Keys Fisheries

I've come here since 2009, and this is one of my favorites seafood restaurants in Marathon. I was disappointed with the foods. Went here for stone crab but it wasn't in season. So sad. Cashier seem like brand new, slow and weak. The conch chowder was fishy. I didn't like it. Boneless chicken wing also not good. Skinny fried calamari. The oyster crackers were chewy and smelly. This place was at the top of my list but I'm not going back. Price and quality left me disappointed.

We stopped at Keys Fisheries on our way to Key West after seeing it recommended in several videos and I was excited to try the famous lobster Reuben. My girlfriend and I both ordered it, and while the lobster itself was really tasty, the sauerkraut (or whatever it was inside) just had a flavor that neither of us really enjoyed. That said, the calamari rings we had beforehand were absolutely delicious, and the setting was awesome — we sat right by the water with tarpon jumping out and even some nurse sharks resting in the shade. Overall it was a really cool experience, even if the Reuben wasn’t my personal favorite.

The setting had potential, but overall, the experience felt a bit too touristy for my taste. The tacos were underseasoned, and the place was quite crowded, making it hard to find a good seat with a view of the water. While the cocktails were visually appealing, the taste didn’t quite match the presentation. Even when we did manage to get a table by the water, the view was mostly obstructed by docked boats — not quite the scenic vibe we were hoping for. That said, we did enjoy spotting ducks and fish near the water, which added a nice touch to the atmosphere.

It’s the coolest thing when you just drove, then turned right and found yourself in a very simple but very tasty place 👌❤️ $35 paella with whole lobster, mussels and the freshest scalops! That’s cool!

We tried Keys Fisheries for the first time this year and we loved it! The food was amazing and the staff were super friendly. I highly recommend that you plan to stop by for dinner. It’s right on the water and next to a fleet of beautiful charter boats. The boat docking area is full of huge tarpon and nurse sharks which the kids enjoy. Prices are very fair and the portions are huge! Also, possibly the best key lime pie in the whole Fl Keys.

Went with my family and two dogs. Place is dog friendly and kid friendly. My family had the crab &spinach dip, fried calamari, tuna, Poké bowl, lobster bisque, chicken sandwich, grouper Reuben, and hogfish francaise Food was delish and the fries were perfect cut and crunch. Only wish we had more crab and spinach dip since the chip to dip ratio was wayyy big Sodas were refillable One single stall bathroom on site though and another in the parking lot. Went around 4pm on Monday and not too busy

Great place to stop for a bite to eat on your way to or from Key West. Conch fritters and veggies were delicious! Cute atmosphere overlooking the marina watching the tarpons and nurse sharks as well as all the seabirds. The staff was amazing and the bar inside a great place to get a cold beer or drink

We learned about this place from our self guided audio tour. Made a stop for lunch and did not regret it. I have to say, these people know a secret to great french fries and just enough batter that it doesn’t overwhelm the fish fingers. Generous portions and nice outdoor seating.

Came around five years ago and I couldn't wait to come back (all the way from France!). Food? Perfect, full stop. Drinks? All you need including some stuff I didn't even know existed. Staff? Friendly, efficient. Place? Low key but authentic atmosphere, surrounded by sharks, fish and even manatees at times. Please drive by, so I don't have to queue for too long. Amazing place, I love it so much.

