Jeanne P.
Yelp
I really enjoy Liberty Tree, and I think it's an excellent place to reserve if you have a larger group or kids who you are trying to get a decent meal in. You need to get reservations ahead of time to make sure you get a seat. (Using a Disney authorized travel agent helps with this bc you don't have to do the leg work to get the reservation.)
We waited about 15-20 minutes past our reservation time - it seems a lot of people were taking advantage of the AC and refuge from the rain and overstaying their estimated times. But we were seated in a cute area next to a lot of colonial décor and replicas of historical documents everywhere. It's not only charming, but it's a fun learning experience for kids.
The concept is "all you care to eat" so if you want additional helpings of anything, they will bring it to you. So it's a fixed price menu. There were only two of us, so honestly, we did not get the value out of it as others will, but we booked it for a specific reason on our trip, and it was fine.
You're in the Frontierland area of Magic Kingdom, so to stick with the America theme, it's a Thanksgiving style meal. You know how you usually eat then have to lie down after a good Thanksgiving meal, yeah, it's the same here - a LOT of food. You'll start with a crazy delicious salad - I mean, we are on the hunt for the dressing recipe. I would have been happy with just that. Then we ordered one regular menu and one plant based one. Both had delicious items a plenty. The regular dish included turkey, gravy, pork, pot roast, dressing, mashed potatoes, a large mac and cheese, and some green beans. The plant based had a plant based "meat" loaf and some other items. Neither of us could eat one plate, so that was a huge waste of food, so again - it is a poor value unless you're bringing a group.
Dessert nearly killed me - an ooey gooey cake with a scoop of ice cream. (I don't know what the plant based option was). I could only eat a few bites of it, so more food thrown away. But WOW, it was so good!
It's not for everyone, but I spoke to some international travelers who loved the idea of a traditional Thanksgiving meal, and again - it's a good value if you have a larger table who maybe will get a couple of helpings of something. But I really enjoyed it. And the cast members working there were extra nice and helpful, and they also understood we were on a time budget needing to get somewhere after we ate.
Enjoy!