1

Key Lime Pie Bakery

Pie shop · Key West ·

Key Lime Pie Bakery

Pie shop · Key West ·
@infatuation
132,814 Postcards · 3,234 Cities

Miami’s Best New Desserts Of 2024 - Miami - The Infatuation

"You’re ordering this key lime pie for the same reason you take a picture with a baby alligator in the Everglades: to channel your inner Florida Man. This pie has the right amount of tartness thanks to freshly squeezed key lime juice. The graham cracker crust cuts like soft cheese. It’s the quintessential Florida dessert we crave at a quintessential Florida waterfront bar. Gramps Getaway can get slammed on the weekends. The nicer the weather is, the more crowded it’ll be. But most people don’t know that you can make reservations here. So book one and walk right past the poor souls waiting at the host stand." - virginia otazo, mariana trabanino, ryan pfeffer

https://www.theinfatuation.com/miami/guides/best-new-desserts-miami-2024

Information

Fresh-baked Key Lime pies, whole & by the slice, souvenirs

key lime pie
key lime
gift shop
coconut key lime pie
friendly staff
cute shop
ice cream
chocolate dipped
Google Rating
4.4 (2.5K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in

412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040 Get directions

$1–10

Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Paid street parking
Free Wi-Fi
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
See full details

1

Information

Fresh-baked Key Lime pies, whole & by the slice, souvenirs

key lime pie
key lime
gift shop
coconut key lime pie
friendly staff
cute shop
ice cream
chocolate dipped
Google Rating
4.4 (2.5K)
Yelp Rating
4.1
Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in

412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040 Get directions

$1–10

Credit card accepted
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Paid street parking
Free Wi-Fi
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
Key Lime Pie Bakery by null
See full details

More Places For You

Cuban Coffee Queen Waterfront

Coffee shop · Key West

Lively counter-serve coffee stand offers traditional Cuban eats

5 Postcards

Winslow's Bungalows - Key West Historic Inns

Hotel · Key West

Retro-chic decor, historic homes, multiple pools, poolside breakfast

9 Postcards

The Gardens Hotel

Hotel · Key West

Tropical oasis with lush gardens, koi ponds, and tortoises

1 Postcard

Sunset Pier

Seafood restaurant · Key West

Dockside seafood eatery with water views, drinks & live music

6 Postcards

Southernmost Beach Resort

Resort hotel · Key West

Oceanfront rooms, pools, private beach, bars, lawn games

6 Postcards

Sunset Key Cottages

Resort hotel · Key West

Private island cottages with ocean views, spa, gym, and dining

4 Postcards

Yankee Freedom Dry Tortugas Ferry

Boat tour agency · Key West

Ferry to Dry Tortugas National Park, includes breakfast & lunch

4 Postcards

KINO Sandals

Shoe store · Key West

Handmade leather sandals, bags, and jewelry since 1966

2 Postcards

Blue Heaven

American restaurant · Key West

Iconic Floridian-Caribbean cuisine & key lime pie, funky setting

19 Postcards

Thirsty Mermaid

Seafood restaurant · Key West

Locally sourced seafood, raw bar, craft beers & wine

2 Postcards