Unfortunately this was the worst first meal I could imagine having in the Florida Keys. I gave them 2 stars instead of 1 because the conch fritters were decent and the sauce was really good. Entrees: atrocious! I got the crab roll (which I asked about before ordering, and was told it was crab salad on a sandwich like a lobster roll, which they are currently not serving.) As soon as the tray hit the table I was like... wait. Is this imitation Krab? At a fishery? In the keys? One, that should be illegal. (Don't recommend watching the "how it's made" episode on imitation krab lol, I don't even like it in sushi- where it's expected.) Two, if they would have just written "Krab roll" on the menu I would have known and not ordered it, which makes me feel like they're being sneaky about it on purpose. When I went back to the window to exchange it for something else I was first told it was in fact crab until I pressed the issue. I asked if the crab cake sandwich was actually crab and was told they had to check! I just think that's crazy. Crab cake sandwich was fine/mid. Can get equivalent or better at my regular restaurants at home. Next, my fiance got the hog fish sandwich and it was all I could smell as soon as the tray hit the table- so beyond fishy it was gagging me. He is a big fish person and orders fish everywhere, and said he would be shocked if it wasn't previously frozen. He said he could have just gotten a mcFish at the drive through for that experience lol. Anyways, as we looked around the dock where we were seated and saw people feeding sharks, and the attached seafood market we had to share a good laugh at the alternate universe experience we were having! I'm sure their fried shrimp or whatever is fine (hard to mess that up!) but based on what we got I would not recommend stopping here especially if you're visiting and want to taste a good example of fresh seafood. Sorry :/

Went here based on Marathon happenings members recommendations. The line was long and not worth the wait. Was hoping we could have dinner and enjoy the view from the upstairs bar but we had our 2 teenage boys. Only 21 and up can go upstairs. We ordered The conch salad had the smallest bits of conch and all greens. Bland The fried seafood platter was disappointing too. skinny fried calamari, fish sticks and shrimp. The conch fritter was over cooked., almost burnt. It might have been a bad day in the kitchen as I was expecting better based on rave reviews. The only positive was the view.

A great view of a sunset, we came here on a Friday night. We ordered food downstairs at the window and brought it to the upper deck. We ordered 1 Broiled Lobsters with vegetables and rice. At the bar, they had half bottles and we got a half bottle for $14 of the Kendall Jackson Chardonnay. It was neat because at sunset, they hand out "Sunset Shots". Sweet and delicious, it was a cool experience. The Lobster was a tad overcooked but the broccoli was good. Paired with some rice and a little butter, it was decent. Wouldn't say that the service was super friendly but it's a cool experience and a great sunset view.

Our first time in the Keys and this place was highly reviewed so we tried it out. Unassuming dockside location, plenty of easy parking and delicious fresh mixed seafood platter. Not fond of the lobster bisque, but loved the lobster tail, shrimp and mahi. Will go back next time we visit!

This place was at the top of my list while visiting Marathon, but it missed the mark. I had one more food stop planned, but after this experience, I'm done until next time. The conch po' boy was extremely overcooked, hard, dry, and unpleasant to eat. The bread was just as tough. The remoulade looked great but did not help. The smashed potatoes tasted like a mix of instant and real, and the texture was off. Two stars only because the seating and view was nice and the staff were very pleasant. The food was a major letdown.

Came because of sign saying they had best lobster Reuben but it's not lobster season.. lol oh well they had pretty big menu so hubby tried few things.. grouper Reuben was very good as was the plantains! We had few meals here as the food was good and price was reasonable. The staff was very nice and helpful. The place itself is not fancy it's very laid back.. tables are picnic tables all around the dock on the waterfront.. you can see and feed tarpon but not people food they have feeders you can get food from for 25 cent. There's other fish too that eat the feed so cool experience.. they do sell out of stuff at times so best to get there early..

Go early to get a lobster roll lol. I got grilled Mahi tacos and lobster chowder. My Wife got shrimp ceviche, it was a small serving but she brought it home for a snack later. She also got the mago shrimp bowl. It was like a sweet and spicy mix but delicious. It was a good saving that she was only able to eat half or it. We got there about 730pm and ther was plenty of seating. Dog friendly as well. A must stop in Marathon.

