David N.
Yelp
I'd been wanting to check this place out for ages, but obstacles kept cropping up that prevented a visit from happening. So when my birthday rolled around, I didn't have to think too long about where I wanted to go.
We showed up right on time for our reservation and were immediately shown to a cozy booth right at the front of the restaurant. I'm a huge booth fan, so I was obviously very excited about this development. And as I discovered a little later, the booth-heavy layout means that Le Swan avoids that seemingly pervasive issue of tables being mere inches away from each other. (It felt surprisingly private and intimate, is what I'm trying to say.)
I pretty much wanted to eat everything on the menu, but we wound up getting four dishes:
Smoked Trout Rillette: Holy cow. I knew we were in good hands right from the get-go, because this relatively simple dish knocked my socks right off. Everything about this works, and the huge chunks of smoky fish are completely delicious (and irresistible). I honestly could've eaten just this all night.
Salad Niçoise: I didn't know what to expect from this, mostly because I figured how much could they elevate a salad? The answer is an insane amount. Every single component in this is just a million times better than you'd expect, including the perfectly-cooked jammy eggs and large pieces of raw tuna. The delectable dressing ties the whole thing together perfectly.
Grilled Cheese: I wanted to try something from the Diner side of the menu, so we settled on the Grilled Cheese. This is a really simple dish that's done better than you've ever experienced. Imagine the best grilled cheese sandwich possible and then elevate it by like a million percent and you have this. Just amazing.
Steak Frites: This is the dish I was looking forward to the most. And ironically, it turned out to be my least favorite dish of the night. The fries were amazing and next level, but the steak was pretty run of the mill. We weren't asked how we wanted it cooked, so it wound up arriving at around a medium, which isn't exactly an ideal choice. Also, it was riddled with chewy bits that made it a little unpleasant at times. The seasoning was top-notch, at least.
We were obviously quite full at this point but I couldn't resist getting dessert:
Bananas Foster: We sure chose well because this is one of the best desserts I can recall eating. The ice cream is very tasty, but it's the preparation of the bananas that bowled me over. They're presented with a caramelized, creme brulee-like layer that's just ridiculous in terms of deliciousness. And eaten together with the ice cream... My lord.
I also want to single out the service, which was incredibly helpful and friendly, and the cocktails, which were as delicious as the food. All in all, Le Swan has unquestionably landed at the top of my list of Toronto's best restaurants.