Little Italy of St Lucie

5* for everything at Little Italy today. Service, cleanliness, food, atmosphere and everything else Cathy Was our server. She was so nice. We ordered 3 slices of pizza and a side of fries. The pizza is so good. Lots of imitators down here but little Italy has a good slice. Thanks for a great lunch

I just had a delivery and my appetizers were in a bag on top of the pizza box. After the driver left, and I opened up the pizza box & the weight of the bag on top pushed the lid into the center of the pizza, lifting off all the toppings and getting them stuck to the top lid of box. I contacted the driver and he said that is the same way they gave it to him to deliver. Tried calling the pizzeria and it just goes into a computerized system loop. No way to get a human being on the phone. Their food is very good, but the fact that you cannot contact them if there is a problem is unacceptable.

The waiter named Andrew was respectful and welcoming. The food was amazing! I swear the pizza tastes like Brooklyn pizza. The Chicken Alfredo and garlic knots was yummy as well!

Stopped there today to enjoy some pizza. This restaurant is amazingly consistent with the superior quality of their food. I try to go here at least once a week. I have never had a bad meal with any item I have ordered. The staff is always happy and polite. Nothing fancy for the interior but the quality goes into the food. Do not miss trying this place.

We’ve been looking for an Italian place since we moved to Florida. This place is pretty decent. We were concerned after reading the reviews. They are all over the place. We’ve been there twice and I understand why the reviews range so widely. The first time we were there we had a great server. The food was amazing and we had a great time. The second time we had another server who was not so friendly and was nowhere to be found and the food was wasn’t as good as the first time. I will definitely be going back because it is the best Italian food we have found so far and give it another try.

Awesome food. The server was amazing. I needed dairy free and he made sure my shrimp were grilled in olive oil only. Salad was huge. Delicious 😋😋😋😋😋 Everyone at our table was extremely satisfied. Large servings. You definitely get your money's worth! I highly recommend!

I tried ordering a pizza by calling the phone number listed, but it was impossible to get through. I finally managed to place my order through their AI system for pickup. When I arrived, there was only one girl working the counter — she was clearly overwhelmed, and the line was long and slow-moving. I asked an older gentleman with white hair if someone could help her, and he rudely said, “No way.” I ended up waiting 45 minutes just to be treated with attitude by the girl behind the counter, who seemed frustrated and uninterested in helping. The other employees just stood around, showing no concern for customers waiting. Although the food itself was good, the customer service was terrible. The lack of organization, support, and basic courtesy made the whole experience frustrating. I won’t be returning, but I felt it was important to share this experience.

By far one of the best restaurants I have ever been to in FL in 10 years of traveling here. The service is unlike any other restaurant. Finally it felt like pre pandemic service. The owner is the sweetest man and truly cares. Our waitress was so sweet and on top of our family of 5 needs. The food was incredible! Came out so fresh and hot. I think we ordered a couple dozen garlic knots for my son who is the pickiest eater, plus pasta plus pizza slice for him haha. The food has so much flavor. The prices are beyond fair. I wish we had this back home in UT. Highly highly recommend. We are going back for another round before heading home!

Best pizza in town and on Thursdays it's half price pizza!. Toppings only 1.99 for a full pie. Clean restaurant, very friendly staff. You have to try it!

Stopped there today to enjoy some pizza. This restaurant is amazingly consistent with the superior quality of their food. I try to go here at least once a week. I have never had a bad meal with any item I have ordered. The staff is always happy and polite. Nothing fancy for the interior but the quality goes into the food. Do not miss trying this place.

Great food and great service I went for a late lunch and ordered an entree The seve gav me excellent advice, so Far ordeed the chicken parmigiana. The entree came with a healthy pasta fagoli soup, arlic lots wre also included The chicken was so tender it must have ben tenderized well Enough food for 3 meals for me. The restaurant was also considerate about my service dog

Upon our arrival the waiter got our 6 menus which included the early bird special then proceeded to seat us. We placed our order from the early bird menu which he seen us looking at. I proceeded to ask about the dessert waiter said if we wanted to see the menu again I said what comes with the special he said that we arrived after the special. Why did he seat us & give us the early bird menus. His answer was the menus were already on the table that was a lie. Next day I called to speak with the manager was told to speak with a team leader manager was not there. Explained my problem left my number 7 days later still no phone call. Paid double the amount. Very disappointed. Be aware