The service started off on weak footing when as I was talking to my wife, and the server shouts to me "I can't hear you". She apparently thought I was talking to her when I was having a conversation with my wife. I played it off. We ordered a bunch of food and was really disappointed to see the conk ceviche come in a pre wrapped sealed plastic container like you'd get from Costco. This is supposed to be the fish market that delivers to all the other local "fish markets". We accidentally dropped it on the floor and the staff was very nice about it and replaced it. The conch fritters were mostly air and breading. I didn't taste much conch. The seafood mixed grill was ok. 7/10. The entire bill with no cocktails was $90. I left there feeling like a sucker. But good news. They charge you $17 a pound to cook any fish that you catch. Robbery.

Keys Fisheries checked all the boxes for us! Casual, relaxed atmosphere with delicious fresh food, and a price point that's easy to digest! We would return to this establishment again and again. Tip: the lobster is fresh, so when it's out, the famous lobsters dishes are unavailable for order. Suggest going when they open for lunch if having fresh FL lobster will make or break your experience.

Came back to visit a year after my initial visit and my review remains the same. Way more about atmosphere and less about the food. You stand in line to order then wait about 30-45 minutes for your food to arrive (on a slow night-- we actually went on a Monday evening). We fed the tarpon and had some drinks while we waited but the kids started to get hungry and upset. Food was nothing to write home about. The chicken on the sandwich was so thin- the onion pieces are actually bigger than the chicken (see pic). Do not order the chicken sandwich if you are hungry. Key lime pie was as expected. The crab Mac and cheese was the best part. Lots of crab and cheesy Mac. The restroom is located in the parking lot and bit sketchy with only one stall. Parking can get full on a busy night. Parking lot is gravel. The bar is at the back of the restaurant with lots of drink options and quick service. They have seating for 21+ at an upstairs area that generally has live music.

We wanted some good seafood and wanted to be out by the water. Saw this place and it fit the bill. Lots of choices - including the "world famous lobster Reuben" ... which looked interesting but we didn't order it. Instead we all got the fish tacos. They were really good. We had some grilled and some blackened. The ambiance is what you'd expect in marathon. Laid back and relaxing. You order at the counter and they call you when it's ready. Very easy.

This is now one of my favorite places in Marathon, and I'm not easy to please. Yes, you can blow a tremendous amount of money on silly things like a lobster reuben. If that's how you roll, more power to you. However, I think a place really shines with how well it does the simple things: Cold peel and eat shrimp Conch fritters Stone crab claws with mustard sauce Key lime pie The stone crab claws will set you back a pretty penny. But the insider tip is to order them at the upstairs bar where they are cheaper for some mysterious reason. The ambiance is rustic, outdoor, picnic table, marina dining. There's a downstairs bar as well, if you are visiting with minors who aren't allowed upstairs and you want a cold local beer or some kind of fruity cocktail. You want frills? Go someplace else. You want delicious fresh seafood and a delightful (if not the absolute best, a close second) slice of key lime pie, go to Keys Fisheries. Next time I'm in town, it might be hard to get me to eat anyplace else. One last thing. There are dispensers of fish food scattered around the dining area where you can get a small handful of pellets for a quarter. On one visit, the feeding frenzy attracted a couple of curious nurse sharks! So you can get some pretty nifty critter sightings too.

We ordered drinks, fish dip, and the tuna nachos upstairs at the bar and they were all fabulous. We then ordered downstairs and ate upstairs. The hogfish sandwich is the best sandwich we've had this trip. The tuna nachos were recommended by the bartender and they had fresh tuna, fried wonton chips, and a fresh seaweed salad on top. Nice view upstairs. Key lime pie purchased from the downstairs bar was terrible.

What a f**king joke. You stand in a long, hot line only to get to the window and have them tell they don't have half the f**king menu. They don't bother to put a sign out that lists what they DON'T have. Lazy and absolutely uninterested in customer service.

Staying on Duck Key and decided to take the ride based on the popular reviews, they were not wrong!!! Family of 7, everyone loved their food, including the baby! Very mom & pop type of joint, order at a window and serve yourself sauces and drinks... there is a bartender for alcohol! The food was straight forward and delicious!! Grouper Rueben was a fam fav! Can't wait to come back on our next visit! Ignore the terrible photos, everyone was ready to jump in!

