Key Lime Pie Bakery

Key Lime Pie Bakery in Key West is a great stop for anyone wanting to try the city’s signature dessert. The pies are creamy, tangy, and have that perfect balance of sweetness with the tart lime flavor. They also offer other treats and products to take home, making it a nice spot for both tasting and shopping. The atmosphere is casual, and the staff is friendly, which adds to the experience. Definitely worth a visit if you’re exploring Key West and want to enjoy an authentic slice of key lime pie.

We ordered a key lime pie so everyone in our group could try it. The cashiers we're very nice to give us small plates, napkins, and forks. We sat in the store and ate our pie in a cool environment. Key Lime pie isn't for everyone. Its tart and rich and the "lime" comes through. Many of us enjoyed a slice and others tried a bite and that's all they could do. To each his own. This small bakery also has a small attached gift shop with many great options.

Super cute spot. You can see them baking their own key lime pies which is pretty cool. Their key lime pie is tart, seems more "lime-ee" than the others I tried so if you prefer tartness, this is your place. Their coconut key lime pie was soooo good! Recommend it.

Is this the original? There's some debate. But! It is fantastic. I loved their coconut key lime pie. I will be craving it for years to come. The shop offers all kinds of key lime treats if pie isn’t your thing. I wish there was more seating, but hey, that's a really small complaint.

I had high expectations for this iconic Key West spot, especially for my first Key Lime Pie experience. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to the hype. The Key Lime Pie was nothing special—I was expecting something fresher and more vibrant. The Coconut Cream Pie was even more disappointing. It was mostly whipped cream, with only a sprinkle of coconut on top. Honestly, I could’ve found a similar slice at a grocery store for half the price. Overall, the food just didn’t deliver. I was hoping for something memorable, but it fell short.

Staff was friendly and hospitable. Cookies were good, tart and not too sweet how I like it. Lemonade was too sweet and very tart. I mixed it with water and ice and was able to double my portion at a sweetness level that was more tolerable.

Key Lime pie...ehh ok...Mattheessen's blows this place apart... Coffee at 9am had to be made..none "ready"...not tasty... Over $7...bad.. Some cute trinkets..marked $5.95 charged $6.19 plus tax for a magnet... Def tourist trap...no thanks..🐓 Cute building, woman was nice.

Stacks of precut pie in plastic containers does not make for a memorable experience. Pie was not as fresh as it could have been and whipped cream had dried. For the price they charge and their reputation it was very disappointing.

Let me start by saying the person that helped us was the absolute sweetest. While looking for another Key Lim in spot we stumbled up this one and so glad we did. All pies are made fresh in-house and we're delicious. We chose traditional and it was the best. The consistency and flavor was spot on. Not only did they have great pie, the store was full of delicious key limenpie treats. Brought home some cookies and now I wish I had brought more. If you only try one place, skip the bigger shops and support this small business.

Delicious! They claim this is where the first key lime pie was made, and literally everything in the store is made with key limes. You can even buy the juice with a recipe on it, to make it at home yourself. My friend is eating the chocolate covered version and isn't sharing, so it must be pretty darn good. Mine was gone before I blinked! It's a slice of rich, creamy piece of heaven.

I enjoyed this hidden gem just a few blocks from the cruise port. The space is small, featuring a few two-person tables, a gift shop, and a selection of sweets. The key lime pie and coconut cream pie were incredibly satisfying--rich, flavorful, and delicious. Plus, the individual packaging makes them easy to take on the go (especially given the limited seating options). The prices are a bit high, but that's expected in a touristy area. However, the woman working there was very friendly and welcoming.

The Bakery is cute with bright lemon lime colors. The reason for 4 stars the pie , it was so sour had really strong taste of lime extract. Others than that the Bakery is cute and I liked all the things they had inside for sale .

Definitely a must stop place if you're visiting Key West. The original spot was cute inside with tons of Key lime items from cookies to Tea. The key lime pie it self was amazing ! 10/10

Nice little shop, very well kept. Very friendly. Key lime cheesecake was excellent. Coconut cream pie was good, could've been a tad sweeter. We will return thank you

It's all about Key Lime! Though we have tried the Key Lime pie from Miami, someone suggested that this place sells the best Key Lime Pie in Key West! Boy! That's right. The best key lime pie! Creamy, soft crust and perfect citrus flavor! Along with the original Key lime pie, they serve a variety of key lime pies as well. We loved the coconut one! Cute little bakery. Always busy. But the service is great. They've got couple of tables outside. It's so lovely to sit, enjoy the pie on a sunny day!

Personal opinion, this is better than Kermit's! Had both, this one just tasted better. Got the coconut key lime pie at both (I'd eat either one and be fine), this one had a thicker crust and was more crunchy. Wish I took pictures but I ate it to fast

Waited 21 years to taste this again. Nothing better the a frozen Key lime dipped in chocolate. Most likely the best in town.

This was my fave key lime pie in Key West. Just the right amount of sweet. Wasn't too rich and heavy. The staff is nice. Tons of stuff to look at and buy in the shop.