Ok so this restaurant was on a recommendation and I wasn't expecting a whole lot since it's only 3-3 1/2 stars! Boy was I blown away!! We went during the prix fix menu time and let's see for 14.95 we got and entree, salad, garlic knots and ice cream for dessert all with a glass of wine or soda!! Really? That explains why the restaurant was packed and everyone looked stuffed!! My wife got the chicken parm dinner and I got the spaghetti and meatballs!! By far the best chicken parm she's had since leaving NY!! My spaghetti and meatballs was amazing!! We finished the night with our ice cream and a slice of amazing cheesecake!! I was blown away and scratching my head how this restaurant isn't 5 stars!! Our service was great, food amazing and the price you just can't beat! Can't wait till we go back!!

We have eaten here about 10x .The Food is Always Consistently Delicious. We have tried A few different Pizzas and Eggplant dishes . Salads are very nicely made and always fresh . We have been served by a bunch of different waitresses and waiters and they are all friendly , helpful and clean people . Nice , Clean Family style business with a Great Menu and Great Food ..I would recommend trying a Calzone.

Food quality was excellent. Service was prompt made good recommendations. I had the chicken franchase and my wife had the Veal. Both were tender and came with angel hair pasta. Will definitely go back.

Great pizza, one of the top three in the area- any entre I tried was always good, especially the Veal with Spaghetti. Prices very reasonable, service friendly. Would definately recommend Little italy.

First off it was so hot in there and we waited 25 minutes outside for a table inside . The waitress took forever to come to our table. Brought the wrong dressing for my friend. Never checked on us to see if we needed any drinks or napkins etc. We had to get up and asked for the bill, waitress never came to get our bill. Not a good dining experience at all.

Never disappoint's Boom forget about it!!! hot wings and Monday night football from LIR

terrible tasting sauce just tasted salt. No tomato. Last time. I was there was a year ago ordered a dinner delivered for Mother's Day. Very disappointed the same disappointing source on the pizza was the same source they used in their appetizers eggplant good quality ingredients. terrible sauce, salt if you're a salt lover, this place is for you.

I ordered baked ziti tonight..it had ZERO cheese in it. It was penne pasta w/ sauce. Not ziti AT ALL. Feel cheated for what they charged. Never going by back.

Orders are always made promptly, food is consistently good, and serving sizes are generous.

Just ate there a few days ago the food was awesome they gave you plenty I would bump this up to four stars four and a half easily

Delicious food and great service. I highly recommend the fettuccine Alfred. the sauce is so thick, rich and flavorful. Better than most fancy Italian resturants.

Just had dinner and again it was AMAZING!!! The dinner portions are enough to get your belly full and leftovers for another dinner. Michael & Kenny are top notch they both are very attentive and very knowledgeable of the menu. We Will come back again and again and again J&G

Two members of our family ate there and brought to-go home for me. Overall, they said the food was good, but the service was awful, as if the staff did not want to be there. I had the stuffed shells, with house salad and garlic knots. I would have had some fried ravioli too if the waitress had filled the to-go order correctly. So, my family ended up paying for an appetizer that did not make it in the to-go bag. The shells were good, not great, but good, cooked perfectly with some nice sauce. I would have liked maybe a little bit more flavor, but generally, I liked it. The garlic knots were delicious. The house salad was very small, though fresh. Is the good food worth putting up with bad service? We are not sure about that right now, but if we go back, we are going to make sure to open up the takeout containers before paying our check!

We were so pleased on a Saturday night to order from this great little spot. We ordered two pizzas which were amazing. Very thin crust with a great flavor. We also ordered Chicken Francaise dinner, a chicken Marsala dinner and a Chicken parmesan dinner. They were delicious, hot and accompanied with salads and soups. The Garlic Knots were so darn yummy. Thank you for a Great family dinner that I didn't have to cook. We will most definitely be back. Also your gal that took our order did a fabulous job. Patti

What the hell can a pizzeria is this? This is worse than Sal's pizza, bro. What the hell not they're not real Italians. They suck at making pizza. In my opinion and what the hell I ordered a large cheese pizza. I got a pepperoni man. But I'm not mad just disappointed.