Ordered fresh seafood to cook at home. Key west pinks were fresh and huge. Snapper was fresh and flakey. We definitely loved their options and staff were friendly and helpful! Would highly recommend if you need seafood to go

We have been putting people on to this place for the last 24 years. Every time we come to keys, we make it a point to stop here. The fried grouper sandwich and lobster ruben are my favorites. The grouper is huge and fried in a light panko. The lobster ruben always hits. We have seen it change over the years. Different bread. More or less meat. This time around it was fire. So much meat! Ty lol. All of the soups are delicious. We usually dip the lobster ruben in the soup. I hope you add this place to your stop!

Line was long, worth the wait! Delicious seafood and so fresh!! Snapper and Grouper

Fast service. Good prices. Nice staff. We did a large to go order and it was ready by the time we arrived

Awesome seafood place off the beaten path. You know it's good when you arrive there is a little bit of a line, and while in line it grows behind you. We ordered the famous Reuben lobster sandwich $26.95, conch fritters $12.95, spicy tuna roll, and a drink. The rubber lobster was great. The conch fritters are worth a try, crunchy on outside and a moist on the inside. The tuna roll was about the freshest tune we have had in awhile. Definitely worth a stop in. They also have chicken fingers if you have someone who does like or is allergic to fish. Had to do a lap to find parking. Lady at counter was nice and helped us with our order. My wife really wanted a tuna poke bowl, but apparently they were out. You get free drink refills, you will need them if it is hot. We sat around back at a picnic table on thr dock and watched tarpon, nurse sharks, and other fish swim by. Great old Florida place and style.

The greatest key lime pie. My sis and I enjoyed it so much, we bought another slice! We also had some french fries, and they were great as well! Loved the sunset view here over the water. Gorgeous unobstructed view for it! plenty of parking. Pro tip: bring and wear insect repellent if you plan to watch sunset by the water. The mosquitoes are savage in the keys!!

After hearing great things about the local stone crab in Florida, I was so excited to finally try them freshly caught! For $39.95, we received 7 pieces of select claws, all cracked, chilled, and ready to be eaten with mustard sauce. Unfortunately, we found the stone crab meat to be tough and flavorless. Not sure if this was a bad batch or if stone crab meat is just too hyped up.  Note that there is no table service - just order at the window, pick up your tray of food, and find your own seating. My favorite things here were the Smashed Potatoes, laidback vibes, and views of the harbor :)

This was a great experience. It was on the docks so we saw pelicans, manatees and fish. You stand in line to order then go to a table to eat your food. We had stone crab, spiny lobster, fresh tuna, yellowtail, and shrimp mango bowl - all were fresh and excellent. The staff were friendly and incredibly efficient. Got to see the sun set from here too. Great experience.

my family tried the place last night. food was good. the place got some good views. staff were friendly. will recommend the place for a family. you can feed the fish when your done eating or while waiting for the food.

We went at lunchtime on a hot winter day just for drinks. We walked straight upstairs in the tiki hut and had plenty of seats at the bar to choose from. Drinks are really affordable and delicious. Despite it being unseasonably hot, it was cool and breezy. The views can't be beat. Tip your bartender well!

This is a great place to come to when in Marathon! Fresh fish, yummy conch and good drinks. There's a window that you order through and then they call your order for pickup when it's ready. Then you can take it up to the tiki bar upstairs or grab a picnic style table and eat there. We ordered conch fritters, conch ceviche, tuna poke bowl, spicy tuna roll, and lobster Mac and cheese. The tuna was fantastic. So fresh and buttery, amazing. The conch was ok, lobster Mac and cheese was yummy. I would come back here for the tuna though because wow.

Had to edit my review from 5 to a 4. Lobster Reuben just didn't hit the same as it did a few years ago. It was kinda bland, they hardly put any dressimg on it. Also the lobster seemed to be Maine lobster vice spiny lobster.