If you're a tourist and love key lime pie; this is your place! Everything is key lime! Super cute shop, they offer coffee also. The key lime pie was delicious and the coconut key lime pie was just as delicious. The key lime taffy was a tasty surprise as well. The lady working here was so sweet. Again if you like key lime pie come here!

The best Key Lime Cheesecake exists here!!! This is such a cute little establishment with some yummy treats. There are a few tables set up inside and there are benches outside. The gift shop has a lot of cute souvenirs and prices are reasonable. The employee was also super friendly to us while we were there. Check this place out!

Besssst key lime pie. We tried a few and nothing beats this one! Come and try it, you won't be disappointed.

Customer service was great, the gift shop has something for everyone. The desserts are endless to try. The key lime pie was perfect! Most are extremely tart, this was perfect! The bread is AMAZING! I wanted to try and make a key lime Pie myself and I grabbed a bottle of the juice!

Yes!!! The original Keylime pie is delicious. Not too sweet - not too sour. just right !! must come here to have a piece!!! The inside is nothing to write home about just simple and the service was nice.

This is apparently "the original" Key Lime Pie shop, but it is very unassuming. There was one employee working here when I visited. Their website and Facebook page don't even mention that it is "the original" so I still am skeptical. The shop itself is quite cute. There are so many candies, sauces, books, clothing items, etc. dedicated to Key Lime Pie now... and you can buy plenty of these items in this store. I did have a slice and it was very tart! But you gotta try it...

Really good key lime pie. Must stop and try some. The staff were polite and helpful. ...............................

Our second favorite pie in the area! While it came frozen, it was quite refreshing this way and not too sweet. The mango key lime pie tasted strongly of real mango and not much like key lime. The extra tart key lime pie was the perfect sweetness and tartness!!! Would generally like some more crust though. There was tons of seating inside with ac - also a nice view to watch them make pies.

This Key Line Pie was nothing special and pie crust is not home made. I actually doubt the pie is home made. Save your $26 and get a Marie Calendars key lime pie. The Marie Calendars Key lime pie taste so much better. We walked yo this place and thought we were in for a treat but it basically sucked. Really if you see a good review it must be someone that doesn't know what a good key lime pie taste like. Maybe this is the original factory...... if so it's the building only. There is no way the pie they serve would ever get a place in the hearts of Floridians.

Delicious pie, as we expected! We did notice that a lot of the bagged key lime treats were not made in Florida. That was a little disappointing. (Hence, the 4 stars instead of 5)

There was several dishes I would choose from again. I highly recommend the chocolate covered pie.

Visited this bakery on 5/1/2025 after arriving via Virgin Voyages Cruise Ship. Walked around inside the store to look for souvenirs to take back home with me. I noticed the store had ice cream. My favorite flavor is mint chocolate chip. The lady asked me what I would like and I asked for a cup of mint chocolate chip ice cream. The ice cream in the container was green; however, what I was given was vanilla with chocolate. I tasted it and realized it wasn't mint chocolate chip. I brought the error to her attention and she asked me why did I eat it. I said "how would I know what I was eating if I hadn't taken a spoonful"? She had a very nasty tone with me and took back what she gave me and said "you asked for chocolate chip". I reminded her that I asked for mint chocolate chip. She said, "that is what I gave you". I said "it is not green". She said "Oh, that is chocolate chip". I said "that is not what I asked for and furthermore, you don't have chocolate chip ice cream in the store". She yelled at me and asked "what do you want?". I said "I want my money back because I don't like your attitude or your customer service". She said "you want you money back?" I said "yes". She gave me my money back and then realized her mistake and said "my bad". I said "you have a bad attitude and you are are very rude. You shouldn't talk to your customers in that tone". I was very disappointed with the customer service at the Key Lime Pie Bakery.

Went to Key West for the first time and knew I had to get a Key lime pie. First of all the store/bakery was very nice and had good vibes. Second of all the Key lime pie was amazing at a 9.5/10 it had great flavor and was delicious. Overall the food, shop, and service was very good.

Service was great! The key lime pie and chocolate dipped one that was frozen on a stick were excellent. Best place to get great key lime pie in Key West.

Absolutely amazing pies and treats at a reasonable price. And Meika, the sweet lady who works the counter, only adds to the ambiance Highly recommended!

First stop on the great KLP quest 8/10 for great balance of tart and sweet Me personally wished Crist was thicker but understand it would take away from the pie flavor Also had the KL- coconut and also 8/10..a great flavor combo. I love coconut.

What to do when in key west? Try their amazing key lime pie. The pie was amazing!! Definitely worth the $7-8 dollars a slice. In the store they have other souvenirs and snacks that one can buy. The service was very fast. The owner was very kind and helpful. We decided to sit in the shop to eat our key lime and it was really relaxing. Absolutely loved the shop and the experience.