Good food.. best pizza around, the small pie a good value. Also liked their Veal Cutlet. Easy to get to, and park

This place started out strong. Super sweet waitress and glorious smells. Out garlic knots were a little too garlic flavored, but I love garlic - so no complaints from me. The fiancé has to split them in half. Our entrees were a little disappointing. The veal Marsala was extremely salty. Almost too salty to eat. It was like condensed soup poured over tough veal. And noodles. Very strange. My Alfredo was bland. But a little salt, pepper, and garlic fixed that right up. It was a huge portion made With spaghetti noodles - not fettuccini. Again. strange but edible. The cost of the food was about $17.00 a plate. For that price there was something off with the quality. I don't know about the pizza. Good service/weird food.

My first review with them was in May, please see below to see it. Today, we got a large plain cheese pizza, Fried calamari, steak sandwich and garlic rolls. Everything was phenomenal . Their sauce is out of hand. Real tomatoes and not sugary or sweet.. sooo good. Their food is just amazing. Home made and authentic. The only thing that wasn't excellent was the calamari portion. Although, the taste of the calamari was excellent, but there were only about 10 rings and they were very small. Feel bad even saying that because everything else was exquisite. Delivery was exceptional as well. They updated us every few minutes and were professional and kind. Every experience I have had with the delivery and Little Italy restaurant is amazing. Love this place. So far our best experience in Port Saint Lucie. This was my review from May 2022. Just ordered from here with trepidation bc the reviews are all over the place. But there is no doubt about it, this place is fantastic. Pasta not being overly inundated with sauce is true Italian (I'm originally from New York). This was so good. Everything was fantastic. Pasta and meatballs and pasta bolognese was perfect. Sauce was not sweet it was savory and phenomenal . The kid's chicken nugget dinner was real pieces of chicken breast wonderfully breaded with Italian breading. Please note the kids dinner does NOT come with fries. Slightly disappointed bc the picture shows fries, but overall not a big deal. The garlic knots were crispy outside and soft on the inside-- loved them. My mother loves the house side salad and she typically complains about the take out salads from anywhere. We just moved here from Vero and are elated that we found this place!!!! Will be back!!

RUDE MANAGER: I ordered a large sausage and pepperoni pizza with ricotta for delivery, which I've ordered on many occasions from this place with no complaints. In the past, this pizza was one of my favorites. However, something drastically changed in the way they make this pizza because tonight I got a horrible, wet, doughy pizza that I couldn't even pick up a slice from because it just just drooped like a wet paper towel and all the toppings began falling off. This soggy mess wasn't at all like the pizza I had ordered in the past. To make matters worse, the manager on duty when I called around 6:30pm-9:30pm was very rude and unprofessional. I did t expect to be treated like that after I had explained the problem to him in a respectful and calm manner. He told me there was nothing wrong with the pizza since he checked it himself. After much push back, he offered to remake the pizza and deliver it to me. I couldn't believe it. The second pizza was just as soggy as the first. So, I gave it back the first and second pizza to the delivery driver and asked if he could tell the manager to credit my credit card and call me to confirm. I never got a call back. So, I called back and before I could get a word out he said my first name and said that they were closed. Despite his rudeness, I politely asked if he could give me a refund. He refused because he said he gave me two pizzas and only charged me for one. I reminded him that I returned both pizzas. I even told him that I asked the delivery driver's opinion if he would take a pizza like this home to his family and that he said he'll no, I'm a New Yorker and that ain't good pizza... you can't even fold it, recalling seeing me struggle while trying to pick up a slice in front of him and witnessing the same thing over my ring cam. The manager instead told me he heard different from the delivery guy, that nothing was wrong with it. He ended with telling me he would not refund me because in his words I had torn the pizza apart when all I did was try to pick up a slice for me and my daughter and put it back. Then he said he would not be able to process a refund because their systems were shut down anyways and I would need to call back to speak with the next higher up and that he doubted I would gain agreement from him as well since the refund had to be done the same day. I'm thinking this is just ludicrous how I was being treated. He ended with offering me an 18 inch pizza good for 90 days. I told him fine because I had taken enough abuse and was still hungry from not having dinner.