Great spot alongside the Keys for seafood, I like the open seating with views to the water and dock, their lobster Reuben is a classic but I usually go for the catch of the day, if you're here don't forget to try their key lime pie.

Service was very pleasant, and the food delivered in a big way on Seafood . Triple Tail Taco...3 Ts...Blackened Mahi Wrap.....and the world famous Key Lime Pie Loved seeing the fish in the water while enjoying our meal...great place for kids and families.

Love this spot, great vibes for watching the sunset and enjoying some great food. The service was fast and there was live music.

Conch salad & lobster roll were amazing! The kids got chicken and fries. This place is by the water. You order at the window and find your seats. Great view to watch the fisherman's. There's indoor and outdoor seating. They have their own parking lot. We tired a lot of seafood places and this has to be my favorite. Everything was fresh & tasty!

This casual eatery is a great outdoor on the water dining experience. The vibes and quick turnaround for ordering honestly give it a couple stars. The food wasn't anything out of this world, but there were very fresh options. You can also bring your own catch and have them cook it. The mahi in the tacos were a bit dense and not really blackened or flavorful, and was quite soggy (fell apart in my hands), but the toppings really carried it home. The pina colada wasn't really frozen but the bartender was very nice and attentive to our larger group. Staff was great and friendly! Would def checkout if you want a outdoor casual fresh seafood spot that is family friendly.

I can't tell you how much I enjoyed late afternoon dining here . Just missed Stone Claw crab season . But I was looking forward to their shrimp Mac and Cheese , I have had lobster Mac and Cheese in Maine, Brats Mac and Cheese in Northern Wisconsin, brisket Mac and Cheese at more then a few bbq joints. But I really like this shrimp Mac and Cheese .

A different type of restaurant as you walk up to a take away counter to order and pay. Then go around the corner to the bar for beverages and cocktails. The tables are all right on the water under fans. Beautiful view and relaxing. You go back to counter to pick up the food. We really enjoyed this food and atmosphere.

The Best! Looks like a dump but it's straight amazing. Best food in the keys, we eat here several times each trip.

Keys fisheries is an awesome place to pick up seafood that is fresh af for you to enjoy at home in the Keys. My aunt has a house not too far from here, and every time we go down to stay we always stop by to pick up fish for the weekend. Our go to is Mahi mahi because we love to make ceviche. They also have little neck clams and shrimp that are great. I love buying from here because it's fresh. Our mahi had been filleted just moments before we purchased it and you can taste the difference when you cook it. They offer a variety of fresh fish and seasonings for them and it's very affordable. Two pounds of mahi with a aioli sauce and spice rub we picked up came out to $40. If you don't feel like cooking your seafood, you can enjoy a meal at their restaurant. With options like sandwiches, fresh catch and a famous lobster Reuben you truly cannot go wrong here. Service is friendly and there's parking in the front.

Stopped by yesterday for Conch Fritters, and they were the best I've ever ate. The fritters were definitely 5 stars, but I don't like to give 5 stars, and only trying 1 item. The fritters were packed with flavor, and the aioli was spicy. Free cups of ice water at the drink fountain around the corner.

Good was delicious. The atmosphere. Is amazing. I love being by the ocean breeze to enjoy incredible food. The lobster sandwich was phenomenal. The stone crab legs were so juicy and delicious. Would eat here more often if I could. Great service. Staff will ask you for your fav cartoon character so they know who to call when the order is ready. Very organized.

