Lilly's Pizza Bar

Cocktail bar · Fort Greene

Lilly's Pizza Bar

Cocktail bar · Fort Greene

1

737 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217

Photos

Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null
Lilly's Pizza Bar by null

Highlights

Lilly’s Pizza Bar served up fresh, wood-fired Neapolitan pies with killer cocktails and a friendly, lively neighborhood vibe.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

737 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217 Get directions

lillyspizzabar.com
@lillyspizzabar

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

737 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11217 Get directions

+1 718 360 9553
lillyspizzabar.com
@lillyspizzabar

$$ · Menu

Features

delivery
dine in
takeout
Tap to pay

Last updated

Jul 30, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

NYC Restaurant Closings, February 2023 - Eater NY

"Lilly’s Pizza Bar, a wood-fired pizzeria from the team behind the Black Forest beer garden next door, has permanently closed. Owners Ayana and Tobias Holler announced the decision on Instagram this week and shared plans to reopen a new concept in the space in a couple of weeks." - Luke Fortney

https://ny.eater.com/2023/2/3/23580317/nyc-restaurant-closings-february-2023
View Postcard for Lilly's Pizza Bar

Alexandra Zieminski

Google
Great new pizza bar! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable, the drinks are tasty and come out fast, and the pizza is fresh and hot. I highly recommend sitting at the bar so you can watch the drinks be made and have a view of the pizza oven in the corner. The Shishito peppers were delicious and the margarita pizza is a great choice. Evan the bartender made an awesome rhubarb sour, and the espresso martini is delicious especially when made with Mezcal.

Marvin A

Google
Really good Neopolitan-style pizza. Unlike others, we have had really good experience. Pizza is great and arrived at reasonable time. We’ve been here twice and it hasn’t let us down. Really glad it’s close to our place :)

Ali Zie

Google
Best panna cotta I’ve EVER had— Nik the chef did an excellent job with this smooth and lightly sweet dessert. Tom the bartender is knowledgeable about drink as and was able to suggest a couple different cocktails that I might like & they ended up being delicious

Marcus Hazelrig

Google
Great Service, Great Atmosphere. The bartender was amazing and helpful. The app was not working for me and she made sure that I still had a seamless experience. I’m glad this spot is in the neighborhood.

Der Joggel

Google
Lovely small Pizzabar with a very nice ambience and very yummy pizzas, that are a fusion out of Brooklyn and Italian style. The crew is very polite and fast.

Ashley DeTar Birt

Google
Pizza was decent, service was bad. I was the only one sitting at the bar when I arrived and essentially got ignored by the bartender. When someone else arrived, he paid her a ton of attention, making conversation and drinks, to the point that he left my pizza (which took over twenty minutes to come during a slow period) sitting on the counter for over five minutes because he was so consumed with this other person. When I left, I had to flag him down to pay and then he turned right back to ignoring me, going as far as to leave the machine used to pay with me and not saying a word. Honestly, there's gotta be a nicer (in every sense) place to get pizza. The taste was good, but not so good as to overcome the service.

Laura S

Google
We had our going away party last night in their backyard with 16 of our friends and it was the absolute best experience! The pizza was crazy good and the cocktails were refreshing and delicious. The staff was so nice and the owner Tobias was very patient with me answering all my questions ahead of time. I honestly think the pizza/service is far superior than that other place close by that recently opened. Everyone had the best time!

Elena Perito

Google
We love Lilly’s! The pizza is delicious and the staff is lovely. The on tap Negroni is amazing! Happy hour is totally a steal ($35 for a pizza and a bottle of wine). The pizzas are personal sized but super tasty, normally we each get one ☺️