestled in a neighborhood in Shinjuku and can be easily missed because their signage is very simple and plain. We went up to the second floor and were greeted by the host, who took our jackets and hung them in the closet, and escorted us to our seats. We chose bar seating so that we could get the full experience, and it was nothing short of amazing.
We started with grilled clam and a tiny tasting of clam soup. This may sound ridiculous, but that tiny shot of clam soup blew us out of the water, and was easily one of our favorites of the night. We then moved on and were able to try different cuts of Tuna, some nigiri rolls, uni, octopus, yellowtail, ikura, shrimp, squid, mackerel, swordfish, and surf clam.
The presentation and skill in which our courses were served to us was intimate, delicate, and supremely delicious. Our sushi chef was personable, attempted to teach us Japanese (we tried our best), and laughed as we "Ooh"d and "Ahhh"d after every bite.
When we left, he came down with us, escorted us out, gave us his business card, and told us to visit him again soon. My descriptions won't give this place the justice is deserves. Look at the photos, and add this place onto your itinerary! It's a must try. And they need a Michelin Star!