This sad little place is 95% grocery/souvenir shop. There is a counter at the back where they keep a few pieces of pie and a couple of tiny tables where you can sit if you choose to try one. After a quick look around, our choice was to move on to the Key West Key Lime Pie Company. It's a few blocks walk, and we didn't regret that decision for a second.

Cute gift shop and delicious, authentic key lime pie. Tried a traditional slice and a chocolate dipped slice. Of all the checklist items when visiting key west, a slice of real key lime pie from this bakery should be at the top of the list. You can find it everywhere, but it is not all the same. Great, friendly staff also.

We love this place! We got the key lime and the coconut cream pie! Both were yummy! The cashier rang up only one slice of the coconut cream after I asked for two. I told her it's ok she didn't have to make the correction. While heading out the store she came after me and gave me another slice for free and said "Merry Christmas!" It was a really nice gesture and much appreciated! I highly recommend this place!

We decided we want to try out all the Keylime places in Key West. We enjoyed all of them! I believe this is the first place we went and ate ice cream. I think it was the best place of them all.

Free tasting of cookies, fast service, seating indoors and outside!Knowledgeable hosts with ready smiles!

We decided to eat key lime pie at this place. It was super delicious. Service was quick.

While in Key West, you must eat Key Lime pie! This place is the place to get a slice. My brother in law and sister in law went in to grab a few slices to-go. We took them back to our hotel room for a late night yummy dessert. The pie itself was tart and creamy, just as it should be. The crust was firm and delicious. The reason I gave them 4 stars instead of 5 is because there was whipped cream on the pie not merengue. Other than that, great dessert!

Service excellent Best of the three places we tried On business in the keys but this place made it more vacay style. Adorable decor

This bakery serves amazing Keylime pie. They have a good selection of desserts, but the Keylime pie is is the primary dessert. The customer service is very good. if you enjoy Keylime pie or would like to try Keylime pie, this is a great option.

YUM! So fresh and tasty. Whipped cream was definitely homemade or at least not the gross fake stuff that you get at other places. Could really taste the key lime.

We just got out of there and the lady there was the rudest. We got multiple things including coffee. One of the people that got coffee took 2 mins to decide if he wanted sugar and she got mad... she took the whole pie we bought and put it on the shelf and threw the bag on top of it; it was a wrinkled bag that looked like she took it out of the trash. We asked if everything was okay and she ignored us... this is terrible customer service

The lady at the counter was very unfriendly and started serving the person after because "we were not ready". The key lime pies tasted frozen inside. Too bad.

The shop and the lady working the register left much to be desired. Took a couple of times for her to take off the $1 for the Yelp check in despite saying she did but giving me a total for the Renault price. It was smaller than I expected and already pre packaged in the freezer (I was expecting the chocolate slice to be dipped on demand). However once I tried it, it was really good and I would definitely go back for another

We went in trying to get the typical required tourist, authentic Key lime pie slice, but also got the ice cream because we read a lot of good reviews on it. We got two scoops in a waffle cone which completely filled it. She put Key lime flavor in the bottom and coconut on top. The ice cream was very smooth and delicious. The coconut was light and fluffy and had pieces of coconut throughout. It was almost as if we had a Key lime pie with coconut whip cream on top in a cone. We shared the ice cream, and we're both too full to really eat any pie, but we did try a taste of the plain Key lime as well as the coconut Key lime. It looks as if the coconut Key lime is just Key lime pie with coconut shavings on top, but it's half coconut cream and half Key lime. Both were absolutely amazing in their own right that we bought an extra slice of each to take back with us. There are two small tables, and maybe six chairs total to eat if you didn't want to take it on a walk with you. There are benches out front as well. They have a lot of touristy, Keylime treats and things for sale, as well as a store with more things to buy and a windowed area where probably see them making the pies fresh during the day.

I enjoyed the Keylime pie. The pie on a stick is difficult to eat. But would be very good if you like chocolate after about 15 minutes on the beach. Cute courtyard to eat in.

Very simple and effective. If you're looking for fresh key lime pie this bakery fits the bill to the letter. Absolutely delicious served cold which is a nice touch. As far as coffee goes they only have whole milk which was disappointing. Overall great location.

Best Pie on the island by far!!! It actually tastes like lime and not just a bunch of sugar with Ghraham crackers. 10/10

The key lime pie tasted perfect!!! Sweet and sour flavors are balanced. It is interesting that it tastes slightly different from some restaurants. Strongly recommend this place if you'd like to try authentic key lime pie.

They advertise 11 but they close usually by 9:30 and the owner is really rude about it.

Great service and the key like pie was amazing! Did not have to wait too long and the price fits the what we got for the pie.

I love the workers that were here the day I went so nice and welcoming, but the things in the shop were so cute and adorable. Definitely want to come back if I make a trip again.

Stunned to enjoy a perfect slice of original Key Lime pie. Excellent flavor balance! Also re-energized by a yummy shot of Cuban coffee. Nice and clean seating area with lite music playing. Ted and Vitali gave excellent attentive service. Do yourself a favor and enjoy a slice before you jump back on the boat (cruise ship)!