Keys Fisheries offers a laid-back, tropical atmosphere that captures the spirit of the Florida Keys. One of the most enjoyable parts of the experience is watching the charter boats come and go, with fishermen cleaning their catch right on the docks. This creates a lot of excitement and activity, and as a result, there's an abundance of sea life in the water--sharks, tarpon, and other fish are often visible, making it a fun and engaging place to hang out, especially for visitors and families. As for the food, it leans more toward basic, fried seafood fare. We tried their fried conch, which unfortunately was chewy and lacking in flavor--not quite what we were hoping for. However, the sauces served on the side were excellent and helped elevate the meal a bit. We also did a bit of a Key lime pie tour during our visit to the area, sampling pies from five different spots, and while taste is subjective, the Key lime pie at Keys Fisheries ranked lowest on our list. It lacked the balance and zing that makes a great Key lime pie memorable. Overall, if you're visiting for the views, relaxed Keys vibe, and dockside experience, Keys Fisheries delivers on atmosphere. But if you're going purely for the food, you might find better quality and flavor at other spots nearby.

Saw it on a food show and we were in the area. First and foremost, this is a seafood market with a small seafood deli for eating. We ordered the shrimp and fish baskets. Both were good and light. Limited amount of seating and you might to wait. Go after lunch time to eat and have a chance to seat at a table. Will come back to try to some other items.

Amazing food. Super laid back. Came back here twice on our trip! Tacos were good but the fried hogfish sandwich was incredible.

Best seafood restaurant!! Amazing food, service is good, and the seating on the water is so nice. Try the conch fritters and coconut shrimp appetizers, delicious! Had a mango shrimp bowl and whole fried fish-- both amazing. Must try restaurant in the keys!

The keys Fisheries has more than redeemed themselves from a prior visit. We had lobster rolls that were delicious and filled with loads of lobster. Our friends had jerk shrimp and conch fritters also delicious. Even the fries were great. Thank you KF's for the improvements.

Was driving from Key West to Miami and stopped here for dinner. Had the grouper ruben and it was delicious! Kind of a quirky thing they do is ask who your favorite cartoon character is instead of your name when they call out that your order is ready. Sitting outside must be really nice on a nice day. There is no indoor seating but just picnic tables outside. It can be really windy though. There is also a bar inside in case you're feeling a drink. They have condiments that you can choose from for your meal that is a serve it on your own. Would come back if ever around again.

Came here for dinner and the food was great. I left very full. The lobster tails were large and good. It's not lobster season so honestly not sure if they were actually fresh Florida lobster tails or just the Australian lobster tails from Costco but they tasted good and the price was somewhat reasonable at like $50 for two large tails. Key west local pink shrimp were good. The fries were ok, but the vegetables were not good, just a bunch of steamed carrots with a little bit of broccoli, I would probably pass on getting this side. Service was fine, they took our order and a then called when the food was ready like 10-15 mins later. They also dumped some of their fish trimmings into the water so we got to see some sharks come up and eat them, I think they were nurse sharks. It's a nice place with a big parking lot and lots of tables on the water to eat and enjoy a nice view. However the one thing that was extremely annoying and kept this from getting five stays was all the flies. The minute we had our food on the table, flies just kept swarming around. I wanted to enjoy my lobster and shrimp but it was hard to do so when I kept having to swat the flies away. They should set some fly traps or something because it was very annoying and ruined what could've been a really awesome meal.

No stop in Marathon is complete without a stop at keys fisheries for the sunset and some raw bar goodies . It was a chilly day so the curtains wi does were down and the crowd was light but the energy was still there ! We sampled jalapeño margarita and the crazy girl beer on draft . You have to get stone crab claws in season and today they had jumbo only , so big and sweet , one was enough along with stone crab chowder and some crab and spinach dip . All so yummy . If you want other than raw bar food you can order it downstairs and bring it up . The best is the complimentary shot and sunset toast nightly for all in the bar ! For there's no better place to be than in the keys

Delicious seafood with nice outdoor seating. The coconut shrimp were really good, a big portion and large shrimp. The fish tacos were great as well.

Best key lime pie while visiting the keys so far! We only had key lime pie and enjoyed the most beautiful sunset down by the water followed. We were also there at the right time (8:15-8:30pm) to see sharks and other big fish as the restaurant feeds the leftover fish parts to them. This is a popular spot, so expect to wait in a line to order your food.