Vinny P.
Yelp
Exact rating is 4.6 stars. I stayed here for 9 days in late June. I am an IHG Club Spire Elite member, and I made my room reservation online on the hotel website. I've stayed at other Kimpton properties in the past, as well as at several other IHG hotel brands. I have, in the recent past, stayed at other IHG properties in SF.
Here are some notes regarding my stay, in no particular order:
-- WiFi is excellent, and it is free if you are an IHG club member.
-- Unlike many other Kimpton hotels, this hotel -- which admits that it entered the IHG family much later than did most other Kimpton properties, and which admits to being behind the curve in playing catch-up with IHG protocols & perks -- does NOT offer many of the perks and amenities normally offered to IHG Club Spire Elite members by other Kimpton properties; I share one example below.
-- Unlike many other Kimpton hotels, this property does NOT offer the welcome amenity of a complimentary fruit tray (delivered shortly after check-in) for IHG Club Spire Elite members, and rather, they offer that amenity and several other amenities only to Kimpton Inner Circle members, an obscure Kimpton-specfic membership level which claims to be one level above Spire Elite (I note that they are technically within their rights to decline this amenity to Spire Elite members, since the membership benefits chart on the Kimpton Hotels website does state, or implies, that this is the policy at some Kimpton hotels).
-- Unlike most other Kimpton hotels, this hotel does NOT offer those great hotel room door handle tags that read "I'll Pass! No Housekeeping Services Today", nor do they offer perks (usually a $5 to $10 credit, or equivalent reward club points, per day of service refusal) for declining to use housekeeping room service.
-- Housekeepers are very respectful of the "Do Not Disturb" door sign if you hang it on your door. Housekeepers are very helpful and very respectful in general.
-- All hotel staffers, including maintenance staff and building engineers., were uniformly friendly, competent and helpful.
-- Front desk staff are uniformly very friendly, competent and helpful, with the sole exception that they are sometimes stymied or confused in trying to render/deliver perks or benefits that are standard for IHG Spire Elite and other IHG Elite membership levels; this seems to be due to the above-mentioned fact regarding their very recent entry into the IHG family.
-- I had requested early check-in when I made the reservation. Got to hotel a bit before 2 PM, and was quickly checked in to my room.
-- Rooms, hallways and common spaces are bright, spotlessly clean and neat, spacious and airy.
-- Rooms are very quiet; I never heard any sounds from other rooms, nor any sounds from the hallway, with just one odd exception: due to poor soundproofing of bathrooms and plumbing during a recent renovation (according to staff), if someone uses the shower in a room immediately above/below yours, you will hear, in all areas of your room, the sound of running water quite loudly; an odd quirk, but nothing particularly fatal nor even very annoying.
-- Unfortunately, the matter of smelling odors from other rooms at times is a different issue. Several times during my stay, my room was suddenly and unexpectedly invaded by a strong perfume smell emitted from the HVAC system vents. It turned out that the smell was coming from an overly-perfumed guest in a nearby room (she also briefly stank up the hallway at times when she'd walk to and from the elevators). Likewise, a colleague found his room invaded several times by the smell of cigarette smoke wafting into the room via the HVAC vents (another guest was smoking illegally in their room). Staff reluctantly admitted that this happens at times due to periodic occurrence of too-low positive pressure in the hotel's aging HVAC system that at times allows "draft" air exchange between rooms.
-- Temperature control in the room via wall thermostat was excellent; I was able to easefully dial in, and achieve, any room temperature that I desired between 58 degrees and over 87 degrees F.
-- My room was well-furnished and tastefully decorated, and very bright, clean and spacious. Very good for a hotel in San Francisco, where space is tight!
-- Accustomed to the spacious lobbies and large comfy lobby seating spaces of other Kimpton hotels, I was VERY disappointed by the tiny lobby & very limited, cramped and uncomfortable lobby seating space; it felt like the seating area in a Greyhound bus terminal. I've seen better and more plentiful lobby seating in a low-end Holiday Inn. This issue badly needs to be addressed.
-- Mums, the Japanese restaurant in the hotel, was adequate, but not up to the same standard of excellence and service quality that I've come to expect in Kimpton hotels, largely due to the fact that this is one of the few Kimptons where the hotel does not own & operate the restaurant, but rather rents space to the restaurant.