Just moved to Port St. Lucie , I saw an ad in the local magazine for free delivery, and 16 inch $11.99 cheese pizzas. Wasn't expecting a lot since I didn't know anything about Little Italy and was so pleasantly surprised that the pizzas were crispy, the sauce was delicious, and the mozzarella tasted fresh and was plentiful. I grew up in New Jersey so I know good pizza. This is some of the best I've had since I've moved to Florida, and I have lived in several places here and eat a lot of pizza. I will definitely be a regular and order these 16 inch pizzas with free delivery on a regular basis. It's nice to find something close to home that is so awesome!

We came to this restaurant because we have a coupon. It's under a new management and the place apparently has brightened up considerably. As this is our first visit, we cannot make any comparison. So, onto the menu we go! There's plenty to choose from. Eggplant Parmigiana is a favorite of ours in all Italian restaurants and we use it as a marker to know if a restaurant is worthy of more visits. I had the Chicken Cacciatore which is delicious! The huge portions are enough for another meal. Bread is dripping with a cheesy butter. Prices are reasonable. We'll be back and we'll try the pizza next time. And we'll bring guests, too.

Oh wow! I asked for a side of sausage with onions peppers and marinara sauce not grease! Shame on them!

I'm starting with the negative. Paying by credit card is a norm. Normally the business pays the credit card company, usually 3%, for this privilege. However, this establishment, is now passing this on to the customer so they don't have to pay the credit card company. As a credit card holder, we pay the credit card company which ensures that the restaurant will be paid. The restaurant in turn pays this 3% for use of the card to ensure they will get their money. But this business is not paying this fee but they are passing it on to the customer. This is not right and probably goes unnoticed by customers. This upcharged price is not on the menu but it will show as a higher price on your bill. If you pay with cash, this "up charge" is removed. This of just wrong. With that said, the food here is fabulous. Better than home cooked by Nonna. Food portions are plentiful. Seafood is fresh and cooked perfectly. Calamari was lightly fried and the sauce it is served with is a rich tomato, warm & well seasoned. Clams are served whole, not chopped up as is usual. Pasta is perfectly Al dente. Garlic knots were with a nice crispy crunch on the top and not over saturated with oil and garlic. It was perfect! House Chianti was excellent. Our server Caroline was attentive, energetic and personable. Manager Hannah was efficient and personable. I highly recommend for food and service. Major disappointment is that management infused hidden fee and passes them on to the customer. For this reason, we will likely not return regularly as hoped.

Has great food, service and ambiance but don't go here if your kiddo needs a high chair they only have one for the entire restaurant!

Absolutely loved it here! Service was a little slower, but the food and the friendliness of the staff was phenomenal! Definitely coming back for more soon!

We had a few appetizers they were garlic, knots, and bruschetta. Very flavorful there was five of us, and we each had different meals. I had the meatball Parm cooked to perfection. Another guest had the veal Parmesan again very pleased. Another shrimp Fra Diablo, so good. Our server Michael was very accommodating. Restaurant was clean and nicely decorated. It had a certain spark of the hometown Italian feel.

Great place for pizza closest to New York style, me and my family have made this our go to pizza spot now that we have officially settled in PSL. We love the service and the atmosphere is always sweet and everyone is very accommodating! Love it here for a good delicious and very tasty meal!

Wow! Food was phenomenal, everything I order always tastes so fresh and the service was impeccable. The manager Hanna is such a bright presence in this place and always made sure I was taken care of! 5 Stars!

It's a hit or miss. First time we went we enjoyed the eggplant parmigiana and chicken parmigiana. Second time we went my salad was brown, the bread was undercooked and the tomato sauce was bitter.

Ordered the Chicken Parm lunch special, paid only $8.49. For the value and portion, it's totally worth the price. For the taste, the chicken was breaded and was very good. The pasta was good and sauce was good too. Came with a huge piece of garlic bread. Overall great experience.

We went there the other day. Haven't been there in a long time. New owners. Big difference. I use a walker a was greeted at the door by one of the owners a given a table close to the door. A few minutes later I recognized him as a singer I've seen in various places around town. So! The place was brighter, cleaner, temp was perfect. Service was great. We had Fried Calamari and pizza there. Excellent We took home a Calzone and Stromboli Again Excellent ! Will definitely be returning soon Would not hesitate recommending to anyone. The owner, Roger, said he may do some singing with his daughter. Don't miss it!!

The food was absolutely delicious. But the presentation was horrible. The pizza looked like it was from an amusement parks microwave. BUT... IT TASTED like NY Heaven. Lol I'd say order it. It's yummy. To the store, update your first impression.

