Amy G.
Yelp
My husband and two adult children visited Kiln last night for my 50th birthday. The space is very reminiscent of Katz's Fire restaurant, although much noisier---we arrived at 8:30 pm and it wasn't until tables started emptying out around 9 that we were able to hear each other speak without raising our voices above normal conversational levels.
We tried nine savory dishes: the popovers, broccolini, chicken, chicken livers, meatballs, scalloped potatoes, pork belly, bibb salad, and croquettes. Our favorites were the potatoes, the croquettes, and the popovers (if you're a party of more than 3, note that the meatballs, popovers, and croquettes come in threes, and that due to the oozy nature of the croquettes they can be difficult to split). The chicken was moist and the beans and carrots that came with it had a great flavor. Our least favorite was the meatballs; they were hard and dry, maybe from over-processing? We loved the chicken livers at Fire, but this version was a little stingy with the cherry compote.
We ordered three desserts: the cheesecake, baked Alaska, and berries. They were fine but not outstanding; I was surprised that on the berry plate the strawberries (which have been out of season locally here for weeks) were the hard, mostly-white-inside variety that I avoid buying at the grocery store. I was a little disappointed in the presentation as well, which was pile of blueberries, pile of strawberries, pile of cream. I've had similar desserts that were styled more appealingly.
Service was spotty. After initially asking for a few minutes to peruse the drinks menu, the server disappeared for more than ten minutes and we had to wave her down to put in our order. The server was helpful when it came to deciding how many dishes to order, but forgot about our popovers until we were almost done with everything else (we had to ask her if they were coming out) . I felt badly for the couple at a neighboring table whose food order she had bungled. She was also a little slow to refill our water---the water glasses are the size of rocks glasses and so require refilling twice as often. Not a big deal if you have another beverage (the rest of us had cocktails/beer), but for my husband, who was sticking to tap water only, it meant having to ask for his glass to be refilled fairly frequently.
Upon receiving the bill we also received a little dish of tiny cookies. They're a nice touch but by that time none of us had anything left to drink with them and we kind of choked them down.