Nicole C.
Yelp
I had above average expectations when I dined at Lilo purely because I've had such surprisingly wonderful prior experiences at Jeune et Jolie. I don't normally like to leave a critical take, but it seems like the Lilo team is still trying to find their footing and I hope my feedback might be helpful to anyone who is open to it.
I've spent a lot of my life dining around the world so my take is likely more critical than the average person, and I tend to favor the flavors of the food / drinks over asthetics and ambiance.
To start the physical location, plating / presentation of dishes, and atmosphere are wonderful. For some, the setting itself will likely elevate their overall experience as it is truly a beautiful space; my only real comment is to please reduce the noise of the music. I had seen some reviews saying it was loud and I thought it could just be nit-picking but honestly it was so loud I actually had a hard time talking to my partner to my side, and it was really difficult to hear anyone that came to present the next dish. I normally never make comments on noise levels but the music at Lilo was so loud it really took away from the space.
To the food, this is where Lilo really disappointed me. I'm not sure if people think of it much, but I find tasting menus to be kind of like an experience at a symphony. You have your start, build ups and breaks in between, your peak, and then a wind down. There's a general cohesion to a tasting menu and Lilos tasting menu was really a whiplash experience in flavors. Constantly there were dishes that were crisp, light, and refreshing followed by really rich, and savory dishes all throughout the entire experience.
On top of this, the entire menu weirdly leaned really sweet. I have a bias as I don't personally prefer deserts or overly sweet things, but I really thought it was alot. Some examples, there was a fish dish paired with this light lemon custard foam sauce and the sauce itself was a few sweet notes from being on a potential desert. Another one was a main squabble dish came with a really sweet reduced berry sauce that could have been put on a desert.
There were a alot of sauces used throughout the entire menu, and I thought all the sauces masked or overpowered the beauty of the great ingredients they were working with. If they could find a way to tone down the sauces to serve as a standalone but very complimentary component of the dishes, I think that could go a long way.
We had the nonalcoholic pairing and it was generally good but as projects a little spotty. They are doing some really creative things on the nonalcoholic front, and it was great to see the use of tea. For nonalcoholic pairings I think the general trend will be a focus on tea as it can become really granular like with wines on sourcing tea leaves, methods used, etc. They also brew their own tonic water in house which is great. As standalone drinks I think the actual nonalcoholic drinks are really creative and delicious, as drink pairings it was generally really nice though spotty. Looking at the alcoholic pairing, we didn't order it but the focus here is California wines with some Sake, and just looking at the menu they are really up charging on the CA wines. The cocktails here are also $30 and while we didn't get any, at those prices it's on average more expensive than even at Kato in LA that has a Michelin rated cocktail program and accolated bar manager.
Lastly the service was nice, though honestly it was inconsistent. Everyone was very nice but I don't really know how to put it, it just felt a little insincere and spotty. There were some that you could just tell were so passionate and lively, and some that really were just checking boxes or were a little robotic.
Overall the bones of an amazing restaurant are here. Lilo has only been open for 7 weeks so there's plenty of time for improvement and I'm sure there are growing pains, but as it was from when we went this was disappointing. One of the appeals of Jeune et Jolie was it was well executed food at a very affordable price point. Lilo isn't cheap, with our nonalchoholic pairing after tax and tip you're looking at around $400 per person, and at those prices you're stating to compare it to restaurants in LA or even Addison in SD.
Hopefully the restaurant improves over time and they take everyone's feedback sincerely. With such a beautiful space and plating presentation, it would be wonderful if Lilo could become a top restaurant destination in the future. As it stands today, there are so many better alternatives at this price point and I wouldn't recommend going to this iteration of Lilo.