So this restaurant is nestled next to Publix. It reminds me of a hole in the wall. Not much signage to really give this place the credit it deserves. This is not my first time here. As you walk in there are about 20 tables. You can see the oven as well. I was greeted almost immediately. I was told about the daily specials. I chose their 2 Slice and a drink for $4.50. The pizza was just as I remembered it growing up in NYC. The slices were big and cheesy Great little restaurant.With some great food and specials. You need to come here and try some of their seafood, in their seafood and pasta. The clams in a white sauce was excellent. The staff is very accommodating and well mannered. Definitely will be coming back here again.

Pizza was banging for Florida pizza! Staff is friendly. Delivery or pick up! Pizzas always fresh! My only pizza place in Florida I'll ever eat at (coming from north end in Boston and from Sicily) this place rocks!!!!

This was not a great experience, ordered a chicken parm sandwich and it took forever, waiter didn't give us forks or napkins, I had to get them. The actual food was just OK. Will not be returning here

Soo happy to share this rating! We enjoyed lunch at Little Italy. My husband had the delicious, freshly made ALFREDO . I had The multi cheese manicotti. The red sauce was excellent and the lunch portion was plentiful. Located next to the Publix @ Bethany & PSL WEST.

Great service, good food, & nice atmosphere. The staff accommodated a table of 8 without a problem. Our server was friendly, very competent, and helped make the meal an enjoyable experience. Recommend!

1st time visiting after reading some great reviews. I had flounder Amandine and my friend had the spaghetti Bolognese. Both dishes were perfectly seasoned, prepared, and were delicious. I loved the side salad presentation in the cute little dishes. My only complaint was, our waitress forgot our garlic knots, so it was a good thing they have huge portions. I will be back and hopefully I will get to try the garlic knots.

Food is delicious meatballs, chicken marsala, penne bolognese and pizzas are so good. The owners are very kind always try to make customers happy. Definitely I will be back!

Food is cold most of the time when served, service is poor since they have chronic staff shortage and ambience is okay. We have given them many opportunities to reveal themselves but we have been disappointed every time! Therefore, we are never going back.

We went to this restaurant after reading the positive reviews on NextDoor and Yelp. Boy, we were impressed!!! The restaurant is spotless, the staff courteous and the food was great! I can't remember if I ever had such well made fried calamari. The calamari was tender and the sauce served w/ it was definitely homemade. We ordered steamed mussels as another appetizer and they were perfect. All of our entrees were delicious and we even went back the following morning to place a catering order for my father in law's 91st birthday. While we were sitting for dinner we watched one of the owners (Roger) stop by every table to make sure his customers were happy. A truly nice man. Roger mentioned his chef was a new hire and every item on the menu is made from scratch - even the dressings for the salad! Besides our catering order, we plan to come back to try their pizza, which looked like real NY Pizza! Give the restaurant a try.

I ordered one Monday the special cheese pizza I guess it's $9. I added extra cheese and extra sauce I told her like a lot of sauce came to 12:20 something. When I picked it up she's opened the box I said that's extra cheese and that's extra sauce she says yes I said really? I asked for some extra sauce on the side I went home underneath the little bit of cheese that was on the pizza was hardly any sauce like a faint residue so that I wasn't giving extra sauce except for a little container on the side and they're definitely wasn't extra cheese the dough was awful. Worst 12 dollars and change I've spent in a long time. Will not go back.

Both food and service are great! Friendly greeting coming in, and a smile and wave leaving. We enjoy dining there. Thanks!

Smells great and the staff is polite! That's where the good stuff ends. Food was BLAND. The stuff in the frozen food aisle next door at Publix tastes better. I'm not being some crazy food snob, it was just hot mush. We ordered the eggplant rolitini and the lasagna. Both weren't good. It included salads and garlic knots. The knots didn't taste good either, and a bit soggy. Salads were salads. 40 min wait time turned into an hour wait time, which they apologized for, and I accept that. But only 6 tables in the place were full. Overheard lots of complaints from time waiting to quality of food. Place seems ripe for an episode of Kitchen Nightmares.

Wait staff terrible and the entire staff are rude,and unprofessional and unpleasant. The food may have improved but not worth the terrible environment. I recommend you find other places for pizza and good food quality