Iasantewaa T.
Yelp
The Carrot Cake Ruined It.
I was this close to giving Lindenwood Diner a full five stars. Like hand hovering over the screen close. And then... the carrot cake happened.
Let me start with the good because there is a LOT of good here. I went twice in the past two weeks because I try my best not to judge a place off one visit. Consistency matters. And baby, Lindenwood Diner is consistent.
The Seafood Scampi is a must. Fresh clams, muscles, a good portion of crab with claws included. It's that girl period!
The char grilled burgers awesome as well. Juicy, seasoned, cooked how you ask.
The salad with the homemade French dressing is elite. I need that recipe.
The coffee is endless, as diner coffee should be.
The fried shrimp and the fish and grits were okay, not life changing but quality and solid.
Everything is made to order and came out fresh. I also like that the menu is very diverse and inclusive.
Customer service also deserves a shout. We had a small hiccup and the manager fixed it immediately. No attitude. No excuses. Just solutions. Love that.
Now... the cake.
I was literally walking out, minding my business, when I saw another patron eating the carrot cake. It looked GOOD good. So I doubled back like, let me grab a slice. Big mistake.
The cake tasted like a boxed spice cake pretending to be carrot cake.
The frosting did not taste like cream cheese frosting.
And the shredded carrots on the outside felt like a costume, not an ingredient as the cake itself was plain.
It was simply not the carrot cake I was hoping for and for 9 bux, I was a bit let down.
If you have a sweet tooth, do yourself a favor and order the pineapple coconut cake or the strawberry cheesecake and leave the carrot cake exactly where it is.
That said, parking is free, portions are big, service is great, and everything else absolutely hits. So yes, four stars. Because if that carrot cake had minded its business, this would have been a clean five.