Chef Priscilla
Google
La Scala – Disappointed by the Quality (Not Recommended for Large Parties)
Rated 4 Stars – My Experience: 1 Star
We had dinner at La Scala last night with a large family group of 11, and the experience was a major disappointment. Because of our group size, we were required to order from a fixed menu priced at $80 per person, which included gratuity but not alcohol. We weren’t concerned about the cost—we were hoping for a quality dining experience. What we got felt more like a cheap wedding banquet—rushed, impersonal, and not at all worth the hype.
We had mentioned a food allergy when the reservation was made, but it was never communicated to our server. After several attempts to bring it up, the allergy was finally acknowledged during the second course, and only then was a separate menu brought out. The server apologized and admitted she hadn’t been informed.
We were brought up a spiral staircase to the third floor—even with a guest in our group who had mobility limitations—and seated in a cramped corner of a back room. The service overall was cold and inattentive.
The food was equally underwhelming. The caprese salad had underripe, flavorless tomatoes. The calamari was undercooked. The grilled Caesar was fine but unremarkable. The penne alla vodka was the one standout—well-prepared and flavorful. The chicken parmesan, however, had a sharp, off-putting taste that the chef attributed to “organic eggs.” It didn’t go over well at our table.
Dessert was a shared platter of tiramisu and profiteroles—just one small piece per person.
We also added two bottles of wine ($40 each) and three cocktails, which pushed the total to about $1,200. But again, this isn’t about the money—it’s the lack of quality and care that stood out most.
Would I go back? No.
Would I recommend La Scala? Not at all.
Large groups, especially those with dietary needs, should steer clear.