John L.
Yelp
Ambiance is fine, especially toward the back of the house, and the server was friendly and attentive. Unfortunately, the food was disappointing overall.
The beet salad was very sweet and hardly contained any beets. It was a few large chunks of what tasted like provolone cheese (?), a lot of large sweet red grapes, and a few chunks of beets, all mixed in with mostly red cabbage and a sweet dressing. I appreciate the deviation from the usual beets with goat or blue cheese, but this just wasn't very tasty.
The fried artichokes were the best item of the night, but even then it was just a bit underwhelming. We liked the whipped creamy cheese and green sauce, and the artichoke was fine. But overall, kind of bland, though tasty enough.
The pastas were both disappointing as well, especially considering this is their speciality.
- Papardelle with beef short rib had a lot of potential. Soft meat that falls apart on the fork. But the meat and sauce were very salty and the sauce was like greasy gravy and the noodles were too firm and stuck together in clumps. (note to the chef: check out the similar dish at Montelupo)
- The veggie lasagne looked great and was probably the second best thing we ordered, but it was also just bland like the artichoke. Not terrible, but not delicious.
And that really just kind of sums up our experience - not terrible, but not delicious. We're Italian food snobs - even though we recognize that Italian food can be very pedestrian while still being amazing (e.g. a great spaghetti and meatballs, perfectly made garlic bread, etc.).
And Italian food is supposed to ultimately be undeniably delicious even when it's basic - rich, savory, creamy, herbacious, cheesy, etc. The problem most of us have at Italian restaurants is NOT gorging ourselves on the food even though we're full. Not so for us, at least, at Gumba.